Just A.
Yelp
Petition Kitchen -
Oh dear. If I have to choose between my other oft-stated favourite place in town (starts with a B, ends with a C and has ivoua in between) I might not be able to. This place was a real treat when I visited with two Yelper mates last night. From the very sexy industrial fit out, through to the sound system, the service and the divine food, this place has started out on an high. We shared four plates and one bottle of wine, whilst sipping on the bottomless complimentary still or sparkling water on offer. All up, that lot came to about $140. Outstanding value, considering the customer was awarded the full suite of what I believe constitutes excellent service: quality in all aspects (service, presentation, portion size, decor, comfort, variety and flavour). I couldn't really fault it, but I will admit to disappointment when our initial hottie Italian waiter disappeared to tackle another larger table and we got a [very nice] lass instead. The whole experience had us wanting more (not just the perve factor) and deciding to check out the beer hall and wine bar to kick on.
Petition Beer Hall -
Wowsers, what an interesting place! From the exposed piping, the extraordinary varieties of beverages on offer to the broad expanse of space and the friendly and welcoming staff, we only stopped in to poke around and check it out, but will return to experience it later on.
Petition Wine Bar -
Well, here's where we were disappointed. In a noticeable difference, the service here let the whole business down in our experience of the night. But I'm not going to mark down, because the purpose of our visit - the Kitchen - was excellent. We decided to loiter with intent and continue our night out by sharing another bottle of wine, something different, in the Wine Bar. And perhaps we would consider some cheese or dessert, if available. We weren't greeted as enthusiastically as we were at the other two areas. We ordered a bottle and were poured a glass each, then studiously ignored until any residual in our glasses had long evaporated. We had to beckon for service and by that time, there were only two other occupied tables to at least four staff, who were busy mucking about, dancing to the music and generally ignoring the customers. There had been some confusion with our order and the process. Apparently the wines on the list can only be purchased by the glass and if you wish to order a bottle, you have to go through the vast selection from the shelves and pick it out yourself. I think. I liken it to flicking through the CD's on special at JB Hi-Fi. You lose interest after the first row, unless you know what you are looking for.
We had a discussion and offered a suggestion to add the bottle price on the menu for all those they have listed. Suggestion accepted graciously. A bit of a kerfuffle that was awkward for us about the bottle versus glass situation, although in the end, we were given the remainder of a bottle, after they had scientifically dispensed our equivalent three glasses worth from a new bottle (and overly-explained the process to us, ad nauseum). Don't care. Just give me more wine.
Overall, the experience of checking out the three Petition venues was very positive and I feel that the new Cathedral District is really going to inject some serious competition to nearby venues (including the Brookfield Place district). I understand the Kitchen is operating for dinner on a booking-only policy initially. I highly recommend booking and experiencing the Kitchen with some friends, so you can order a larger variety of dishes and really enjoy the offerings. In saying that, I feel that solo diners would also enjoy the venue as some of the plates are small, to promote both sharing and variety. I would not hesitate to dine there alone.