Stephanie L.
Yelp
Hands down the best Italian food I had on a recent Chicago trip! We were staying nearby in the area and decided to try Nonnina since it was close-by, and I'm so glad we did. We were able to get seated immediately as a party of 3 on a Saturday around 11am. The restaurant interior is pretty large, with both a more intimate indoor section and a livelier patio section. We ate in the patio, and it was very well decorated and also well heated on a cold and windy day.
Our server was very helpful in recommending dishes, since it was our first time here, and we mainly ended up following their recs. We got the prosciutto-caprese and chopped salads, squid ink spaghetti and bucatini pastas, and the prosciutto & arugula pizza. This was A LOT of food for 3 people. Everything tasted delicious! Both salads were very well dressed, but the prosciutto-caprese was more interesting flavor wise (and very well plated). Of the 2 pastas, I enjoyed the bucatini more - it had great truffle flavor, but mixed with the egg yolk the pasta felt quite heavy in my stomach. The squid ink spaghetti was yummy as well, with brighter flavors and slightly spicy. The prosciutto & arugula pizza was probably the most standard dish, but very well done, with a thin and crispy crust.
There was a promotion for Mother's day when we dined here, so we were able to get a free slice of tiramisu for dessert. It tasted very authentic and was very well soaked in coffee. Very nice of them to have such an offer for mothers! Service was impeccable on our visit, all our needs were taken care of promptly and in such a friendly manner. Overall bill came out to around $160, which was pretty pricey, but seemed fair given that this is a bit more upscale place, and the food quantity & quality as well as service was amazing. Will definitely be back on my next Chicago visit!