Pie Whole Pizza

This place definitely needs to have more than one server working at a time, as the service is super slow (even slower than the usual island time at other local places). After forgetting our drinks and then have us wait for 45 minutes for a large pizza, my husband and I were given a personal pizza to share and told they could take it away and have us wait to make a whole new one or we could just share the small personal pizza. We shared the pizza, which had crust that was so hard it wouldn’t break even hitting it across a plate and tasted nothing like pizza. We were still required to pay the 18% gratuity. We left and got an awesome dinner elsewhere after.

Hate to post a bad review, but got takeout and our pizza was totally nuked. Wasn’t that busy so it couldn’t have been overlooked, but disappointed. Tried choking down a few slices because it was late and we were hungry, but not great.

We absolutely loved the food here—every bite was delicious! The pizzas were fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. On top of that, the servers were incredibly friendly and accommodating, making the whole experience even better. Definitely a must-visit spot if you’re in St. Thomas!

The pizza dough is pre-baked. They had a stack of them by the prep station. Probably the worst pizza I have ever had. They got the toppings wrong and took it back replaced it with the correct ones and just covered it up with a ton of cheese. Very disappointed. The tables and benches are falling apart and are loose. The floor is lifting when the table is rocking back and forth. I was extremely embarrassed to have taken someone there

We were totally shocked at how good the food was! Their marinara sauce is honestly the best I’ve ever tried. Very kind and friendly staff and owners. Highly recommend

This was one of the only places open on New Years Day. The staff were kind and helpful. The pizza I’m sorry to say is meh at best. I would never eat here again as long as other options are available.

Greabbed some pizza to take back to our hotel after a long travel day. Exceeded our expectations, great pizza. The wait was the only downside because they were so busy - a testament to how good it was

This restaurant was walking distance from our hotel and was listed on the map provided by the management. We selected this place for lunch and ordered the hurricane pizza (cooked in a real brick oven) . It was absolutely delicious!... more so than a lot of the dedicated pizza joints in Austin Texas (where we're from) and a lot of other places/cities for that matter. We will be back for dinner as they have several pasta dishes including fettuccine alfredo , stromboli, chicken parmesan, beef or shrimp tacos, wings, and much more. They have a full bar also. The very friendly wait person was personable and attentive. If we lived nearby, we would be regulars here. Prices were very reasonable...more so than some other nearby restaurants. But, MAN!...was that pizza good! [UPDATE] We returned for dinner. I had the stromboli and the wife had the penne arrabbiata. Both were delicious and HUGE portions. We each took half our order home. Sharing is recommended for small to medium appetites. We had a nice Argentinian Malbec along with our entrée. This is a small, low-keyed restaurant well worth your time (and money).

Solid pizza place. We got the meat pie pizza, if you are a meat lover you must get this pizza. It is a thin crust style pizza. The cheese was super melty and the toppings were delish. It is not a big place so if you have a big party it prob won't work. Also the pizzeria is tucked inside this pier like area. Not alot of parking so depending on when u go parking will be a pain much like most places in St. Thomas. The service wasn't super fast but at least it wasn't as slow as the typical island time.

Frenchtown's best pizza place!! Delicious food! Clean and comfortable both indoor and outdoor dining. Full bar. Pleasant staff with good service and great prices. Definitely recommend and will always come back here.

Super friendly small little restaurant with a full bar and nice champagne by the bottle. Staff is awesome and make sure you the dice when you're here!

Please let me start by saying I am a huge fan of the Pie Whole and have recommended them to friends and family through the years. However, todays 53.00 dollar order was unfortunate to say the least. Two large (24.00) pies were ordered and when I saw the finished product I was a little startled. Not only were half the toppings missing but I was also charged for the "to go" box (which is not a charge if you dine in). Needless to say, noticeably smaller pies with less toppings will not retain my business as a customer. When I returned to the office with the order, several people simply changed their mind and ordered food from another restaurant after waiting an hour for me to return with the order. Pie Whole I know you have the capacity to do better, please try a little harder.

Pizza was good, ordered onion rings and received 3 onion rings for 10 dollars! Called to complain, they said " yep that's it" and hung up. Very poor service!

The pizza was amazing and we will definitely be back next time we are in St Thomas! The staff was friendly as well!

Very disappointed. I'll start by saying everyone was very nice. We started by ordering bruschetta. It was mistakenly delivered to the bar, which was right next to where we were sitting. The customer at the bar said it wasn't hers and when saw what was happening so we said it's ours. The three employees (one of whom I believe to be the owner) proceeded to argue over whether the ticket said B8 or Booth 8, who messed it up, and what to write on tickets instead of immediately bringing it to us. When we got it the bread was so overdone it completely broke into pieces on every bite. Then we ordered two small pizzas. One arrived slightly over cooked but the second (all cheese) was severely overcooked. To the point that the person serving it HAD to have known it was burnt and consciously chose to serve it anyway. No need to return.

Absolutely disappointed, from the price to one pizza looking nothing like what was advertised. Food is very expensive on the island so to pay almost $50 for 2 10" pizzas (ten of those dollars was delivery) and it not be enjoyable not what you thought you were ordering was disappointing to say the least. I even requested no onion in the box at the end and what do you see: purple onions smh I'd continue looking around for a more quality pizza.

Got takeout from pie whole last week while in st Thomas. Yelp says they're open until 10, but google says 9. We showed up at 8:30 and we're told they were no longer seating guests, but they would allow us to order for takeout. We did not mind at all because we were actually talking about eating pizza right by the beach-- it was a win win! The pizzas are really thin, so definitely order more and/or bigger than you usually would. Personally, I ate like 4 slices, which is a lot more than I normally would. The taste was amazing... can't remember the names of the pizzas we ordered, but I'm sure whatever you get there will be awesome. Highly recommend!

Pizza was average and service very slow. Went mid day and wasn't busy at all. Had to go inside to get the check

Amazing pizza so delicious. Michelle provided excellent service very attentive and accurate. She also makes the best rum punch - a must try!

3.5 stars. Pizza here is ok. Service is really solid, super friendly (but then almost everyone is in the USVI!). Sat inside at bar where the AC is working vs. outside.

We asked best appetizer and was told the garlic bread. When it arrived cold we tried to eat it and they garlic was so strong we spit it out. I really needed a coke to wash it down but the cup was a small tumbler full so I didn't have any extra cause she said maybe he would give me a refill . The pizza was $27 and the size of an American small. It was also cold. It took it forever. This was our first meal on the island and so disappointing!

Service was awesome. Owner really nice. Made sure we had everything we needed. The Pizza crust was extremely thin, which seems to be standard in the USVI, but I liked it. We sat outside on a very nice night. It turns out that of the 4 nights we ate dinner they were all in "French Town".

OK, read this one with a grain of salt. We're from NYC people. In a word, we are the "worst" when it comes to pizza. We're beyond pizza snobs. We're downright pizza obnoxious. So for us, while this might be the best on the island, it was slightly above edible for us. Eh... forget my review. I'm sure you'll enjoy it just fine.

Owner attitude awful Cold food Then a snarky owner saying sorry But not meaning a word Any self respecting restaurant would have competed the food after sending it back twice which is just plain embarrassing

Your gonna have to shut your pie hole fully shut if you have something bad to say about this places pizza. Crispy crust, tasty sauce. Fantastic pizza

Our first stop in St Thomas - very close to the airport. The owner and staff were 10/10 in conversation and food was 12/10. We got so many recommendations for what to do while here - we are literally on our way back now!

Killing time before going to airport and stopped her for lunch. WOW! Outstanding pizza and staff. Food was great and staff very helpful. Highly recommend. One note- Yelp had them opening at 11am but they open at noon.

Each time we come to the island, we go here. They have the best pizza I've ever had. The fettuccine Alfredo is surprisingly wonderful and also the best ever! This small unpretentious eatery in the French quarter of Charlotte Amalie is a must-do. The service is friendly, courteous, and thankful for the business. I just can't say enough about this great spot. The only drawback is that we can't get to St Thomas often enough to enjoy this gem.

One of the best thin crust pizzas I've had. Got the mushroom pepperoni and it was delicious. Didn't get the waiters name but pretty sure he was both cook and waiter as I noticed he was the only one in there. Very nice guy, friendly, and attentive. Plan on coming g back during our trip.

The Pie Whole serves the best pizza we have had in a very long time! Great variety of toppings and delicious. Elizabeth, the owner, is also very welcoming, making sure everyone is taken care of. You can either dine indoors or outside on the patio. NOT TO BE MISSED when you are in St. Thomas!

First night in st. Thomas, parking was a challenge, but worth it! Tried the eggplant appetizer, amazing. Hubs had pizza and I had a lovely salad. Great service, nice vibe, indoor and outdoor seating. Great experience

Everyone was extremely friendly and the service/food/ambiance was awesome. They gave me great travel tips for the area and when I didn't have any internet connection and needed to access my Airbnb, they even went out of their way to let me use their phone. By far the best experience I've had with any restaurant!

The hours posted online are not correct. We weren't able to go because they are supposed to close late, but when we came at 4:30pm they were closed. Double check before you make the drive!

My heart is beating fast. I've been waiting to have a free moment to write this review about Pie Whole Pizza ever since I returned from St. Thomas 2 weeks ago. Like in the 80's classic movie, The Goonies....when the little crying boy Chunk, is about to have his hand forced in a blender by the villains unless he details everything....all the truth and all the details.....well.....after coming to this place.....I honestly felt like crying (in a sad way). And I want to spill all the details about the WORST SERVICE!!! Yes here, at Pie Whole Pizza I received the WORST SERVICE EVER!!!! And....I have traveled all over. I've been all around the world and now this place ranks....by far.....without a doubt.....the worst restaurant and food experience I have ever witnessed. Yeah, let's just say at the end of me waiting 30 minutes and being COMPLETELY IGNORED, I walked out. It was that simple. I guess this place saw me, my appearance, or whatever, and decided not to serve me and ignore me. How sad. Words can't even describe how dejected I felt. I mean, I wasn't some homeless St. Thomas local. It was so obvious that I was a tourist. Why wouldn't they serve me? I didn't do anything wrong! Now I need to get into detail. Before I do.....like I've seen other Yelpers vent about how places have deserved zero stars.....I used to think how bitter they were..... Now I understand! Of course it's now my time to unleash fury about how Pie Whole Pizza deserves zero and negative stars! Have I mentioned yet it was the WORST EXPERIENCE IN MY LIFETIME!!!!???? I was in the mood for pizza, just something easy and casual after spending an entire day at St. John and Virgin Islands National Park appreciating the scenic surroundings. After getting off the ferry about 7pm on a Sunday evening I immediately headed here to Pie Whole Pizza. I was wearing shorts, a t-shirt, baseball cap and sneakers (without socks) as I knew I wasn't going back to my hotel to shower up. It was too late. I was grabbing a quick bite here and then calling it a night. As I approached Pie Whole Pizza, there were a few folks sitting outside under the cabana. They all looked just like me. Just straightforward people having pizza!!! I walked inside and no one cared to sit me. The restaurant had a few tables and chairs and a small bar area. I made eye contact with a waitress and asked her if I should seat myself? She said yeah, wherever. Since I wasn't drinking alcohol, I avoided the bar and grabbed a two person table. Overall, the atmosphere was quite laid back. Nothing fancy. Btw, I was alone by myself....just to give exact detail. Well, the restaurant wasn't even busy. There were open tables and some people eating outside. Yet, the waitress walked past me countless times. She did not care. She avoided me. I waited like 15 minutes and finally a busboy handed me a menu!!! Finally, a menu! And he asked if I wanted a drink. Okay here we go! I said a Coke please. Well, there you have it. For the next 15 minutes the busboy never returned with my Coke and he didn't even glance at me. Yet, he walked back and forth around avoiding me like I had the plague. The waitress never came to serve me. But here was my ultimate boiling point.... Within the first 15 minutes, people came inside and sat at the bar and the bartender happily served them. I thought too bad, I just should have sat at the bar as well. Unfortunately I chose a table. But then.... 3 more people came in together and they sat down next to me. And here I was still waiting for the waitress or busboy to come over to me so I could simply place my order for a large pizza pie!! And....hmmm....you think I'm not a good tipper?? I would have been the easiest order ever! And I tip wonderfully!! Too bad, such stupid idiots here that don't care! So....just sitting and staring, waiting for anyone, the bartender then came from behind the bar and started taking the order from the 3 people who just sat down next to me! What?? And he did it so friendly. And without even looking or giving me the time of day! At this point I accepted my fate and just gave up. I walked out and didn't make a fuss. I didn't cause commotion. I just let it go. But why? What did I do wrong? I'm such an easy going, friendly person. I'm approachable! I cannot recall being so discouraged ever in my life. Oh well, I sucked it up and moved on to another restaurant. Just what a waste of at least 30 minutes to not even have had the chance to be served! It was so evident I WAS NOT WANTED IN THE RESTAURANT! They weren't even busy! This story doesn't even really begin to describe how unthinkably IGNORED I was. The bartender looked like he could have been the owner/manager. Wow how ruthlessly inconsiderate...I'm certain in the end, what goes around will come around.... And as I think back and reflect on this miserable experience that took place to me here at Pie Whole Pizza, I can easily say.....I want to vomit real hard. Barf, yak, puke, hurl!!!!!!!!

We wanted a casual lunch spot near the seaplane terminal and we found the perfect place at Pie Whole! Their freshly made pizzas satisfied our pizza craving, and most importantly it came out piping hot. We got their Hurricane pizza, which has a mix of all the meats & veggies - I asked for no mushrooms and they were happy to accommodate! The pizza is a thin crust pizza so not too carb heavy. The cheese melted just enough to make those beautiful strings of cheese as you pull apart each slice. The meats were pretty good too (sausage, pepperoni, etc). It's not a pizza that will change your life (this isn't NYC), but it's a pizza that will leave you full and satisfied!

One of my families favorite spots since visiting Saint Thomas! This pizza is authentic Italian pizza! If you're looking for ooey-gooey over cheesy, basic pizza- this is not your pizza place. This is authentic, high quality ingredients, homemade sauce, trip to Italy pizza. Really good! So good we visited twice in one week! Try to sit outside or get take out- inside is small and can get a bit smoky- but even so it's that good! Great beer list too- we are PNW people snd we love craft beer!

The Pie Whole isn't easy to find, and it's fairly small, but take the time to get there - they serve the best pizzas I've had on St. Thomas. The pizzas are exactly the right size for one very hungry person, or two people just looking for a snack. There isn't much by way of atmosphere, and there isn't any kind of a view, but the service is excellent Bottom line: Not the place to come for an amazing ocean view and you'll have to work to find the place, but if you want really good pizza and some good cold beer then this is your place :-)

Amazing food! Portions were a bit on the smaller scale but nothing beats a thin crusted melted cheesy pizza. We ordered the holy trinity (margarita pizza) and the pollo pesto which were both super delicious.

I am so disappointed that we picked this place for a pizza night. I don't know how our appetizer wasn't put into the kitchen until I arrived to pick up our take out order but she said I could wait until they made it which would be longer than I would want to wait or she could just take it off the bill. I don't know how she knew how long I would have been willing to wait but I didn't elect to. It was a take out order so I shouldn't blame the pizza being cold on the restaurant but it wasn't that far to drive and I can't imagine that it was fresh from the oven even though I had to wait on it. We had the taco pizza and it was unique. Dry, bland, hard tasteless crust, minimal toppings, and most of it went in the garbage. Overall I really can't recommend The Pie Whole and I wish I would have picked something better.

Chicken parm came out cold three times. Owner has the worst attitude. Avg food at best. $7 order of onion rings netted about 6 rings- half of an onion. I'd never go here again. Stay away. To top it off they charged me more for my chicken parm than their menu price shows. I'll be disputing the charge with my Amex.

This place is aaaamaazing! Our bartender Taz was awesome! Liz was always checking to make sure we were having the best time! I felt welcomed and enjoyed all the food and drinks we had! We went there like 3 times on our stay!

We went to Pie Whole they have the Customer Service we did enjoy the pizza it is on the Banner side with the crust which I like but we definitely wet hair twice while we were on vacation I would recommend.

Wow. Damn fine pizzas on the island. I will note that these pizzas are very expensive. You're looking at a starting price around $20, which is high. (That's the only reason for docking a star.) That said, the quality is excellent. I really enjoyed my pepperoni pizza. The leftovers were even good cold, right out of the fridge. The real star is the chewy crust, which is cooked to perfection. They do take a long time to make them, so budget that into your dining plans. While I waited to take the pizzas as carry-out, the folks at the bar offered me water and let me connect to their wi-fi. That was cool. This isn't really a place you want to stay to eat, especially with the gorgeous views afforded by the island. It's really just a cramped, tiny bar that happens to serve amazing pizza. Get your pie to go and enjoy a great view from a balcony somewhere.

Good pizza, friendly service. We actually came here twice during our visit. Awesome beer selection but also plenty of wine to choose from and of course the usual tropical cocktails. Pizzas are very good, thin crust just the way I like it. You can tell they're freshly made and this meal must've been the best deal for our whole trip, it was basically almost 1/3 to 1/2 less than anything else in Frenchtown.

The pizza quality was ok, but for two 14" pizzas for $46 is quite expensive for what my family of 4 got. We were still hungry after sharing those two pizzas. They were also out of the first two toppings we asked for, didn't have any seasonings like parmesean cheese, and didn't give us plates or napkins to take back. I don't see myself coming back any time during my vacation here.

Super friendly owner, originating from Chicago! We loved the pizza and our pasta/salad lunch combo

Worst service of any restaurant on the island. And that is while the owner is on-site working. Tried to go once and waited 40 minutes for a table the hostess didn't even bother seating us (tons of tables empty and we were the only ones waiting), so we left. Went the next day tried to order take out. Ordered on the phone they said ready in 30 minutes. Over 1.5 hours later and I'm still sitting in the restaurant waiting for them to make the food. Order was two simple pizzas. Finally got the pizzas and they messed up the toppings. And the wings are COLD! How in the world is the food cold when they had me wait for 1.5 hours to get the food? Pizza is palatable but nothing great. The only other person ordering take-out came in after me and got 4 completely incorrect pizzas that they had to re make which they said would take minimum of 45 minutes. They were still waiting when I left

6 years later this place is still amazing. Thin crispy pizza you wouldn't expect in the islands. The pasta may be better and the beer selection is awesome. Hopefully won't be another 6 years before we're back.

Ordered for delivery on our arrival night. Great pizza and prompt delivery. There was a delivery charge based on a percentage of the total bill. Very friendly!

Stayed the night at Olga's fancy and stopped by here to get a bite. Had a rum punch and my son had a bushwhacker. We decided on the margarita with added house made sausage. We decided to get the large thinking we would have a couple slices left over. Nope we are the whole thing. Definitely the best pizza I've had on the island. Check them out.

So delicious and right by the ferry! Great appetizer and pizza options - they give you to go boxes that you can bring through the airport!

Used to be our favorite and should be a gold mine but the service is so slow... seems like a spoof on Saturday night live! You order a drink and 20 mins later it comes then they deliver your pizza which has been sitting while the server has slowly walked past it several times and even though your drink is empty he doesn't bother to ask of you would like another. The food except for the temperature is terrific but who wants luke warm pizza? The bathroom trash was over flowing and they were out of paper towels. Come on guys- it's a tiny spot itshould be immaculate and well run! Update we went again the following week because friends invited us- different waiter and totally different experience! This gentleman was efficient and the food was really good. Manager/ owner just needs to train the staff for consistency.

What I like about pie whole is that they are consistent. The food is always good and the service is as well. We always make reservations as the 25 seats including the bar, fill up fast and you'll end up not eating. Pizza is cooked in a hot wood burning oven which is located in the dining room so dress light. It is warm in here no matter how long they run the AC. They have nightly specials which are always fun to try. The ingredients are always fresh and if you like thin crust pizza then you will really like it here. Frenchtown is a great place to spend the evening hopping from place to place. You may stroll down the street for dessert and drinks or just park here for the evening. Either way you have to give this place a try. You won't be disappointed.

What an incredible box! Sturdy, rigid, multi colored corrugated card board. If you're looking for great pizza boxes, this is your place. The pizza itself? A big box of island disappointment. $32.50 for a burnt crust, cold pizza with mediocre toppings. We ordered 2 pizzas for delivery. Total bill after delivery fee and tip was $73 (that's right, only 2 pizzas). I thought "this must be an amazing pizza for that price". I have only been more wrong one other time in my life. Over an hour later our pizzas arrived cold,ugly and burnt. I've had better microwave pizzas from the frozen food aisle. Save your money.

So I was pretty close to not being able to experience this amazing place! My wife wasn't too keen on the idea of having pizza while on vacation and I kind of agreed with her. One day we needed to get a simple lunch without all the frills and decided to just get ourselves a pizza. I am so glad we did this because Pie Whole isn't just a pizza place, its THE pizza place on the island. The flavor is out of this world and knocks any chain pizza place out of the water! The attitude of the waiter or owner, not sure which he was, was awesome! It was lunch time and he was totally fine with us ordering off the dinner menu. He had this awesome surfer dude attitude that felt like you were hanging out with your friends. The crust on the pizza was perfect and crispy. The sauce was perfect and not over bearning and the cheese was delicious. My wife got her half of the pizza loaded with meats and veggies! The home made sausage was out of this world! I was so jealous that I didn't get that on my side. We also really enjoyed their garlic cheese bread! The price can be a wee bit high. It set us back about 40 bucks. All in all though, great eats!

Cool little hole in the wall with killer thin crust stone oven pizza, great beer selection, and friendly staff. Loved the atmosphere. I'll be back anytime I'm on St Thomas.

We ordered pizza and Tacos, bot were great. Good prices. Very friendly service. Well be back.

We really enjoyed our dinner and experience. Great pizza and I am picky about my pizza. Really nice Rum Punch. Fun atmosphere. Next time to island, I will come back.