Pies & Pints - Carmel, IN

Had the caprese sandwich for lunch. Really good for something with no meat! Would come again to try other items, my sandwich was great and the bartender was attentive and friendly.

Pizza was very good. Staff is very friendly. Love trying new places. We will be visiting again soon! Edit: Such consistency in food, quality and service. So much fun and tons of atmosphere.

From the moment we walked into Pine & Pie Pizza, the ambiance was warm and inviting, setting the perfect tone for what turned out to be an exceptional dining experience. While the food was absolutely delicious and the atmosphere cozy, it was our server who truly elevated the evening. Our waitress was the definition of professionalism—attentive without being intrusive, knowledgeable about the menu, and incredibly efficient in managing our requests. What made her service truly stand out, however, was her kind and gentle demeanor. She greeted us with a warm smile, made thoughtful recommendations, and treated every member of our party with genuine care and courtesy. Her sweetness and approachable nature created a welcoming environment that made us feel like valued guests rather than just customers. It’s not every day you come across someone who embodies both professionalism and heartfelt hospitality so effortlessly. We left not only satisfied with our meal but genuinely grateful for such a pleasant and memorable service. Pine & Pie is lucky to have someone like her on their team. We will definitely return—not only for the great pizza but for the outstanding service. Highly recommended!

Pizza dough is amazing, great taste. The sweet and spicy beers were awesome. You are allowed to taste before buying. Time of service was appropriate for pizzas made tomorder. Service was awesome. Recommended based on quality and worth.

We are in town for a volleyball tournament and decided to try the pizza here. It was SO good!! Also, our waitress was amazing!! She was so sweet and talked to our girls about volleyball and wished them good luck the rest of the weekend!! We will definitely come back every time we are in town!

Holy smokes is this place good. Walked in for the first time with our four year old. They had a large beer and wine selection and the menu was beautifully simple yet expansive for all taste. My partner and I split a house salad and a 10" Margherita pizza. It was outstanding. The whole experience was great. Kids menu was reasonably priced. We will definitely be back.

Visited this place almost a year later. Love the food and selection of beers n wine.love their potato skin pie. Jus so yummy, and they have good salads as well. The server was good and loved the casual atmosphere. Will definitely go back. It's my comfort food kinda place.

I simply cannot recommend strongly enough. The beer list alone is the best I’ve seen in central Indiana. The food, especially the pizza is outstanding and the service if beyond compare. What a gem! Do yourself a favor and come here!!!!