Pies & Pints - Fayetteville, WV

The food was fabulous! We had a cheese, pepperoni, and a chicken Gouda pizza. The chicken Gouda is probably the best pizza I have ever had. Our server was attentive and very friendly. The kids enjoyed playing pool while waiting for our food. The winter margarita was good and there was a good selection of local beers.

Travelled to WV recently for Bridge Day at New River Gorge National Park. Pies & Pints came recommended by our AirBNB host. Due to busier than normal crowds we had to wait an hour for service, but the food and service were exceptional. We tried several menu items including their famous grape and gorgonzola pizza, pizza skins and house salad. Everything was hot, freshly made and delicious. Would highly recommend if you’re in the Fayetteville WV area. Indoor and outdoor seating available including a covered outdoor waiting area with ample seating and a small enclosed outdoor play area for toddlers.

Traveled from Buckhannon - we initially planned on going to the Secret sandwich society - but they turned us away at 8pm - we ended up coming here & honestly, I'm so glad. The service was phenomenal. the food was amazing. The atmosphere? Great. There was a pool table and arcade games in the waiting room if there was a wait. Those wings & that sauce? 100/10. Will go back.

Pies & Pints is a place I stop every time I’m in the area. The service always top notch and I love the pizza and beer selection. Always seems to hit the spot. This most recent time I visited (August 2025) they’d added on to the building since I was last there. Really like the new addition.

If you are looking for a great restaurant in Fayetteville, getting a pizza at Pies & Pints is a MUST! They have a great selection of pizza, salads, and other food, and the pizza is some of the best I've ever tasted! I personally recommend the Pine & Swine, the Chicken Gouda, or my absolute favorite, the Italian! They also have a good beer selection, both local and national brands. Whether you are in WV for hiking, rafting, or simply sightseeing, Pies & Pints is a great place to go to fuel up after a day of exercise. It is also family friendly!

We had a good meal here after going rafting on the recommendation of our guide. It is a bit deceptive with the parking lot and entrance, but it is bigger and busier than it looks. The pizza was great with many things we wanted to try. The ability to split a pizza into halves that both tasted great with an exorbitant cost was a great way to try more. We tried mushroom and street corn. They had a decent bar and nice atmosphere. We would definitely eat here again.

These pizzas were delicious!! I strongly recommend just ordering one of their specials off of the menus, as they are all good. Our group got half gluten free pies and half regular. The half that got gluten free wished they would have split a small one and gotten side salads. I ordered a gluten free sandwich in some kind of panini and it was amazing!!! 🥰 We are already trying to plan trips around where we can find another pies and pints!! 🙌🏼

It was a sweltering weekday in July when we stopped by. Unfortunately, when we asked about seating, the guy told us that all tables were reserved and we'd have to wait an hour. So we decided to sit outside and ordered a pizza. The pizza was no doubt really good but we were puzzled to see that most of the indoor seating remained empty throughout our wait. Despite the plenty of available space, we had to sit outside in the heat.

In town visiting from Pittsburgh and it seems to be a tradition for us to get pizza wherever we go, domestic or international. I guess its our comfort food! Pies and Pints had great reviews and interesting pizza toppings so we were intrigued. It was a saturday night in the summer and it was VERY busy. We had three small children with us, so that was not ideal...we definitely should have gotten a reservation, but we sort of decided last minute to give this place a try after hiking all day at New River Gorge. We ended up calling and doing a to-go order, which was also a very long wait, but they had a playground on site that our kids were able to play at until our pizza came. They gave us all a cup of water since it was a very hot day. We got a half and half pizza of the cuban and the pine and swine. Both were quite good! The crust was perfectly baked and chewy and the toppings were interesting and flavorful. We ended up eating outside at a picnic table that was not one of the tables they use to seat guests, so when all was said and done we were able to eat at the restaurant and keep our kids appeased during the long wait. It was a win-win for us! Great spot, fun atmosphere, and good service...albeit long!

Huge win!! 10/10 Pizza was fantastic 5 stars Root beer on draft was amazing Caesar salad was delicious- we shared and it was plenty - we got a small No pic- sorry- we took a peanut butter brownie back to our hotel and it was SO GOOD Clean bathrooms Plenty of parking Cute playground Lovely staff Definitely will be back if we ever pass this way again!

We are here twice on our vacation to New River Gorge. The first time my husband and I shared the Greek salad and the mushroom garlic pizza with spinach. So good!! We had the pizza skins minus bacon. Kinda weird. My son had the margarita which was good. Lots of leftovers. Great beer and cocktail menu. The second time we got the wings. The first batch was overdone. The second batch (had to speak to the manager as the waitress said they looked fine) was better and meh. They apparently bake them ahead of time and then wood fire them just before you get them. Meh. My husband and I split a large Greek salad again with chicken. Tons of toppings!! My son got the regular cheese which was meh. He also got the flatbread as an appetizer and loved it!

Our second visit and it was great again. We had the hot Nashville chicken pizza and the nachos. Both were worth the trip. Nice service. We got two sandwiches to go for snacks while skiing the next day. They were great. Pool table, pac man, and play ground for the kids.

Love it here! Super big place with a kids playground. Pies are super unique and all delicious, Cesar salad was amazing, desert cakes were yummy, beer selection was good too!

Introduced to this yummy spot! Tons of places to sit both indoor and outdoor! Wonderful service! Delicious pizzas: and Gorgonzola cheese Thai Pizza with Garlic bread with cheese with tomato sauce Andd yummy wings with tasty dipping sauce I tried the berry basil cocktail which was refreshing! Would definitely come back to try some of the other awesome pizza choices!

Sat at the bar and the bartender was great. Friendly and attentive service. The pizza was great too. Tasted fresh and didn't take long to come out. Came in starving and left full after only eating half! Made for great leftovers and the price was really reasonable!

Awesome place all around. Great service! Great atmosphere! Ample seating. Even a small kids playground, pool table and chill outdoor couches. Amazing selection of beer. Great variety of salads, sandwiches and pizzas. They even had a kids menu with reasonable prices. We enjoyed all our dishes.

Wow wow wow. That was PHENOMENAL. I took a risk and ordered a pizza (with vegan cheese) for the first time in over two years and am so happy I did. I ordered the regular sized margarita pizza which was bussin. Delicious crust, the cheese actually worked (which surprised me because Daiya isn't that good), and everything was great. It was really busy on a Sunday at 4:30 though so you know that it's great. What a lovely place.

I don't understand the bad ratings for this restaurant. We arrived around 5:30 p.m., and we were greeted promptly and politely and told there would a 15-minute wait. They took my cell phone number and told we would get a text when the table was ready. After about a 10 minute wait, I received a text and were shown to our table. The waiter was polite and quick to greet us and took our drink and appetizer orders. We ordered the garlic bread and wings, which were both delicious and brought to our table in a reasonable amount of time. I had three of the local beer offerings, which were also delicious. We then ordered the Antipasto salad and a large peperoni pizza. The salad was great, and the pizza was nothing short of amazing. I would definitely return and recommend this restaurant.

Yup. Great food, chill vibe, good music. Def come check this place out if you haven't been yet!

OMG!!! This place. The food. Best pies I've had in a while. The beer selection. We like to drink local brews when we travel. This place had them. The service (and they were SLAMMED!) STELLAR! It's not a place you go for a quiet dinner. There were families, kids, and a lot of people. But the food is fantastic, and it is a fun atmosphere. If you are going, go to enjoy everything about it. Put this at the top of your list if you go to the New River Bridge area. It's worth it.

Pies and Pints was one of the top recommendations I got when searching for food places around New River, so on my trip here, a friend and I had to check it out! The Food: A friend and I decided to split a large pizza and some wings. We went with the "Steak and Mushroom Pizza" and the "Char-Grilled Hot Wings". the Steak and Mushroom pizza was absolutely delicious! Big pieces of cut up steak paired with the creamy white sauce and mushrooms made for a perfect pie. The large is really big, so splitting it up between two people left us incredibly full. The slices were cooked perfectly and the crust was nice and firm. The wings were also really good! You can really taste the char grill on the wings, which added that nice smokey flavor. It wasn't spicy, but paired with some blue cheese or ranch really elevated it. The Service: Service was good! Staff were very friendly and attentive. This place can get really packed fast, so if you go during peak dinner time, you may have to wait a while. They do let you put your name/number down and will call when a table clears. But you can always walk up tot he bar for an open spot for faster service. The Atmosphere: Very nice place to relax and have some great food/drinks. Definitely a very social atmosphere that is nice to spend time at. There's plenty of tables to sit at, and there's a section for people to wait for their turn. Parking is also a little limited as well. Overall, a 5/5! The food was amazing, the atmosphere was very chill and relaxing, and the service was great! I'll be back for sure!

We were staying at #AITG and were spent after the day's adventure. We checked out the menu and ordered online, which was super easy. They told us 50 minutes to come pick up and it was ready in 45. We got the 10 inch pies and tried three. We got the steak and mushroom, the Classic and the shrimp pizza (we had them not put on the pineapple) and all were delicious.

Long wait, but worth it when visiting Fayetteville. Delicious and unique specialty pies, and an incredible and massive beer selection!

We came here on a Sunday night and had to wait about 15 mins for a table. Loved the creativity and atmosphere. Delicious pizzas, also love local beer selection.

Great music! Kendrick and death cab right off the jump. I stopped by here while a thunderstorm rolled through the valley. There was a wait (and the guy in front of me wanted to walk in with a party of 13, ). I was dining solo so I got to skip the wait and enjoy the bar area. The bartenders were very friendly and also didn't give a hoot that I wanted soda, not beer (though the beer impression does look great). I ordered the Cuban specialty pie. It was delicious. A small was perfect for one person.

I was up at the gorge for a business meeting and missed my Usual annual Pies night on Tuesday due to flight issues into Charleston so I moved it till Wednesday. I absolutely love this place. Great pizza and a great selection of beers both on tap and otherwise. Set at a high top at the bar since it was just me. Service was great as always and the pizza was spot on. Hot and delectable. Wow and they had an amazing Stout on taking so I was in my happy place.

This was a great find! We stopped in for lunch after hiking at New River Gorge NP and we had a great meal. We ate at the bar and our service was very good overall. We enjoyed some tasty beer and a mule and had a great spinach salad with lots of sunflower seeds. We also had a really great sausage and mushroom pie and we were very pleasantly surprised that we could find delicious pizza in Fayetteville. All in all, this is a great restaurant and it tastes even better after a day of hiking.

The place I was most looking forward to on our second visit to Fayetteville was Pies & Pints! One bite and you'll understand how amazingly delicious this place is and wonder how are there not more of them???? First off, we LOVE the portion sizes. Ginormous. We got two 16" pizzas thinking that we were ambitious enough to finish them both off. Wrong. It's ok though, because that's what leftovers are for. Second, the salads are just as big as the pizzas. These are designed to be family style but that didn't stop me from attempting to finish one off by myself since I just couldn't stop. Third, GET THE THAI PIZZA! I know you're thinking it sounds bizarre. A thai pizza???? YES, it's a game changer and it's time for you to become a believer. Lastly, their selection of beers is AWESOME. They've got a great curation of local and regional beers. They do a good job at really making you feel you're at a "place" and not just another joint. All the bar tenders and wait staff are super friendly. Kind of what you'd expect when visiting a hippie mountain town. Wish we could have one of these near us in LA but then it wouldn't be as special. Can't wait for the next visit!

This place was AWESOME! We had a party of 11 and they were able to accommodate our reservation on a busy night with only a minor delay, which didn't bother us because it gave us the opportunity to sample their selection of local microbrews! We had appetizers and a couple of big salads we shared, followed by 6 pizzas and everything was delicious! Some standouts that blew us away were the Siracha and shrimp pizza and the Thai pizza and the steak and mushroom. Our waiter was a hoot, super pleasant and attentive, and the hostess checked on us as well. Fantastic service! This place rocked! Definitely worth a stop if in the area!

Sometimes in life you just want pizza and beer (or in my case cider) and Pies & Pints hit that itch too perfectly. My wife and I did a 3 hour ZipLine tour and this was overwhelmingly the most recommended place from our tour guides. Let's do it: Pros: - The Pizza Skins (appetizer) blew me away. It's like a loaded potato/mashed potato/scallions/baconey pizza with sour cream that was up there for me. I can honestly say I've had nothing like it in my life and it was damn delicious. - Varieties of pizza. There's something for everyone. - Price. This place won't break the bank, even if you get "pints". - Location. Close enough to the Gorge so you can have an adventure and come right here. - TASTE. Everything was delicious. My wife got a mushroom garlic 10 inch pizza and I got a chicken with Gouda pizza 10 inch pizza. They were both phenomenal and I'd recommend anything. The star of the show though? That dang Pizza Skin pizza. Textures/tastes I've never had before, but man....that was it. If you're thinking of this place or wondering....do it. All of the tour guides recommended it and this place is a home run. Get here fast on a Friday or Saturday.

Omg ! Yummy yummy ! Great service quite vibe Great food , pizza was so fresh and yummy

This place makes filling up in carbs after a day of hiking easy and enjoyable. I really liked their Caesar salad (the croutons were delicious) and if you like a saucy pizza then this is the place for you. Our service was great, prices reasonable, and overall just a great vibe. (Did I mention the outside play area for those kids that are still energized after hiking all day!!)

This is a chain, and of my local outlet (not this one), I was told that the "pints were better than the pies". Given that I'm not a beer drinker, I was not persuaded to try the place. But this Fayetteville, WV location had the virtue of being one of the few things open; the area is beautiful but it's not the most happening town and everything is seasonal and has limited hours. The location has parking behind the shop, and a widespread interior with a bar, a covered patio, and a small playground out back. When you walk around to the entrance, there is a podium behind which the hostesses apparently hide so they can pop up like a jack-in-the-box when someone walks in. I was unsure of the wisdom of ordering a salad and a beverage, but I saw they had a draft root beer so I figured I'd give it a try. And it was a deliciously complex mix of flavors, plenty sweet but with various spice notes in each sip. My salad, described as simple, was better than I expected. I've had some low-effort salads that are just a few leaves with one or two toppings, but this was a large plate with radicchio in addition to multiple lettuces, and an abundance of tomatoes, onions, and croutons. So I was pretty satisfied before my pizza even arrived. I asked about half and half pizzas given their many options, but they could only do that on a large, I was told. This seemed kind of ridiculous to me; I mean is putting toppings on half a pizza rocket science? But whatever, I went exotic and tried the Mexican Street Corn pizza, with a lot of corn and a few jalapenos. It didn't have conventional tomato sauce, but with the lime chili powder and the fresh onions and parsley I think they achieve what they were going for. It wasn't a great crust, and frankly the pint did end up being better than the pie for me, but I could see the place is filling an important niche.

One of our stops while visiting New River Gorge and it was a good one! Bottom line first: was it the best pizza that we've ever eaten? No, but it was still a solid pie where they don't skimp on the premium toppings and the dough/sauce was tasty too. If I were to rate the place on the pizza alone, I think it would be about a 4/5. We ordered a large pizza with half italian and half pine and swine. Context: if you order a large, you have the option of ordering half and half. The pizza was solid. The ingredients were tasty by itself and all the flavors were balanced. I would say the pizza here could hold its own all by itself if they needed to. What sets this place apart is a combination of other things they offer. 1. The drinks - a large selection of beer, wine, and other adult beverages. 2. Ambiance - they have something for all sorts of ages. They have TVs set up for any sporting events. They have some video games and billiards for the slightly older kids and even a mini playground for the really young kids. The service was also good too. Our waiter was very prompt, kind, and knew how to multitask well. I could totally see the experience being a YMMV (your mile may vary) situation, but we had a great time. I'd totally come again if we were in the area.

I was excited to try this place when I saw they have an oatmeal stout. It was good and their Cuban pork pizza was fantastic! I ordered the large and ate the second half the following day. My wife ordered the pork nachos and she says they good and different with marinara sauce on top. Staff was friendly.

There's so many unique pizzas to try here & a good amount of beer as well! Was the perfect date night, a small pie was perfect for 1 person so we each got our own. Our waitress was super kind and helpful with suggestions! I got the Thai pizza with no cheese & really enjoyed the coconut flavor that came through, though I wish there was more sauce. We sat in the covered heated outside area and it was so nice! I was really impressed how warm it stayed. Definitely come here and try one of their unique flavors or get an amazing classic pizza (their pizza dough is delicious)!

TLDR; Rude Staff, No Dogs, Food was fine We were recommended to go here by locals to be able to sit outside with our dogs and eat. Upon arriving we were directed to a single picnic table outside of their actual outdoor eating area - at a fence next to the road where we could order takeout and sit. Obviously that was really disappointing. But we ordered carry out and waited. The carry out staff were incredibly rude and everyone just seemed in a bad mood. Mind you we were bummed but still being polite and not sure why we were being treated so poorly. Anyway the food was good - we got a cheese pizza, Caesar salad, and locally brewed rootbeer.

Pies and Pints is my favorite pizza joint after I first tried their food in Morgantown. I was surprised that the little town of Fayetteville had an location, but it turns out this is the OG spot, so I was excited to go. I love their pies.. the crust is just right - not too thick and not too thin, just a bit of crisp and no huge crust that you don't want to eat. I ordered my usual, the grape and Gorgonzola pizza and will now be dreaming about it until the next time I am back in WV.

Deep in West Virginia, close to the rim of the state's green "Grand Canyon" (the New River Gorge), you'll find great pizza and beer. The pizza choices here are creative and unusual. The steak and mushroom comes with a gargonzola-based white sauce with strips of medium-well steak (would have preferred a little rarer) and a sprinkling of mushrooms and scallions. If I was assembling this pie I would have gone a little heavier on the mushrooms and scallions, but notwithstanding that preference, it was a perfectly satisfying and refreshingly different take on pizza. I asked what the most popular pizza here was, and it turns out to be "the classic" with pepperoni, followed by the chicken specialty pizza. I suppose locals get to a point where the long standing classic pepperoni is what you seek, but one hopes they would have at least tried all those intriguing choices on the specialty menu. They also offer sandwiches on the flip side of the menu, but most of what emerges from the kitchen is pizza. A note for the traveler: if you arrive right before closing time expecting to be told "we're about to close"--which I did and just on a lark decided to try anyway with just 8 minutes before closing--instead I was advised "there's a wait for a table, but you could eat right away at the bar." Nice! I sat at the bar with some bearded local guys drinking PBR talking about best routes to places. The bar has about six feet of taps lined up with an impressive but not overwhelming choice of beer on tap. A larger selection of canned beer is available, too. Bar patrons can get a taste on request of the varieties on tap. I had two excellent dark brews, one described as dry and 4.7% alcohol, and one based on coffee. THe pizza itself was in proper format: thin crust, crisp, and the white cheese sauce was the perfect consistency. The atmosphere is muted dark gray and feels like an updated mountain lodge, which is just right given the local setting. For pizza, beer, and atmosphere, five stars.

The pizza was amazing (I wish I remembered to take photos). My friends and I split the Street Corn pizza, Margarita, Chicken Gouda, and a Pine & Swine and each one was just as good as the other. The only issue was our pizzas took 2 hours after ordering. Although this was Bridge Day so we understand the increase in business and wait time.

We are nomads, so we get to sample pizza in many regions and locales. This is definitely one of the best taste experiences ever! Service was great (thank you Hannah) too. My only not to pick was the lack of anything like brown ale, porter, or amber/red ale on draft.

Always a must stop when we visit The Summit! The pies are awesome and despite swearing off beer, I always make an exception when we come. Great drinks, great food, and the servers are always wonderful even when they're super busy. Word of advice: make a reservation for the weekend or be prepared to wait awhile or sit at the bar!

Ordered a street corn pizza and garlic bread . It was Amazing! The waiter was so sweet. Super quick service. Cute place with indoor and outdoor spaces to sit.

Always a favorite stop when visiting Fayetteville, WV Street corn pizza was excellent. Favorite is grape and Gorgonzola. We are the wings too fast to snap a pic!! Love Pies and Pints.

Love this place! Great options for local draft beers and unique pizza combinations. The pizza was awesome! Two of us shared the small house salad which was very good, the house dressing was great. If you are a blue cheese lover, ask for a side of their blue cheese-like dressing as a side with your meal. Also, love the atmosphere and seating areas. It's a big place but I imagine it gets packed around meal times, so be prepared for that. We went for an early lunch and there was no wait.

Nice place, great service and excellent wings and pizza. Great beer choices too! Would return if we lived near !

Enjoyed our experience. We've visited Pies & Pints in Charleston a few times and it was always positive - so felt confident coming here while in Fayetteville. We came on a Mon night and the place was fairly busy but still had plenty of seating and we elected to sit at the bar. Good local brews on tap (which I expected). While this may sounds crazy, we elected to go with a salad - and the bartender (Josh) recommended a large salad to split for the two of us. We ordered the arugala & goat cheese salad and added chicken and it was plenty big for the both of us along with generous toppings - we loved it! Service from Josh and the crew was great. We would absolutely come again!

Fun atmosphere. We played some pool! Unique pizza toppings. Great salads too! Loved the cauliflower crust!

Easy ordering, amazing menu, delicious pizza, quick pickup! I've never had pizza from this chain, and was pleasantly surprised, especially at all the non-tomato based sauces. The steak pizza was sooo good. My other favorite was the potato skins pizza appetizer. That was a crowd pleaser. The chicken wings were moist and well seasoned. We ordered for pickup, and everything was ready on time.

The pizza was delicious, the service was fast. I could see why food network has been there twice, and it's americas number one pizza! I do think that $25 is kinda steep for a pepperoni pizza. Would probably return though.

This seemed quite popular and I can see why. We had a large group so we got 4 different pizzas and had them double cut so there were more slices to share. We had a sausage and pepperoni, baked potato, Mexican street corn, and the Nashville hot chicken. Every single one of these was very well executed. The most basic one (the sausage and pepperoni) was delightful since each element was high quality. Sauce, meat, cheese, crust, so good. My favorite was the Nashville hot but it was by a very slim margin and I would gladly eat any of them again. Oh, and our waitress was spot on as well. Checking in just enough to make sure everyone had what they needed. My only complaint is that it seems this location is the closest to my home. I can't say it's good enough to be only reason to make the 4 hour drive but if you are anywhere close, and you like pizza, then this is a great choice.

Best dining experience in Fayetteville so far! If you want great service and food, come here. The restaurant has both indoor and outdoor dining options and has great vibes. Yes, it's busy but, totally worth the wait. We had the ceasar salad and that dressing is amazing with homemade croutons. We order a 1/2 and 1/2 with mushroom garlic and Thai shrimp. Both awesome combinations and so delicious we forgot to take a photo. We never make it to dessert but, decided to give them a try since both items are homemade. OMG...that chocolate dessert is amazing!!! Hands down would order that again. Check them out you will not leave hungry.

Great pizza! We got take out this trip. It was fresh and ready at pick up. Easy peasy.

Amazing, inclusive, and friendly atmosphere with quick service. Lots of allergy and preference-friendly options (vegan and gluten free)! An excellent choice to stop on a long trip down rt 19.

Great restaurant in downtown Fayetteville. Be prepared for a wait because both tourists and locals love this place. You can get a drink at a bar and then wait outside on their seating. There is a pool table to chill at. Huge bar with TVs. Bathrooms are single stalls. Pizza was delicious and there are so many different options!!

After a challenging three-hour hike, we were all in desperate need of some hearty pizzas and refreshing drinks, so we decided to head over to Pies & Pints. Despite a 40-minute wait, we weren't discouraged. My friends grabbed some drinks and enjoyed a game of pool while we waited. One neat feature was that we received a text with a link detailing the waiting time and the number of tables ahead of us so we could make the most of our wait by playing pool or relaxing outside. The place had various seating options, perfect for catching up with friends or engaging in arcade-style games. Once our table was ready, the service was prompt and attentive. The food arrived quickly, and it was absolutely delicious. We ended up sharing slices, and everyone was thrilled with their choice. Not a single slice was left untouched. We thoroughly enjoyed our visit and highly recommend it to anyone searching for a chill spot after a long hike.

Had the Char-grilled Hot Wings Pine & Swine pizza. Both were great choices, especially the pizza. Crust was just right and the combination of toppings delicious. Beer menu is extensive. All for a reasonable price. Thanks for a nice meal after a long drive!