Michael X.
Yelp
I love ice cream, and when I saw that there was a highly rated ice cream place in Hanalei by the name of Pink's Creamery, I was excited to check this place out! We went on a Friday around 7:30PM and had a brief 10 minutes wait before getting ice cream in our hands.
The ice cream shop is located near the shopping area in Hanalei, and there is a lot (about 10-12 car spots?) right in front shared with a couple of other shops. When we went at 7:30PM there was still a small line out the door as the shop only can service one customer at a time. Since were getting close to the closing time of the shop, they were out of a couple of items such as milkshakes.
I got two half scoops for $7.75, which I thought was pretty pricey for two HALF scoops of ice cream - the most recent reviews don't mention this, so just note this. I have tried numerous ice cream shops where this is the price for two full scoops so I was a bit disappointed that they were half scoops. I got the Haupia and Aloha Cherry Truffle as my flavor options - they tasted nice, you can taste the coconut flavor and the cherry bits in the Aloha Cherry Truffle, but the fudge ribbons are bit more hidden and smaller than I expected in the scoops. I also forgot to mention, they also didn't do samples when I went, so hope you enjoy the flavors that you get!
As for my experience, I thought that Pink's Creamery was only an alright ice cream shop, where the two things that disappointed me were the bizzare service of one customer at a time in the store, and the $8 - $10 for 1 - 2 scoops of ice cream respectively. If I'm ever in the Hanalei area again, I'm not sure I would revisit.