Pisillo Italian Panini Chelsea

Very great sub shop to stop into, atmosphere is very casual. Great service, I ordered online and it was ready by the time I walked in. I ordered the L’Aquila panini and it was great. Only downfall is that you can only get a full sub and it’s very large but it’s a great deal for 2 people!

One of the BEST sandwiches I’ve ever had…but you walk into this tiny spot, see the guys slicing meats and cheeses as the sandwiches are being ordered…choice of bread…30+ sandwiches…order, wait a few minutes, grab your bag and dig in! Wanted to eat the whole thing but had to work this afternoon but have a date with the other half later…Carmelo, the owner, came out and brought us some cannolis on the house…can’t hid his passion for what he does…could eat here once a week! Already looking forward to going back.

There are sandwiches, and then there’s Pisillo — where each bite feels like it’s been blessed by the sandwich gods and delivered straight from Naples to 7th Ave. I went with the Parma, and let’s just say this thing doesn’t play small ball. It’s stacked like a luxury high-rise: prosciutto, mozzarella, roasted peppers, arugula, and that sesame-crusted bread that crunches just enough to make eye contact with your soul. You unwrap it in foil like a treasure, take one bite, and suddenly you’re reconsidering every “Italian sub” you’ve ever settled for. Bonus points for the outdoor seating — nothing says “power move” like housing a sandwich the size of your head while watching Chelsea traffic crawl by. Pair it with a Coke Zero if you want to pretend you’re being healthy. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — the kind of sandwich that makes you cancel afternoon plans and just sit there, smiling like an idiot.

One of the best subs I’ve ever had. Sliced the prosciutto for my sandwich right in front of me. Big enough for two meals. I will be returning

Decent sandwiches. In my non-Italian opinion, they would be better with mayo or some other sauce to make them less dry. Portion sizes are very large, lots of leftovers.

I wasn’t sure how I felt at first, but after a few bites in, I fell in love. This is not your classic fanfare American sandwich. These are high-quality Italian ingredients with an incredibly fresh and robust flavor with each ingredient that is used and the massive bread is baked and delivered fresh daily. They have a pretty wild selection of options on their menu and the portion is incredibly massive. I was only able to finish half my sandwich and left the other half for the next day. And to my surprise, it tasted even better the next day as the ingredients soaked each other’s flavors and mash together This place is wholesome with high-quality fresh tasting sandwiches. If you’re looking for stereotypical American fanfare sandwich this is not it. Lastly: These are not HOT pressed Panini’s like you would normally expect here in the United States. These are Italian style cold subs.

I did not eat here. Let me explain. My sister and I were in New York for a concert. So we decided we wanted Italian food. We looked on Google maps and this place was closest(were walking). When we arrived it was a small but pleasant Panini shop. Since we wanted some kind of pasta with our meal(all they had was paninis) we asked if there was another Italian food restaurant nearby. The man behind the counter was very nice and friendly and directed us to a restaurant 1 block down that had good Italian food. He was correct in his judgement of the food and where restaurant was. If we had more time in New York City we definitely would have gone back and eaten here. The food looked good and the people are very friendly.

Ewww this place sucks the sandwich was gross and what kind of sun dried tomatoes are these it was $18 bucks and I asked to switch it for something else because it looked gross and the lady at the counter said no!!! Don’t go here also bread was stale

Amazing, delicious, and massive sandwich. Great if you're very hungry or want to share.

a piece of shit place. Panini is kinda supposed to come pot, heated in between two hot plates, right? No, these people tell you, you are an idiot, this is "Italian" panini. Cones on cold as fuck two pieces of baguette. Can you please heat these up? No we cannot , this is "Italian panini". Fuck this place, they do not give a shit about a customet. Too many tourists? DO NOT VISIF THIS PLACE

I was so excited when this place finally opened in Chelsea! I ordered the Napoli sandwich online on focaccia and added hot peppers. It was soooo delicious!!! The sandwich was huge and is perfect to split between two people. It was ready in 20 mins after I placed the order online, and the pickup was super easy. The menu is huge, so I will definitely be back to try another sandwich variation soon!