Mr. Falafel - Best Halal Food In Newark

Took a seat to eat a few bites before leaving. After eating a portion of the burger I felt unwell. So i ended up taking the rest home. When home i noticed the burger was undercooked (pictures included). Feeling queazy and regretting the money spent… couldn't see meat clearly while sitting in the store since the lighting was dim, it's an empty space, and weird vibe - not worth it.

Delicious food, wonderful service, and cozy atmosphere. I loved trying the unique Middle Eastern beverages and desserts served here.

We were not greeted upon arrival, and the staff seemed disengaged. I ordered the ‘Mr. Falafel’s Platter for Two,’ which is the most expensive item on the menu, but it was underwhelming. The platter had an excessive amount of rice, very little salad, and we only received two types of meat despite the menu stating four different types of meat? I also didn’t find the freshness and bold flavors I typically enjoy in halal/falafel places. Overall, I expected more balance, variety, and value given the price

The staff's service was excellent, and the food was more than delicious, especially the burgers and shawarma.

Highly recommend. Dude outside handing the flyers gave me a discount just for checking them out! Food was great. I’ll let all my friends from Rutgers know!!

Mr. Falafel’s lives up to its name, their falafel is perfectly crispy and full of flavor😍Fresh, affordable, and always satisfying. Highly recommended🤌

The kufta kebab platter was SO GOOD. The meat was so tender and packed with flavor. Service was attentive and efficient. If you want the kufta though it’s recommended that you call for pick up before you go because it takes about 15 min to prepare. Highly recommend if you’re craving halal food!!

If you're anywhere near Newark and craving truly authentic Middle Eastern flavor, Mr. Falafel is an absolute must-try. This place is a hidden gem that delivers freshness, generosity, and genuine hospitality in every bite. From the moment you walk in, you can smell the warm spices and the freshness of the food being made right in front of you. Their falafel is perfectly crispy on the outside, soft and flavorful on the inside, the kind of falafel that takes you straight back to the Middle East. And the portions? Huge — they don’t hold back. Their hummus is unbelievably smooth, their tahini tastes homemade, and the shawarma is seasoned to perfection. You can truly feel that every dish is made with care, not rushed or commercial. Even the bread is soft, warm, and fresh — exactly how it should be. What really makes Mr. Falafel special is the people. The staff treat you like family, always friendly, always generous, and always making sure you leave happy and full. Places like this are rare. f you want real, bold, delicious flavor — not the Americanized version — Mr. Falafel is hands down the best Middle Eastern spot in Newark. Everything tastes homemade, authentic, and made with love. Highly recommended. 🌯🔥 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 — A must-visit!