Jared G.
Yelp
Polo Grill - Utica Square, Tulsa (American)
Note on Ratings:
Scores are out of 100, emphasizing food quality. This review is based on my subjective opinion, primarily in fine dining.
Introduction:
Polo Grill, a longstanding fixture in Tulsa's fine dining scene for over three decades, beckoned me for an appraisal after its lofty reputation endured the test of time. Despite Tulsa's culinary evolution, Polo remained a beacon of excellence. With great company in tow, it was time to explore if this venerable establishment still held its own among Tulsa's culinary giants.
Atmosphere:
Polo's ambiance blends Midwest charm with modern country elements, creating a captivating setting rooted in old-world, country club vibes. The decor, lighting, and artful wine displays contribute to a relaxed dining experience. The diverse elements - from themed decor to sports-focused elements - might cater to a wide audience, albeit occasionally lacking clarity in identity.
Service:
Bella and Sam, our servers, delivered excellent, personable service. Bella's menu insights enhanced our experience, ensuring our needs were met throughout the evening, aligning with top-tier fine dining standards.
Food:
Lime bacon-wrapped shrimp, a delightful first appetizer, blended sweet undertones with a tangy lime sauce, elevated by a hint of heat from the jalapeno glaze. However, the beef tartare struggled to find balance due to an overwhelming beef flavor and chunky accompaniments, resulting in an unbalanced dish. The Arancini balls boasted a crispy crust but fell short in texture and flavor harmony.
The lobster and crab bisque stood out, delivering a velvety, briny essence with cognac undertones, a standout rendition. However, the filet of beef tenderloin oscar style disappointed with overcooked portions and lackluster accompaniments.
Dessert redeemed the meal with a satisfying chocolate Grand Marnier cake, complemented by vanilla bean ice cream, providing a creamy, flavorful finish.
Overall:
Polo Grill's generous portions and diverse ambiance may appeal broadly. Service and ambiance are commendable, yet the food quality and execution leave room for improvement. While some dishes were satisfactory, none stood out as exceptional, with a significant letdown in the steak dish. Polo Grill's unique dining experience and reasonable prices may still attract many despite its culinary inconsistencies.
Atmosphere: 13/20; Occasionally ambiguous but overall pleasant.
Service: 13/20; Good service, meeting fine dining expectations.
Food: 36/60; Several good bites, some great, but overall room for improvement.
Overall: 62/100
Price point: 1 drink; 2 appetizers; 1 entree; 1 dessert: $100.00