Pots & Pans Pie Co.

The older lady was rude, the younger one was helpful. The old lady was more concerned about who was on my phone and what they were talking about than helping me. The pies were burnt and I saw that when I went back to the truck. I came back to inquire and she wanted to see and said it was the jam... Why is there jam burnt on the bottom when there is NONE inside the pastry?!? She said they were all the same with red pepper that's all she kept saying but there were two types two of those burnt ones which we lost half the pastry cutting that part off. The others were jalapeno and cream cheese, the last was cat food or something in there. Idk what that was but it was a weird flavor. Wasn't a fan of the apple crumble and I hate root beer but they tossed in the minis to get rid of them but that was the only thing able to be eaten the rest of them hand pies were dry and had a filing in the last one was not able to be identified it was a creamy mess inside. I won't be doing pies any time soon but when I do it won't be from this location. If it wasn't for the young lady I would not have added 4 stars for the atmosphere and two for the service.

Fast service! And yummy food! My first time coming here! Glad i did the food was really good and fresh tasting! We got the most popular, the classic chicken! 10/10! The cost is kinda higher for 6” -$13. But its homemade so its worth it. The store is super small so not any seats! The parking is small. But definitely recommend

If anyone said to me that I would love a sugar cream pie would never have expected that. I usually think pies are too unhealthy or what not but had to give this a try on a trip. We really picked the best place to get this by because it was phenomenal! Them a really large variety of pie options. They were available but we were there for that famous to the green pie so had to take that one. Fire was served cold but that was no issue at all. It was perfectly sweet and not too sugary sweet (I didn't usually go for sugary sweet stuff). Creamy and smooth and with a perfectly flaky crust and just overall delicious. It had a creme brulee kind of a topping on top which made it even better. Husband that I open this as soon as we got into the car. Finished it in a matter of minutes and then wanted more. That's how good it was!

Perfect pies ✔️ from a cute little shop with friendly people. Seriously, y'all were so patient as I indecisively mulled over which of the many delicious pie options. We ended up getting a supreme pizza hand pie, and individual slices of the sugar creme brulee and the blackbottom frangipane. My favorite was the creme brulee since I have a sweeter palette but my significant other really liked the frangipane as it was less sweet and had a bit of a kick of salt and depth of flavor. The hand pie was a little different than I was expecting. It was good but definitely for someone who likes cheese on a pizza more than I do, because I love tomato and I was hoping for more of a tomato flavor. I'm going to need to come back to try the other pies as well as get one of the take-home and bake pies as those seem to be more of the savory hearty variety. Check out these photos!

We picked up a small biscuits and gravy pie for dinner, and I cannot believe how delicious it is! The gravy tastes homemade, and the crust is made with love. I look forward to trying another one of their pies soon!

What a disappointment. 3 different items and they were all bad. Creme brule pie was not sweet at all and the top was completely burnt. The Shoofly pie was probably the nastiest thing I have ever eaten and the oatmeal cream pie tasted like an oatmeal cookie with a glob of butter in the middle. The cream had no sweetness at all. We drove over 100 miles to try this place because of TikTok and will never do this again. Update : we also got a frozen to go Mac and cheese pie. To continue on the disappointment journey. Spoiler: this is not a pot pie at all. Just a pie pan with Mac and cheese in it.

I got a the lamb pie from the broad ripple farmer market. I had high hopes because I love lamb. But this pie STINKS! The meat does not taste great at all and there’s only 1 piece of meat inside. It’s filled 98% of just the sauce and some beans. Do not recommend. What a ripoff

I’ve tried at least 6 different savory pot pies. The flavor combinations are incredibly well thought out and balanced. The pies are simply amazing. I still haven’t figured out exactly what oven setting, temperature, and length of cooking works best but the crust and filling is so good that it doesn’t even matter if you cook it correctly. Also, their shortbread chocolate chip cookies are hands down the best cookie I’ve ever had. Forget just the best chocolate chip cookie, the best cookie of any kind from any place I’ve ever tasted. Simply amazing. Highly recommend