Big E.
Yelp
I have played Poxabogue several times over the last couple years.
Poxabogue is MAYBE an OK place to have breakfast at and maybe hit a bucket of overpriced golf balls. They have decent pancakes and sandwiches at a reasonable price for the Hamptons area. The range is a little pricey for what it is...Medium bucket of balls is $17 and large bucket is $24. You could walk 18 Holes at Sag Harbor for those prices and actually work on your game.
Poxabogue is a LESS than OK place to play a round of golf at. It is basically a 9 Hole Par 3 course with a few Par 4 holes. It's really only decent for working on your short game. The course itself is pretty well maintained, so I will give it up for the grounds crew however, the pro shop/check-in is ran by a rather RUDE bunch of non professionals; especially the woman who works the front counter. If you ask her a question, she is immediately mad and rude.. if you ask her more than one question, she will bite your head off. One time, I was 5 min early for my tee time when I was ready to walk to the tee box and I was told I was late? I understand some courses like it when your are 10-15 min early, but the course was totally empty... 7:30am on a Tuesday.
I opened the door to the pro shop to possibly buy a hat and some balls and was immediately yelled at by an older gentleman. He told me to ask to enter the pro shop, because he had the dogs running loose in the shop and didn't want them to bite me or get out. Dogs... IN THE PRO SHOP!!!!! oh right, I should have known that.
You can't book 18 Holes online. You have to book 2 different 9 Hole rounds, 2 hours apart from each other and then deal with the rude staff when you arrive. A few times they have overbooked and we have had to wait to close to an hour to make the turn to play a 2nd nine.
The rental push cart and clubs are below par and outdated.
Poxabogue would be a great option for a round of golf if every course in the area were on fire at the same time and there weren't any farmers fields that you could play in. Save your money.