Pub 235

It’s not surprising that for such a hidden location Pub 235 is so popular. They successfully maintain two separate spaces - a bar and dining room - with unique feels. All areas are wheelchair accessible and the staff worked seamlessly without any hesitation to accommodate. The menu isn't labeled well for dietary needs but the server was informative. Substitutions were made for gluten free needs, though not in a dedicated space. Unfortunately, one of my dishes was presented with a slice of wheat toast on it. Servings were substantial and flavors were fresh and flavorful.

We stopped in while visiting family and were seated right away around 530PM. Everyone was friendly, portions are huge, and the food was good. We ordered buffalo chicken rolls, a turkey wrap, and their prosciutto pasta. There is a patio area with seating, bar seating/high tops, and a smaller dining room with lower tables. Our server seemed pretty busy on a Monday evening and didn't check on us after food was brought, but was friendly.

This was our first time at Pub 235 in many years and absolutely loved it. Started out with a loaded fries appetizer, which was amazing, artichokes French, and the chicken French Panini and the burger - all excellent. Lots of food for a decent price and the desserts were excellent also. Even better was the great service that we got from the hostess and from our server Dominique. Will definitely be there again.

12/4/24: I was amazed 👏 at the high quality of the food at Pub 235! The offerings 🫴 were extensive yet not so much that they couldn't prepare what they offer at a high quality. The service was great. The atmosphere was posh & fitting of a Village of Webster eatery nowadays. The parking lot had numerous Porsches, BMWs, Genesis, & Audis. That surprised 😮 me too. There's so much money 💰 in Webster. I'll go back to this restaurant & start ordering take away items too. I was quite happy 😊 at this village eatery. They even had a warm, welcoming bar 🍸 🧉 area.

Top notch food, staff is always friendly. Sometimes the food can be a little slow coming out, but hot food never comes out cold. Innovative food variations, always know I can try something new. The French Onion Cheese Steak is UNREAL! Prob my favorite dish to date.

Chill pub vibe with seating and menu of almost a bistro. Great service, lots of seating, great bar and bartender. Got the French onion steak sandwich and it was one of the best sandwiches ive had

The service was great. I ordered the fish fry and it was very greasy, more than I would have expected. Fries were fine. My husband’s broiled fish was kind of tasteless and fishy. The seafood bisque was just bland.

My wife and I had drinks last night. She had a dirty martini and I had a makers Manhattan. Bartending is often overlooked so I wanted to say that the drinks are always great and kudos to the bartenders. We shared the bruschetta which we have had many times and was excellent. We also shared the pub 235 burger but we always add an egg and ask forlorn pretzel roll. It stands up better than the regular roll and it is still soft. Great job last night!

Came here after getting a tree the other day. I got the chicken French panini and WOW highly recommend! What a unique and delicious item I would come back just for this! They also have gluten free buns which was a huge plus as someone in our group was GF and was able to still get a sandwich. Our server was very sweet and helpful and the food came out fast

My second review of the Pub. We are regulars and always enjoy our meals. Special favorites are Hank's roast beef, Greek salad, Pastrami melt. On Monday 3/3/25 we had issues. The nice waitress asked if we would like our courses brought out separately . We said yes but they came one right after the other. The breading on the haddock was not up to par and my roast beef sandwich arrived rare and I asked for well-done . They took it back to the kitchen and the return sandwhich tasted dry and as if it were microwaved. My Virgin Mary cocktail from the bar was outrageously good !

Great attentive service. Nice patio vibes. Awesome pastrami. Chicken a little dry will definitely come back for the pulled pork.

The Saturday brunch was amazing!! Everything was so good. I highly recommend, you will not be disappointed.

The Saturday brunch... unreal. The best kept secret in Webster. I've had the Pub Eggs Benny, a twist on your normal eggs Benedict with smoked pork belly and an Asian sauce. Incredible. The flatbread breakfast pizza, a savory filling delight. The breakfast burrito, simplicity, and deliciousness all wrapped into one. Forgot to mention the mimosas and the bloody Mary's... So affordable and delicious.

My favorite place for a fish fry when I visit Rochester! (Additionally I can order spaghetti on the side which I love)! The crispiness of the fish fry and the batter amount is perfect - there's no sogginess at all and the haddock inside has that nice moisture when you bite into it. My fish fry is completely demolished every time I order it here. My boyfriend pointed out that he likes that two tartar sauces are provided since he tends to use all the sauces while eating. I like the variety of sides a lot since I tend to eat a lot of fries with my meals when I'm upstate and sometimes I'm not feeling fries or chips on the side :) Service is very good every time I go here and it seems like a popular spot for locals! It is most always crowded during dinner but I honestly think the wait is worth it - if you don't want to wait you should at least order the fish fry (beer battered haddock dinner) for pickup!

Great burgers, great sides, great wings, great cocktails. Attentive service , good vibes, fun little spot with everything you want in a neighborhood pub. Two thumbs up

The prime rib is wonderful! chicken French is tasty. The appetizer -pesto burrata bruschetta- is amazing. Karen, our server is wonderful as well. She is very attentive. Highly recommend

Such amazing food and the drinks are phenomenal! The bartender Shareen is amazing! Great drinks and so personable! I always have a great time here!

The service was not good im not sure if the waitress was preoccupied but she was upset splitting a check that was not down the line even. Never asked me why i only ate 2 bites of my nachos. The owner was great asked me if I wanted it re made. The cocktails were watered down but the draft beer was good. Would come back for bar seating and a different app.

great service, food, and nice atmosphere. I got the special, roast pork, mashed potatos, stuffing and gravy. PLENTY of food for $20! my friend for the fried spicy chicken club and fries, he said it was delish! one of the best parts of our visit-dessert! we ordered a warm sea salt caramel skillet cookie with vanilla ice cream. North Carolina. First of all, it was huge-we split it and the two of us couldn't finish it! one of the most delicious desserts I've ever had! we will definitely be back!

I got the Pub Riggies , and added Chicken, OMG , sooooo goood . And I got it to go , was still hot when I got home !

This was our first time going here and it did not disappoint!!! 1. The service was amazing, quick and friendly. Always there when we needed her and checked on us an appropriate amount of times 2. Food was absolutely delicious. The tots were some of the best I've had in a while and the garbage plate was seriously delicious. The proportions were right on point, couldn't even finish it all. We also got a mule and cosmo and they were delicious and you could taste the alcohol 3. The inside is very nice, we sat in the porch area that's covered and heated and we loved it. Definitely recommend trying

The food is always amazing and the drinks at the bar are phenomenal! Shareen is an awesome bartender who takes pride in her work and is so personable. Love it here!

Never had a bad meal at Pub 235! As a family, many dishes have been tried. And it's noteworthy to mention that they the kids menu was just as carefully prepared for the kids as the adults. Sometimes that is not the case at restaurants.

The prices and lack of vegetarian options are terrible. We wanted a "Plate" and they told us it would be an up charge of $10 to replace the meat with a veggie burger. $27 for a veggie burger, Mac salad and French fries topped with onions and mustard. We left. The server was really sweet though.

Went there for a fish fry dinner for 2.. Great service, Great meal.. But...A few weeks later, I ordered 2 fish fries to go.. When I picked them up , I should've looked before I drove off.. The Fish was put in the box with NO Plate , laying on the cardboard box, Along with the fries and extras tossed on top of the fish.. got home in 5 minutes, everything was Cold.. I called and complained, got no apology.. Well , too many other places to get a fish fry,around here.. So.. Bye Bye..Pub 235

My favorite spot for lunch in Webster. They can get quite busy, so I think a lot of people share my feelings about that.

Very cozy sports bar with a great atmosphere! My first trip to Buffalo and the reviews brought me here. We were not close to the live music but it was great anyway and not overbearing for those seated close to it. I had the chicken parmesan and it was massive and amazing. I highly recommend this spot!

Friends took us here after recommending it and it was very good! So many yummy options on the menu I wish I could've tried more. We had chicken parm sandwich, pub Cuban sandwich, shaved steak sandwich, and the bugsy malone pizza, all were delicious. Drinks were also so good. Definitely will have to come back soon

Delicious food with lots of variety. Stand up service, able to give recommendations and details to questions.

Online order. Picked up food at time specified. Over $80 order. Returned home and noticed more than half the order was missing. Returned back to the restaurant and received only an apology for forgetting half the order. When returned back home (living less than three minutes away) food was completely cold like it had been sitting around for over 30 minutes. Not impressed at all and a waste of money.

Great food and service with a busy happy hour atmosphere. Occasionally, there's live music. You may want to request a seat in the dining room to avoid shouting.

Delicious and well portioned food. Sampled the pizza special...a blt that was peppered with peppery arugula. The Ruben sandwich was good, the sauerkraut could have used a squeeze. The drinks stole the show, mules n martinis were delish.

Dowling scoring system Ambiance: 8/10 Service: 8/10 Food: 10/10 Value: 9/10 --------------------- Total: 35/40 Chicken French Panini

This is a fun place. Great food, great drinks, and great people. A great place to meet friends and gather as family. Very cute place.

My wife and I have Ave eat there several times and it is super restaurant We go there when we are in that area. Highly recommend

I stopped here between Christmas and New Years while looking for something to eat. We didn't have to wait long and were seated at the bar. Donna was the best as we never had to wait for anything and checked on us regularly. The Chicken French was great. The chicken itself was cooked with a nice crispy batter and the sauce was absolutely amazing. It was a huge portion but I ate it all anyway. They had a wide variety of beers on tap and bottled. All around great spot with quality food and drinks.

One of my absolute favorite restaurants. The Pub is great for any occasion. They have your classic party/pub foods, but also a lot of upper scale specials, burgers, steaks, and pastas. With their wide variety of menu options, you can always get something you're in the mood for, at a very reasonable price! My two all time favorite menu options is the bruschetta (pictured here) and the chicken French panini. I can't explain how good their French sauce is. YUM! Both potions are large and I definitely recommend sharing the bruschetta with your whole table. I have been going to the pub for years and the entire staff treats you like family! The owner, Billy, truly cares about his business and ensures your experience is wonderful. I definitely recommend giving this Webster restaurant a try!!

This restaurant grew on me. At first I was put off by the prices. I've ordered take out a bunch durring covid and this place is close to home. It's safe to say that everything is worth the money. Portions are huge with high quality ingredients. The artichoke french is great. Add pasta for a few bucks to make it a meal. The sauce is so flavorful unlike many others I have had. The burger is huge. Loaded with bacon, onion rings, bbq sauce. They give you a ton of seasoned french fries. It's uncomfortable eating the entire thing in one shot. I obviously know that from experience. The online ordering wasn't working last time. I just call them. They bring things out to your car so you don't even have to leave.

Came for lunch and sat at one of the high tops in the bar area. Our server was very attentive and friendly. The menu made it hard to choose what to get because everything sounded so good. They have a variety of food options, certainly something for everyone. I left satisfied and full! I'll be sure to be back and recommend to anyone.

We were out in Webster and asked for a good lunch place. 235 Pub came highly recommended. It was a hot, humid day but we decided to sit outside. The patio area is shaded so it was actually very nice to sit outside. Our waitress, Cheryl, was awesome! Friendly, attentive and a great sense of humor. Everything we ordered was tasty! I had the french dip. Very generous portion of roast beef! I took half of it home! My older daughter had hot wings... and she said yes... definitely hot! Younger daughter had the chicken french panini. I had a bite and it was amazing! Mom/Gramma had a build your own burger and she said it was fantastic. You can get fries, waffle fries, tater tots or mac salad as sides. I love the choices. I will definitely go back and would highly recommend!

This is my second encounter with this restaurant. We just threw $35 out the window. Hubby decided to try a different restaurant from the one where we always get our fish fry . Bad move...two big servings of over cooked, hard ,greasy awful fish. The cole slaw tasted spoiled and the fries were rubbery. Wow lesson learned. NEVER Again!!!! I tried to call but got a constant busy signal...understandable ..it is Lent. I think I will give this place up for Lent. My husband waited on hold for 15 minutes for this. Be advised .... not good.

Very popular location. The bar was jammed, but they don't take reservations this was the downside. Once we were seated the service was quick and friendly. The food was delicious and the portions were very large. Overall it was an excellent value.

My husband and I were out running errands on a Saturday and decided to grab a drink and a snack here. The bar area was packed with people, but a nice couple were leaving as we looked around for a place to sit, so they offered us up their seats! We gladly took them, and each ordered a beer. They have a good selection of draft beers and an even better bottled/canned selection! The menu is full of delicious sounding bites to eat, and I could smell pork cooking (which smelled mouthwatering!) We only wanted a snack as we had dinner plans later that evening, so we ordered the fried cheese curds - so so soooooo good! Better than any mozzarella sticks I have ever had! The dip has a slight kick to it, but it complimented the cheese curds fantastically! As we walked out afterwards, I told my husband we HAVE to return again to get a better sample of the menu in our bellies! I will be back!

We've given pub 235 a couple chances over the past 6 months and both experiences weren't great. The food is solid however the service both times was absolutely terrible. It took 15 minutes to get drinks and food was about 45-1 hour after ordered.

We went here on a whim with friends on a Friday night. It was already pretty packed when we arrived and we were told the wait would be about 45min. Our friends drove across the city so we figured we'd stay and just get drinks while we waited. Luckily some bar spots opened up and we were able to watch hockey and baseball and sip our drinks while we waited. I went back to the hostess to check on our status and also request a table in the bar area. They were very nice and accommodating and we were seated soon after that. The bartenders were friendly and even made sure to refill our pub mix. Drink prices were good and wine pours were nice. We started with fried Mac cheese and wood fired ravioli. The Mac cheese was homemade and delicious with an amazing cheese sauce. The raviolis were perfectly breaded and had the right balance of cheese and breading. The marinara was delicious. We all really enjoyed our entrées: BYO pizza, bacon cheeseburger with waffle fries, meatball sub special with waffle fries, and Haddock French. Haddock French was perfectly breaded and just the right amount of sherry and lemon. absolutely delicious! We will certainly be back and bring more friends!

Local great family !!! Great food options and big servings ! Never leave hungry and always a great happy staff

My mom and I stopped in for lunch after meeting with a florist at Kittelberger. It's a very cute restaurant with a nice patio area that has real hops growing on the fence. Our waitress was very friendly and helpful. They have a good selection of beers, wine, and cocktails. I ordered the Greek salad with garbanzo beans, and my mom ordered the corned beef Reuben with waffle fries. My salad was fresh and delicious, My mom said hers was excellent and very filling. I really enjoyed having lunch here. It was beautiful out and the atmosphere was great. The only recommendation would be a couple more vegetarian options. They have a veggie burger and salads but a veggie wrap or another option would be awesome. I'm not in Webster often, but I'll definitely stop in again when I get a chance.

Newer restaurant so the trendy aspect is still working. The food was fresh and prepared creatively. Nice atmosphere and good service. Would definitely go back.

Good food (small portions), cold beer and nice friendly service staff. Make sure to try the roast beef sandwich.

Food is better than typical pub food. The service is great. You can eat in the small dining area, the "outdoor" or the bar area. I prefer the ambiance of the small dining area.

Good food, prices a little high, covered outdoor seating is great except in the summer when the sun blasts you.

I've been meaning to try this place for a while now- glad we finally did! Cute, casual atmosphere. Huge menu option... took us forever to choose. Turkey wrap was very good. Everyone enjoyed their meals... 4 stars due to some meal mix-ups but overall a nice meal out!

Well, Food, AMAZING! Entertainment, solid. Staff, best ever! Loved this place, the friends, the atmosphere, the "Northern experience"

Went during lunch and ordered a French dip on a pretzel roll. Very tasty and a nice amount of meat. I paired this with a side salad with balsamic vinegar dressing and enjoyed the dressing a lot. I will definitely be back for the French dip again.

Overall the place is very nice. I had the special appetizer which was pulled pork nachos on tater tots and they were spectacular. But, the issues came with the entree. Smokehouse burger was just a stack of frozen products. Microwave bacon, frozen onion ring, and worst of all, a frozen, prepackaged burger Patty. It was awful. Just make a beef Patty folks. It's not that hard and probably costs less. And roast your Brussel sprouts. 5% of the population wants boiled sprouts with a vinaigrette on them. Nasty. I'll be back, but definitely for different menu items.

Food is very good and atmosphere is nice. I like their menu and going in for just drinks.

I've been here two times in the last few months and both times the food was delicious. The first visit I had a New York strip sandwich (special) with caramelized onions and au jus dip, which was delicious. Second visit I had the chicken French panini, which was unique and also delicious. Their fries are delicious, though I was not a fan of the Mac and cheese. Service is decent. The outdoor seating is nice, with the exception of loud cars and motorcycles peeling out of the back lots. Out of the restaurant's control and just because the location, but still disruptive when you're trying to enjoy yourself. Will go here again.