MalTorero
Google
While not perfect, this place is very special. It was in transition to new owners when we were there, so a few things needed to be updated and I'm sure they will be. That said, part of the charm is its rusticity, so I really hope they don't make it too schmick. The island is the perfect size - big enough to really explore (see cows, sheep, goats, ride horses, hunt for crabs in the mangroves, etc) and have villas well apart. The people are amazing: we will remember locals like Johnny, Sale, Henry, Sam, Ollie and many more for a long time, who were like friends to us. The locals who did the fire show were great too - personalised, not slick like you'd get in Fiji. Just an incredible adventure if you have kids - highly recommended.