Reposteria Nitin

We purchased a pineapple cake on 2/20/26 for a birthday celebration. When we distributed it for everyone to try, we immediately noticed that the pineapple was spoiled and the cake overall tasted old. After cutting and serving it, everyone left their slice on the plate because it was not enjoyable. We had to go out and buy another cake last minute since it was for a birthday. It was very disappointing, especially because we have been customers here before. Unfortunately, the quality of the cakes has declined. When we called to inform them about the issue, it seemed as though they did not care. Please see the picture attached — the pineapple cake was the old one, and the white cake was the replacement we had to purchase elsewhere. Please be mindful when purchasing cakes that are not made to order, as you do not know how long they may have been sitting out. Considering the prices, we expected much better quality and customer service.

Bought a cake today and was very disappointed. This cake was dry and light. Dominican cake is usually moist and heavy. How are you charging more for less quality? It tasted like pound cake with frosting. This was not a true authentic Dominican cake. This place used to have great Dominican cakes.

Everything I bought here was delicious. The donut and cake were very fresh. They also sell a delicious oatmeal which is good for a quick morning breakfast.

Ready-to-buy cakes are good and the right sizes from 1/2 lb to 1 lb. 1lbs.=$50 They do custom cakes, should be placed in advance obviously. 🎂 Experience: Younger woman at register seemed annoyed when I came. I told her I want a birthday cake with vanilla filling with pink decorating. She just stared at me and then pointed at paper with the prices per weight of cake. As if she can't just say it. On top of that, she talked to friend that came in and she just straight up talked to him for the next 10 minutes. Completely ignoring the fact I was waiting for my cake. Wanted to get her attention but afraid she might get mad and deny me some cake. I was hoping to talk with the older woman on the phone. She seemed nicer, like a grandmother wanting to serve you the cake you want! 🎂

We always get the guava cake yearly for celebrations because it’s the best ! This year we got the guava with ninja turtle decor for my nephews 3rd birthday ! Loved it !

Amazing they made my cake for my 23rd. The exact way that I wanted it beautiful design and tasted so good!

Friendly service, but the quality of their cakes has gone down over the years. The filling tastes like it was made from cheap ingredients and the cake itself lacks moisture. Adding more butter will go a long way ! The only thing that has not changed is the frosting. Please bring back the authentic Dominican cake I fell in love with.

The Dominican Guava cake went from being one of the best in the Bronx, to the worst. The guava now taste like candy sort of Strawberry like. This has been happening to a lot of bakeries here in the Bronx, this was my last Good Cake spot. Now, I have to go all the way to Brooklyn to Angela's Bakery to get authentic Guava taste. (See Image..Filling too light looks like candy)

Best Dominican cake ever! They always have some ready.... And I love their coffee cookies

Customer service was abysmal! I walked into the storefront and the one woman working at the counter did not acknowledge that I was standing directly in front of her at the counter as she continued to text on her phone. After I politely and eagerly greeted her she still did not look up, return my greeting or smile, and just proceeded to retrieve the $80.00 cake from the fridge. If a customer walks into your brick and mortar establishment, the proprietor should at the very least appear to welcome your business, acknowledge your presence and thank you for your business. I wondered if these best practices are simply not part of their culture. The cake was subpar to say the least, plain and not worth the steep cost. Many other pastry shops not too far from the Concourse on nearby Arthur Ave and I will take my business elsewhere. I only went there to help a coworker transport her cake. Never again!

the server was pretty nice and the dulce de leche cake is incredible! My family gets it every year for my birthday

These guys are in a Dominican-heavy, prime location in the Grand Concourse area. Just a few doors down from where we did our taxes, I avoided looking Nitin's way but was easily tempted by their Dominican Pastries and Sweets. Dominican Cake is sinfully delicious with a unique texture and ratio- which doesn't compare to Yellow, White Cake or Pound Cake. Any Dominican (or not) can make the cake- but the thing is so freaking daunting to make, majority of Dominican folks go out of their way to endlessly search for a great Dominican baker. Place is practically the size of a LEGO®. But there's a variety of Dominican Cookies, Desserts and lots of cartoonish Cake toppers. Write ups here complain about horrible customer service- and I can almost see it. But listen...get your stuff, crack a smile, be on your way- and stop b*tching. Decided on 2 slices of Dominican Cake with Guayaba, a Raisin Cake and a Cortado for me and Mom. But Nitin is more known for their full Dominican Party Cakes- than anything else One decent try is all I needed and $11 for my 4 items was doable. I'll be honest though- my Guayaba-filled, Dominican Cake slice was moist and the Guayaba in it was fresh- but it was steering more like raspberryish ó¿ò. Really nothing like the one I grew up on- but was edible.

The cake was good. But it's not what I agreed upon when ordering the cake for a baby shower. I got a lot of attitude the first time I went to order. The second time they were more polite. However they said they could accomplished something they clearly couldn't handle. On the day of the shower after paying $360.00 dollars for the cake . Another bakery worker wanted to charge me more for a ribbon that was already agreed upon. The customer experience here is not good. The cake decor is lackluster. What saves this place is that the taste of the cake was good. (How I received the cake, the end result and what it had to come close to looking like)

I was desperately looking for a place to do my gender reveal cake and after being disappointed at the customer service of a "well recommended" spot and another over priced bakery I was quickly losing hope. My partner recommended me to a bakery in the Bronx and at first I was a little skeptical. I went and was surprised by how nice the staff was. The two young ladies were incredibly helpful in assisting me-over the phone and in person. They had a fast turnaround and were super nice..expressing excitement at opening my sealed envelope with thw baby's gender. The day I went to pick up my cake it was raining but they were very busy nonetheless. I was very happy with my cake and the price was affordable. My family and I cut the cake thay night at our gender reveal dinner and we were ecstatic! The cake was a nice pink color-a girl!!!!! Besides yhe cake looking oh so pretty, it tasted quite good. They told me because of the color of the cake it would taste sweeter. I def recommend this bakery! Thanks girls!!!!

I purchased a flan. It was frozen , and super sweet (melao). I told the lady in the cashier, it has a bad taste its frozen, hard and super sweet i can't eat it. She said " if i give ypu another one it will be the same; then i told her change it for something else, she said " you taste already. But she said if she give me another one it will be the same ‍.. she rather lose a customer than let the customer leave satisfied, i tild her just keep it i am going to it it anyways. Most owners think that we are animals adding extra sugar to what they make, its not proper they want to kill us . Too much sugar is not good, it can make you sick from diabetes( and that is one of the worse thing you can get). I WILL NEVER COME BACK..!!

My favorite place to get a good slice of piña bizcocho. The chocolate dipped cookies are amazing too.

It was a bright sunny day, my friend Marleny and I were exploring the Fordham area of the Bronx without much entertainment. It seemed that everyone was cut from the same piece of thread... boring. Everyone dressed the same, the stores all sold the same things. Our senses were underwhelmed by our surroundings, so we made a few turns, walked up this block and down this block until we saw a bakery. Me: wanna go in? Marleny: no, I'm not in the mood to be disappointed. Me: shut up, let's go. So we walked in and looked around, it looked like a pretty typical bakery, cakes and cookies and coffee and stuffs... but... um... wait... they were Mexican? What you must understand in that I grew up in a Dominican neighborhood and think that all bakeries with elaborately designed cakes in the window to be Dominican bakeries. I was proven wrong. But it felt oh so right. Being adventurous we order a tres leche cake (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tres_leches_cake) and some coffee. Now, I've had some banging a$$ tres leches so I was skeptical. But then I ate it. And then I was in love. It was perfect in every way. Moist but not gooey. Sweet but not cavity inducing. Perfection. And that's not all they make that's awesome. During a Superbowl party my friends got me a birthday cake from that bakery and it was delish! If you are ever in the area, do yourself a favor and get me a tres leche cake... I mean, get YOU one... and me.

The original Resposteria Nitin in Santo Domingo is known as the best cake shop. This one has very good Dominican cake but not quite as perfect as the original one. I got my boyfriend a 3/4 pound cake with dulce de leche filling for his birthday and it was very good. You can place an order the same day a couple of hours in advanced. Cash only.

You would be hard pressed to find a Dominican cake as moist and tasty as the ones in this place! Order ahead because they only make a limited amount to sell each day and they go quick!

Horrible Customer service! As a Dominican, it saddens me that this kind of service is what leads people to make general assumptions of our culture. If I'm ordering a cake is because I have a happy occasion happening the least I expect is a nice attitude, not a rude, don't bother me or ask me any questions attitude. Is a pity because their cakes are awesome and so are the pastries but I've yet to see someone with so much attitude when attending a customer.

I think this place has the best pastelitos EVER. I always place large orders for parties and they are amazing!!! They are small and very well done, not over fried or anything like that. They have chicken, beef, cheese and they also sell quipes. Overall super great and super cheap, a dozen is ONLY $9. Go try them !!

Worse experience yet again!!!! I have not ordered from here in years!!! My sister told me she had a good experience and told me they weren't being cheap with the cake filling anymore. I ordered a dulce de leche cake for a baby shower and the day of the shower the girl cuts it open and it's pineapple. It was embarrassing after promising everyone they were getting dulce de leche to get the nasty pineapple. I'm disgusted with the service and when I called all they offered me was $5! It's bullshit and I'm never ordering from these incompetent workers again!

Horrible and nasty attitude, is what you will find here. Not proffesional at all. The younger lady with the glasses is very nice and helpful but the older woman is just a jerk. I held my mouth out of respect but it would be the last time I go there. Smh

I have been to Nitin Bakery several times for several years, the Dominican cake is good, but I had encounter sometimes that the cake is a little dry but the frosting is fantastic. They are a little stinchy with the flowers on the cake, and you have to reinforce what you want. The interpersonal relationships with the staff, generally Dominican women needs improvement, they need to be a little more invited, they need to smile and please deliver your service like you want to serve the customer. But I still buy my cakes there for many years possibly 3 to 4 times a year regardless, I always send my husband to buy it. Nitin Bakery is good for the Dominican cakes.

At all honesty here, the cake is not Dominican , maybe the owners of the bakery are but not the taste of the cakes! I went and purchased a cake for my mothers bday (huge mistake) since my mother only eats real Dominican cakes, and everyone was excited when they saw me walking through the door with it and placing IT on the table. After we sang happy bday and all and moved on to cutting the cake... What a disappointment, to make the story short the cake was thrown in the garbage... $40 down the drain just like that... The pineapple taste like if it was from a cheap brand and the cake was dry and had no flavor at all!!!! Horrible experience. I gave it a star because I had to but this place might be owned by Dominicans but they are defenately not the ones making the cakes in the back of the store!

My family has been buying cakes from Nitin for over 15 years. Best cake hands down. Everything they make is always fresh and full of flavor, from Pastelitos to the cakes. My favorite is the Guava filling cakes. If in the area make sure you stop by this bakery.

Customer service here is absolutely terrible!!!!!. Would not recommend their cakes either. The place on Jerome and 183rd has better service, cakes and are more reasonably priced. The Reposteria Nitin over charges for cake toppers that can easily be made for a few bucks at home, which is what I always do anyway. What the heck will I do with a ceramic baby worth $60 after the cake is eaten?! Anyone I've ever come across who has dealt with this place always had negative things to say !

HORRIBLE customer service. The workers see you walk in and pay you no attention. The older gentleman needs to learn how to speak to his customers, he's very rude and a smart a**. Ordered a dozen cupcakes, they were ok.

I bought a cake yesterday at around 6:30ish and when I got home to cut the cake it was nasty it was hard and the frosting was hard. So dissapointed that they would sell me a cake like that. I called to complaint and no one answers. I have bought plenty of cakes from them and never had this experience. I would definetely reccomend to not sell cakes that been sitting out for so long just to make a sale. Super dissapointed not sure if I can purchase a cake from them again.

The best Dominican bakery! I am a huge fan of their bread loafs that are baked at the bakery daily. I've been coming to this bakery since I was a child. Over the years, I've purchased cakes, bread and appetizers- I have no complaints.

loved how the cake looked they dont get five stars because the top decoration had some dust and I think is because they didn't wipe it before putting it on the cake and i had to wipe myself other than that the cake was great

One word HORRIBLE. Extremely rude. I ordered a cake but they made a mistake and made it with the wrong filling, i asked if they could change it they tell me no they cant give me another one because they already made it . So i ask can i get my money back they say no because they don't give refunds. Apart from that the owner gets rude with me calling me a liar saying that i ordered that filling when i didnt and raising his voice . Just an overall horrible experience. I got stuck with a cake i didn't want when it was their mistake in the first place. So if you want expensive cakes and to pretty much be treated like garbage then go ahead. Otherwise stay AS FAR AWAY AS POSSIBLE!

Do not waste your time! Went yesterday to order a cake and it was bad! There was no customer service and they don't have any graduation themes and for 2pound cake wanted to charge $110 I ordered the cake with guava and it was supper dry and too sweet

WOW .. i agree with tamara ..their customer service sucks .. they act like they doing u a favor or something .. and unless its the regular things they have on the window they dont do anything else.. their answer always is "oh we cant do that " they need to hire new help and teach them the meaning of customer service !! i used to love that place growning up my mom and step dad would by there cake just because they were in the mood for something sweet and good ! but as the years went by and i guess the owner change that place has gone down hill. AND DUE TO THERE RUDE WORKERS I STOP GOING THERE . SIMPLE AS THAT ! SO NOW I HATE THAT PLACE !! all thanks to the workers I DID LOVE THOSE CAKES ... GOOD CAKES BUT THEIR WORKER ARE HURTING THEIR BUSINESS !!!

Tamara I couldn't agree with you more, cakes are good, but service is terrible. I have always wonder why ugly people have a face and an attitude only makes them uglier. The should trained them in service or get rid of them all. I remember going into the bakery to get a cake can you believe I had to wait about 15 minutes to be serve because all employees including the kitchen were having a personal conversation, and then it happen after almost 20 minutes believe it or not, one of them said standing between the kitchen and the counter area, "QUE TU QUIERE? TERRIBLE EXPERIENCE :(

The cakes are average. The breads are ok. The flan tasted like fridge. If you are desperate for a cake you can come get one here.

This place is just plain disgusting. Came here looking for my child's 3rd birthday party cake that a friend recommended and out desperation I decided to give it a try. Well let's just say the women/ owner persuaded me that she's the best in the business, but the cake is dry and it's not dominican cake, she claims its dominican cake, but she isn't. She doesn't know how to design cakes and she's pricey. Go somewhere else and don't settle like I did.

Bought a cake from here and it did not taste like dominican cake at all, it was just tasted bad. Their staff is rude and they are way overpriced. I do not recommend this place unless you want to waste your money.

Their cakes are pretty good.I always order from them for special occasions .I wish them continued success.