Thomas K.
Yelp
This is a solid 4.5 star restaurant. We debated whether or not to give a 4 or 5, and decided upon the 4 because although the food was great we also didn't find it as good as many of the $$ restaurants we visited. As a $$$ restaurants we have a somewhat higher expectation and so settled on the 4 stars.
We chose La Cordonerrie for our last dinner in Paris during our 10-day vacation to the City of Lights. We started the meal with a glass of champagne, and ordered the Chervre Frais (fresh, warm goat cheese) and the Terrine de Canard (Duck Pate). Both were excellent choices with the warm fresh bread. The warm goat cheese was extraordinary in that it was the creamiest cheese I've eaten, and the semi-bitter, semi-sweet red beet mouse really complimented the cheese well. I'd highly suggest trying this. I've also included a photo too.
For dinners, we ordered the chicken fillet, which was very tender and tasty and served with a Lemmon-butter and rosemary sauce. It was good, but I liked the potatoes they were served with even better. Similarly, my daughter's scallops were very good, but the vegetable mix (leek, cauliflower, and some others I couldn't identify) was even better than the main course. Not that it's not a criticism of the main course, but rather a complement to the accompanying food.
I personally thought the lamb steak was the best of them all. It was tender and tasty. My wife got the steak with challots, which has already been reviewed about multiple times and was very good.
The fries served with the lamb and steak were somewhat soggy. They were tasty, but probably not my favorites.
I also thought the service was excellent. The Chef and owner came out to the tables. It was an intimate environment. Only say 15 on the main dining room. I also noticed that 100% of the guests were American, which was surprising since it's off the beaten path.
One other thing of importance is that there are a couple La Cordonnerie restaurants in Paris, so be careful when using Uber or iMaps that you have the right one.
I also suggest making a reservation since the restaurant is so small and has limited hours. They were unresponsive to the Yelp messenger, but we're very helpful when we called.
Last but not least, the desserts! The Faudant au Chocolat was like a chocolate lava cake and we had to beg my 8yr old some to let us at least try a taste of it. It was awesome. My daughters Mango Mouse was also very good, and the bananas Flambe was a big hit too.
One other thing that my wife and I liked was their 1/2 bottle wine selections. Since we started the meal with champagne, we typically would only want one large glass of wine (6.5oz pour) each with dinner, and these half bottle selections were high-end but affordable since they were half the price of a full bottle.