Ristorante Pizzeria Il Paguro

We had a very average to poor experience here on a Sunday evening. The Caprese salad was disappointing as the tomatoes were rather green (not ripe) and tasteless & the basil had large, bitter leaves. Costing €12.50 I had expected much much better. The grilled red chicory was rather good. One pizza was good, the other poor. I had the mixed mushroom with buffalo mozzarella. The pizza came out with a layer of liquid on top that made the undercooked base very soggy. I suspect the mushrooms were frozen and they didn’t cook it long enough but if they did then the mozzarella would burn. Really poor cooking here or they don’t care as the tourists normally only come once to the restaurant. Go for the standard pizza. We didn’t have the pasta but at the table next door the portion sizes looked small. Overall it wasn’t good value. The place is busy, so I suggest you make a reservation. We didn’t and luckily we got the last table for 2 at 7.10pm, just after they opened. There is inside seating but there is no air conditioning, therefore it seemed hot when we went to pay.

After driving around Alghero trying to find somewhere to eat to no success, we Arrived just before 19:00 and was greeted very friendly by the waiter. He spoke good english and took our order straight away. Our food was served after 15mins. It was excellent and fresh. Can highly recommend.

Went for lunch. Was told much of the menu wasn't available as it was lunchtime(!), including pizza not offered at lunchtime for some strange reason. Annoyingly we only found this out after trying to order. All very odd despite being called Ristorante "Pizzeria" il Paguro! Roasted boar also wasn't available which was my second choice. So in the end we were left with a very limited selection of lunchtime choices which was disappointing. Outdoor patio gazebo is very nice to sit in, but unfortunately the roof structure helps the cigarette smoke to linger for all the non-smoking patrons while eating. Service seemed abit off to me, they weren't particularly busy at all but it almost felt like they were overwhelmed. Desserts were good, though nothing exceptional enough to make me return. I have many favourite restaurants in the Alghero/Fertilia area so don't think I'll be returning il Paguro.

Very good restaurant! They have the best pizza and wine. The staff are also very kind, good service!

Atmosphere is great. Food is good enough, but not perfect. And service is slow, and require reminders, xD

Food is ok. Not great but not awful either. Pasta was over-salted. Pizza was average.. salt and pepper was served in sachet, not exactly a restaurant style:)

Great food sadly service at the start was not great , unfortunately our drinks were forgotten so waited 20 minutes but after that, it was all very good. lasagne and gnocchi both gorgeous. Would definitely go back again....very authentic lots of Italians dining....very reasonable prices too

Seems like it's a decent restaurant for getting a pizza. Was not impressed with the menu otherwise. Ordered the pork steak which came with no side, the vegetables mentioned in the description are only decorative (i. e. 4 leafs of ruccola). Therefore to the €12.5 of the dish you have to add another €5 for the side. The other item we got was a plate of Culurgiones, but it had just 5 pieces. We waited about 40 minutes for the food when the restaurant was not at full capacity.

We got into Fertilia pretty late at night and mostly everything was closed except Paguro. They have tons of pizzas, fresh seafood and pasta options. We had just come from Naples and were sick of pizza so we opted to order something from the entree list even though the server warned us it may take a little longer. We had no problem waiting as we were seated on the breezy back patio to enjoy a glass of wine. Our food came out within 20 minutes or so, not as long of a wait as I expected. I got a platter of sea bream with mussels, clams and veggies. My sister got the bowl of mussels. The sea bream was delicious and well cooked. The sauce had a nice flavor but wasn't too overwhelming. The fish had a few tiny bones to work around but it wasn't a huge deal. It was a nice meal with good service - they accommodated us late in the evening and we really appreciated it.

Defenitely one of the better places in Fertilia. The Restaurant offers a wide range, from various meat and fish dishes to a wide selection of pizzas. If you are into seafood, you simply have to try their sautéed mussels. They are simply divine.