Matt W.
Yelp
Oh, good heavens, no. This may be the old main hotel but it's incredibly weary; it's not just that the rooms were cramped and noisy and smelled quite a bit off, they haven't even bothered to do cheap upgrades where they can (see also, the incredible CRT TV). We were just spending the night waiting for the ferry, fortunately, but I can only barely recommend it for that.
The oddity of the night we were there was that they were hosting a wedding (oh, the poor Bride) and had some other event, so we didn't even have adjacent parking. The parking lot across the street, downhill, was dirt and gravel. And we got no help, once again, with our stuff, for love or money.
I realize Yarmouth has seen better times, but I have to think there's a better alternative around for the quick night's stay, and I certainly hope there's one for the longer-term resident.