Morty T.
Yelp
I went there in December, expecting a good experience based on the reviews. I spoke to Danny, and told him I was something of a novice, but I knew what I wanted in terms of quantity and strength. As soon as the word novice left my mouth, I could tell he lost all respect for me, and talked to me like I was some kind of moron. I do know a little about cigars, including "don't be a cigar snob." We all have to start somewhere. Instead of treating people who don't live and die by cigars with disdain, try to be helpful and enthusiastic for them, and maybe they'll become a connoisseur some day because of you. Not think, "Ahh, I see. This is a hobby for snobs."
Despite repeating myself that I wanted only four or five mild cigars, I would up purchasing 10 cigars of varying strenghts (mostly stronger than I or my friends are used to), because well...he didn't listen to a word I said.
The cigars themselves are good, though the cigars were a little dry and cracked on the ends in one of the boxes I purchased. As I said, I am a novice (only having three and a half before these), but the ones I smoked were enjoyable. My friends are about the same level of smoker I am, and enjoyed them too.
I have not been anywhere else in Key West for cigars, but if I return that way, I'll probably try someplace else.