Mark F.
Google
Note for this review: This review is based on the price we paid, which I think is somewhat lower than is typically offered. At the rates I'm seeing today I might go one star lower. We paid 3500USD for a Diamond Club Presidential Suite.
The Good:
1. The diamond club checkin and checkout process were incredibly smooth. We were checked in within 25 minutes while sitting in a nice comfortable lounge.
2. The architecture and landscaping are incredible. Tons of great spots to walk, sit down and watch the sunrise, etc.
3. The resort is sprawling and doesn't feel crowded. We were there at full capacity and often had pools to ourselves, bar lines were short, etc.
4. It's very clean, both room cleaning, public bathrooms, and common areas were all pretty much spotless.
5. Every staff member was super friendly and helpful
6. The buffet food is very good and varied from day to day, much better than I'd expect from a buffet.
7. The resort gym was very good. Better than a lot of commercial gyms I've been to.
8. The presidential suite was huge and the beds, sheets, pillows, etc. were very comfortable.
The Bad:
1. A la carte restaurant food is very inconsistent. While some of it was great (especially the Mexican dishes), other items were quite bland. I'd say about 30% of dishes were great, 70% were a bit dissapointing.
2. There is no lunch available until Noon and no Dinner available until 6, this is tough with a toddler.
3. The apps had the wrong opening and closing times for restaurants, and staff indicated it's been that way for quite a while
4. The room maintenance is quite poor. There were missing tiles on the walls, the roof was peeling off, the fridge was covered in dents, the sinks were loose, and a number of other relatively minor problems.
5. Tap water had an odd sulfury smell.
I think most of the variance you see in food reviews depends on what type of food the reviewer prefers. Some of the cuisines (Mexican especially) were pretty consistently good, others (any American style beef product) were quite poor.
Overall, I'd happily go back if we see a price this good again, I don't think I'd go back at full price.