Jason K.
Yelp
This place knows how to look and act very fancy, complete with a nice big shiny price tag on each entree, but the food failed to impress me. I have to say though - the atmosphere is really nice. We sat by a window overlooking Lake McDonald and it was gorgeous.
I tried the lentil and tomato soup, which was quite bland and boring. I would normally get a burger at a lodge like this, because it's much cheaper and, you know, how can you go wrong with a burger? But I was getting a little sick of burgers because it seems like that's all you can get at a lot of places, so I got the lamb chops. They were alright - they were cooked fine, but the "rosemary garlic demi-glace" was so sparse, it's like they were rationing it. The potatoes and colorful cauliflower and carrots were barely seasoned at all and made me regret trying to eat slightly healthy for once. It wasn't terrible, just kind of average in a disappointing way because of the atmosphere and the fact you are on vacation. All this, and the plate wasn't even very filling, for 25 dollars. I don't know - maybe I'm just your average American male who has gotten used to 2000-calorie over seasoned meals swimming in sauce? Who knows.
One thing that I did love here was the huckleberry ice cream, which I believe started me & my wife's obsession with huckleberries the short time we were in Montana. Also, the service was over-the-top excellent, but it's all part of the show, you know? The atmosphere, service, and presentation were amazing here, but if the food isn't that satisfying, whats the point?