Hunter S.
Yelp
I ordered because of the high rating on DoorDash and the grandma pie. This may be a matter of taste and preference, but I feel the ratings are based on their trendy chicken vodka sauce specialty pizza and neighborhood nostalgia.
They touted their grandma pie as the best in the Bronx. I admit anyone with a grandma pie is up against tough competition because Frank Pinello's grandma slice at Best Pizza is my all time favorite. But this one really missed the mark for me. It was thick and doughy and really reminiscent of a Detroit style pizza. And about 30 bucks, the price is wild (maybe it was increased for DoorDash, and I get that).
I also got a couple separate "regular" slices. One with extra cheese and pepperoni and one with extra cheeses, sausage, and mushroom. Without extras, it's 5.62 a slice on DoorDash, but they are HUGE. So a value. One person could have one slice and be done for the night. That being said . . . a few things. One, the extra cheese is TOO much. Literal mounds. I should have known better than to order extra anything on a first time order. But I think these slices would have been cheese heavy no matter what. Flavor was meh and it was again thick and doughy. And by the time I added any toppings (the mushroom, the sausage, etc), prices were 10-11 dollars for each slice.
Emilio's has garlic knots, several different types of pizza, salads. On lunch they have wraps and mini-8-inch heroes and combos, wings, pasta, soups, calzones, paninis.
I'm not going to tell anyone to not try it out . . . again, a matter of taste. And it was DoorDash. But I think the reviews over-sell it and I wouldn't eat here again.