Charlotte F.
Yelp
While Saint 1881 offers a somewhat ~vibey~ environment, I'm unlikely to return.
The waitress was lovely and attentive. Offered explanations and seemed to care about her tables. I ordered an espresso martini and learned I'm just not an espresso girl. My friend absolutely loved it, so I imagine it is a good cocktail if that's your thing. However, the biscotti cake was very tasty! Moist cake, smooth and creamy mousse, and cutesy presentation. Enough to split for 2, but you could definitely just eat it on your own too ;)
My issues lie with the ambiance and set up of the bar. Firstly, it is beyond loud. I could barely hear my friend sitting across from me. The noise just echoes and travels creating a cacophony of chaos. Then, at the entrance, there is no where for the people coming in to go or stand aside from on top of the tables seated near the door. Which is really uncomfortable being watched and crowded around by the waiting guests. The host stand is up a few stairs past the initial tables by the door, so people are then also crowding the stairs and also the only path for the servers to reach their tables. The amount of times someone walked in front of a server carrying a tray of drinks is countless. The tables on the "main" floor are crowded close together to fit in as many as possible, making the pathway behind the guests seated at the bar and the guests seated at tables, extremely narrow. Especially when there are people standing behind the guests seated at the bar. This should not be allowed. This is the only route to their bathrooms and kitchen as well making it a primary walk way. The bathroom was clean enough but toilet paper was scarce, the lock on the door didn't work, there is no indication of which stall is occupied, and again- it's so loud you cannot hear a thing when knocking.
One thing I wanted to note, the tables at the front are half booth and half chairs and they seat multiple parties next to each other. I did not feel the group of girls next to us were too close when sitting but they were close enough that their squealing, shouting over each other, and flash photography definitely interrupted our evening. When holding the phone out for a selfie, one of the girls hands was definitely in my personal space. The group was overall rather obnoxious and while this is not the doing of the establishment, it is worth noting since you never know who you will be seated next to and this could easily happen to other groups as well.
Learning Saint 1881 and Rochester Brunch House are owned/operated under the same owner was everything I needed to know. While I do not foresee myself returning, I am at least glad I tried Saint 1881 to form my own opinion.