SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill

Great location on the dock overlooking the marina. I sat outside on the covered deck area. Service was friendly. Food was very fresh and good.

I came here on a Sunday afternoon during Labor Day weekend on a day trip to Shelter Island from East Hampton with two others. We made the reservation for a lunch table two days prior on Yelp. Just to start off with, who uses Yelp for reservations any more? This is so dated and honestly emblematic of the experience we had. The setting of the restaurant is fine. Along a Mariana that has covered outdoor seating and plenty of parking. The food is terribly expensive and not good. I got the lobster roll thinking that no one could mess up a lobster roll but I was wrong. The lobster was over cooked and lacking flavor. The snow crab roll was inedible. The people who worked at the restaurant were friendly but a bit odd and like they didn’t really know how to work in a restaurant or communicate effectively. I realize there are not a lot of options on Shelter Island in the summer for meals but I would not go back here and I would not recommend.

SALT is one of my favorite spots on Shelter Island. The setting is beautiful, right on the marina, and it has such a relaxing vibe. I’ve been a few times now and the food is always fresh and delicious. The lobster roll is a standout and the fish tacos are also really good. The staff is friendly and the service is quick, even when it gets busy. It’s a great place to sit outside, enjoy the view, and have a nice meal with friends or family. Every time I go, I leave happy. Highly recommend if you’re visiting the island.

The fact I couldn’t get pictures of the two entree’s should be very telling. Every dish we ordered was fantastic, made with such talent and love. Please do yourself the favor of trying the seared Tuna sandwich!!!! Fantastic. And the Carrot cake is good enough to save the world. A great variety of drinks as well. Blue crab roll is distinctly East end, a diverse taste that feels at home on the docks of SALT. I wish the Artichoke had some more garlic/ginger or just another primary flavor to enhance the artichoke texture and taste. Looking forward to seeing this place in full summer bloom. Come check it out!!

Drinks were eh but the food was good! The vibe was nice , right on the water. We got the Lobster Cobb Salad and the Tuna Poke Bowl.

We made reservations through Open Table and were seated promptly upon arrival. The wait staff was friendly and always had a smile on their faces. Salt is a nice laid back and cozy eatery with nice views. The menu had a nice mix of food to choose from and was amazingly well prepared. We had a wonderful time and will definitely be coming back.

We had the sweetest waitress! She was not only super bubbly but she was on top of everything. Nice clam chowder. While it was fresh, we thought the poke bowl was a bit dull considering how many options there are when you go to a poke restaurant Throwing on some toasted sesame seeds, scallions, edamame, nori flakes, sliced cucumbers shredded carrots, shredded red cabbage, crispy onions from a jar, etc. could go a long way in making this dish more tasty, delightful and colorful without increasing the food cost very much. BF enjoyed his lobster roll which was expensive but had a lot of lobster on it. Probably enough for two lobster rolls in the city.

Salt was great for a Sunday lunch. The GF and I, took the ferry over in the morning. Drove around and checked out the island. We ate lunch at Salt. I recommend you make reservations as it fills up fast. I had the Lobster Roll and she had a sushi roll. We sat outside, right next to the boats docked. The atmosphere was great on a beautiful Sunday. Service was great and the food was delicious. We plan to return.

Ambience was great beautiful view watched the wedding happening So this was attentive, even with a 15 month old Food was good. Drinks were delicious.

Was visiting the island and found the rudest service I've had in a decade at this place. Specifically at the Shipwreck outside bar. My friend asked for a cocktail after we waited 10min for service. The bartender said we don't make it and walked away. 10min later he comes back and my friend asks for a red bull, apparently a ridiculous ask. Bartender says no and walks away again. At this point we're looking at each other confused. Bartender says if you're going to be d**** you can leave. Meanwhile the couple waiting next to us were literally yelled at by another bartender and told that she's busy and that they can leave if they don't want to wait. We all left. Needless to say, don't go there.

Burger was very good but $28 Lobster roll good but $48 Clam Chowder good but $16 for small bowl Here's the kicker $24 for Carrot cake, yes it's a big portion but not necessary to be Costco size. $5 for bread and butter? Come on There was a party of 10-12 having too much fun. They were very loud and the restaurant did nothing. Despite all the above, quality food and fun place. Would go again just be aware of the above.

Nice place on the water in shelter island. Our waitress was super nice. We ordered sushi and muscles for appetizers. They were just ok. I got the chicken Milanese. It tasted pretty good. But it is usually served with arugula not red leaf lettuce. For dessert i finally got my mudslide. Which was also ok. Overall a nice place. Food was just ok.

Food is always amazing and the service is just the best! Can't beat the view either

Good service, nice views being at the waterfront. I liked that there was a merch store connected to the restaurant, as well! Good options to choose from in the menu.

This is our favorite family restaurant on Shelter Island. We really enjoy the delicious food, the warm atmosphere, and the friendly service every time we visit.

This was our last dinner on Shelter Island and so glad we chose Salt! We honestly felt like we were in the tropics or another waterfront destination far from Long Island. We got to sit outside, right on the dock which was a nice view of the water and its boats. Our server was super friendly and helpful, and knew the menu well. We were interested in the "butter service" appetizer which ended up being such a nice choice! We had so much butter leftover that we took it with us to use again! The sushi rolls were fresh and thoughtfully prepared. Our entrées were excellent and I highly recommend the warm lobster roll! Salt was such a great experience that this will likely be our first stop the next time we visit Shelter Island!

My boyfriend and I had a late lunch at Salt. He had the poke bowl and I had the lobster roll. Both were very good. Local oysters were interesting and wonderful. I had the most sublime lavender lemonade and my boyfriend had a Bloody Mary which he said was great. Service was friendly and quick. Sitting outside under an umbrella was fun whilst watching the boats come in. Pricy but understandable because of the location. Highly recommend.

Quaint little restaurant in the marina on shelter Island the service was excellent and quick, the food was very good. The lobster roll was a bit pricey so was everything else but it was highly recommend. Definitely will come back.

overrated! very pricey even though expected price being out here food was just ok. Over cooked fish, average lobster roll, dry withered fries. Atmosphere was nice

Top tier establishment, the staff is friendly and fun! Shoutout to Luciana !Food was exceptional and the portions are generous as well as great quality. Highly recommend! Well done!

I enjoyed the laid-back, casual vibe at Salt. While the food wasn't outstanding, it's definitely worth trying. The service was a bit slow, but the staff was friendly and accommodating. I ordered the TUNA POKÉ, which was fresh, but the ginger had an off taste--almost as if it had been left out too long or wasn't of good quality.

The food is wonderful, the cocktails are amazing, and the people are all time - so kind, responsive, and efficient. The vibe is perfect rain or shine!

SALT is way more than a restaurant, it is a summertime institution on Shelter Island, and in the off-season a haven for residents through long Autumnal evenings and Spring's Awakening. The food is always amazing, served with great care by local owners. They set the standard of a legend.

Service, food and wine were not good. Tuna on crispy rice was limited and did not seem fresh.

Great afternoon as we stopped in with Friends, riding our bikes, the staff at the winery was very friendly and show tremendous hospitality when we discussed the wines that they carried. We're able to take our wine and sit out on the beautiful lawn in the in Adirondack chairs, and enjoy the beautiful afternoon. I highly recommend this little hidden gem for everyone that reads this review to give this place a try

Pleasant waterfront restaurant along the docks, nice outdoor bar with live music adjacent. Ample parking, all seating is on dock or under tent. Fare is standard summer beach offerrings. Crabcake app with mint chutney was the clear highlight of apps. Calamari, tuna sandwich also nicely done. Drink selection better than to be expected, would revisit

The hostess was extremely unfriendly and unhelpful. We asked to sit outside for our cocktails - we were only going to be there for an hour. The hostess said all the tables were reserved, although they were mostly unoccupied. She said that the only option was to sit inside, in the bar, although with the step up, this was difficult for my friend who has mobility issues. One hour later, when we left, the tables outside were still empty so we could have sat there after all. Totally unfriendly, rude. Not going back.

Food was very good . Had salmon, lobster rolls and the sushi. All fresh . The piece de resistance was the dessert-Carrot cake for two , truly for 3-4 people. Friendly service . Go enjoy!

First time dining in Shelter Island and our party was a bit disappointed. Our food took over an hour and a half to come and drinks took 30+ minutes. Our waitress, Jackie, was super sweet and improved our experience. The food was delicious so that made up for the wait times. I would recommend only coming here with a small party--- our group was a party of 10 and it does not seem like they have proper kitchen staff to accommodate that party size.

Excellent service. Great place to stop for lunch if you are on a day trip like we were. I enjoyed the Tuna Poke, the Mezzo appetizer, and of course a tall Narragansett. Beer was cold and the food was fresh. Pleasant outdoor seating overlooking the marina.

Ida is a great server, friendly, helpful. Food is fresh new items every season. We will be back.

The food was super delish and very fresh. Katelyn E was an amazing server. Ask for her ! She was very attentive and was awesome.

Good food. Nice sized portions. Service is hit or miss but you can't beat the views of the marina

Salt is a great spot to enjoy a drink and look at boats. The service is earnest- but the kitchen needs work. The mesclun salad was wilted. The tuna was not fresh. The chowder was great- best thing in the dinner. Nice cocktail and beer choices. Uneven food. I suggest going for drinks and chowder- maybe oysters/ clams.

Service was A++++, our server, Jackie, was such a gem, wow. The best attitude, so friendly, just amazing vibes. She was such a bright light in our evening. Also, the food was fantastic, actually the best lobster roll I've ever had!!

Had a lovely time! Great food, wine, and service. Definitely recommend SALT for lunch or dinner!

You can get here by boat or ferry easily. Still not as warm so they had a tent with a heater for outdoor seating. Service was great with our party of 8, and the food was phenomenal.

Great place for lunch on the weekends. Katelyn E was our server she was excellent and super helpful with our little kids. Sushi was delicious!

Good food and service and a lovely setting. Have been going here for years! A favorite of the entire family.

Very nice dinner here tonight with family. Clams on the 1/2 shell, fried calamari and dumplings as apps were delicious. A few of us had the steak and a few had the burger. Both delicious! Good menu good service . Def would go back

When arriving ... it's a beautiful scene and ambiance is great too . The people who work there are so inviting and sweet. The food and presentation is fresh and all delicious I have had many dishes this year already .... Keeps me coming back to try other terrific things .

Food so so definitely not go back service was terrible To noisy. I would say boat front not exactly water front

I came here on a Sunday afternoon for lunch with a group of 5 people. This is one of the few restaurants on Shelter Island. We ordered clam chowder, lobster rolls, and fish tacos. The clam chowder was creamy, seasoned well, and full of ingredients (bacon, clams, potatoes). The lobster roll bun was well toasted and buttery. The lobster was a bit bland though. The fries were very crispy. The fish tacos were tasty and well seasoned. I didn't like that they use takeout containers instead of actual plates. I understand it's cleaner but it's wasteful to use so many disposable things. Service was very fast and friendly. I would come back if I'm ever in the area.

Love this place! Great food and relaxed vibe. Reminds me of the Caribbean. The rum punch is excellent.

The outdoor patio was very welcoming and the weather was perfect for sitting outdoors. The calamari, salmon dinner, Oysters, and chocolate lava cake were delicious! The spicy tuna roll was tasty, too. The server was also very sweet.

Beautiful place with great views and A great menu. We had the veggie burger and sushi along with wings to start and everything was fresh and delicious. Children had chicken sandwiches and pasta 10.00 children's menu is a great deal. Thought other options were a little Pricey but good quality of food. Mimi our sever was sweet and welcoming. Would definitely recommend.

Made a reservation for my very special birthday & mentioned it to person taking it. Was seated on upper level of awning section. Next to a extremely group of 10 inebriated very loud men. I did not want the bar area,this was the restaurant part. The food was passable,not up to par with the extremely high prices for very small portions,cooked poorly. I gave it a 3* only because the waitress was very nice. My special birthdays will not be celebrated here. The view could not be appreciated, since it was blocked. Try another venue.

Nice location. Good food Service was slow considering there were lots of staff just walking around.

One of my favorite places! The food and service were both awesome! We had a lovely dinner in a beautiful setting.

The lobster roll was very good as well as the fries. Had a Jalapeño Margarita to start which was outstanding. However, the service left a bit to be desired. It's hard enough dining on your own, but then when you feel invisible, it's even worse. Took longer than usual for waiter to come to my table. The hostess left a second place setting so he claims he thought I was waiting for another person to arrive. Other than taking my order and asking me if I wanted dessert, he never came back to the table. Not even to see if the food was all right or if I needed anything else. Also, he never offered specials which he did to other tables. To top it off, the "manager", I imagine, stopped at all the tables at some point during everyone's meal to check if everything was okay, but never came to ask me. It is a lovely place, but the staff should be more attentive to everyone.

Food, service and vibes are always on point. You can not go wrong with anything you order either- everything is so yummy! Even have done takeout before and it hits the spot. A staple on the island for our family!

Giving stars for food only. Terrible service, unfortunately. Our main server was what ruined the experience. This feels silly to say, but our beverages/water were never refilled.. When I asked for recommendations or highlights on the menu, she had nothing to say... When I asked about the oysters, I asked if there was a minimum or if I could just order a couple and all I got was a short "No." ................. so then I had to pull teethe and ask, "Okay so how many do I need to order?" Maybe she was having a bad day. Was just odd as we have had an extremely pleasant and beautiful experience on Shelter Island and this was the only negative interaction we had. Looking forward to future vacations here but will gladly dine elsewhere. Ordered calamari, truffle fries and chowder - all were good if you need food reccs. Hopefully you have a nicer server than we did. :)

Never again... we have summered on Shelter Island for more than 25 years and have experienced the full spectrum of the vagaries of restaurant dining (mediocre overpriced food, poor service, etc). Both of our families who also live here recommended SALT. On this particular occasion, we wanted to take our close friends for a reunion celebration and made a reservation here (my first mistake). My wife has mobility challenges (uses a walker) so I scoped / mapped the best approach to the area with open tables and explained that to the 'Hostess' who with apparent indifference (ignorance) insisted on seating us on the upper deck requiring multiple steps to traverse.To minimize the social discomfort for all involved, I acquiesced (second mistake). While visibly struggling to reach it, the tables below remained unoccupied for the duration of our dining. That said, the third-mistake was not to walk away (with some repeated difficulty) despite the self-imposed social pressure. Worth mentioning that the server was perfectly sympathetic and polite - he deserves no blame for the disappointing entrees...

Great waterfront restaurant. Food and service were excellent. Salmon hand roll was great

Not to be dramatic but I was incredibly disappointed. We arrived to wonderful ambiance on the water to an attentive hostess. After we sat down our experience soured. We went for the "Thai shrimp roll special." We expected actual shrimp but were served minced crustaceans which were not what we expected. We dared to also order the fish tacos after seeing several tables send them back. They were equally as awful. As for the service. Well it was just a tad better than the disappointing shrimp roll.

Great location. Great drinks. Delicious chicken wings. Great social distancing. Everyone wearing masks correctly. Love being able to order right from my phone and having the food and drinks delivered to "the Island"

Great atmosphere, it gives off a great summer-beachy and casual vibe. I came with one other person around 6:30 on a Saturday night and we got seated right away. The food came out pretty quickly. We ordered the lobster roll (salt style), greentail roll, mahi mahi tacos, 1/2 dozen pearl oysters, 1/2 dozen gold oysters, and 1/2 dozen clams- everything was amazing. We were surprised with how much lobster we got in the lobster roll- they were nice big chunks of lobster rather than shreds. Greentail roll was a nice twist on sushi, wasn't expecting the fish to be cooked but it was still great. I would definitely come back next time I'm on SI!