Saltaire Market

Life saver on Saltaire. We’ve bought newspapers, groceries, pizza, hot sandwiches, ice cream, even nail clippers here. Has everything you need, but you need an unlimited budget to shop for everything here. It might be the most beloved monopoly in the world! They have to charge freight fees to bring things from Bay Shore, so it’s understandable that the prices are high. I just wish they’d mark every item or shelf with prices. Otherwise, you’re shopping blind most of the time till you get to the cashier. A very friendly, courteous staff adds to the experience.

Best market on FI. Plenty of selection including fresh bagels and pastries, homemade salads and pre-made sandwiches. Prices are reasonable for FI. Worth a stop.

Love this place. Great breakfast sandwiches and their baked goods are amazing. Sandwiches are good. Good selection is pretty great considering the store footprint.

Clean and great selection - esp beer - and the prices are not unreasonable.

Food was ok, and Fire Island prices are to be expected. I was disappointed that the employee making the sandwiches had his mask around his chin while taking orders and bread/bagels were passed over the counter. As it is high counter he breathed all over the food. The employee did put his mask on while actually making the sandwiches, but he had already risked significant exposure due inadequate mask wearing. Saltaire market is adamant that its patrons wear masks. It would be appreciated if their employees extended the same courtesy to their customers.

For the given situation of a grocery store on Fire Island I feel that the quality is amazing. However I give the customer base of saltaire 1 out of 5 stars. They walk in and feel it’s appropriate to talk down to the employees. It’s like the world revolves around them. If you feel it’s appropriate to talk down to a 17 year old seasonal worker you should probably seek therapy.

Definitely serves its purpose on the island. Expensive prices to be expected. Better chicken salad than Fair Harbor. Diverse selection given location and well stocked.

Love the music and all the cool, polite kids working at the market. The food is delish. Quacamole is stellar! Cold brew is intense.