Isabella T.
Yelp
I came to Salumeria for dinner on a Wednesday night with a friend. We had a reservation which I highly recommend since this place was packed already by 5:45pm! Our table was indoors and the ambiance inside the restaurant is just amazing: very elegant, classy, and romantic which would make this place perfect for a nice date. Service was also great, our waiter came by fairly quickly to get our order and gave us some helpful suggestions of what to order. For our dishes we decided to order and split:
Caprese salad: wonderful appetizer and perfect to split between two people. The tomatoes and basil were fresh and deliciously garnished with some high quality olive oil and balsamic. The fresh mozzarella that came with the salad was creamy, with a hint of salt, and balanced out the rest of the dish very well. Had the perfect ratio of tomato to mozzarella, not sure if this was intentional but there was a piece of mozzarella for every tomato wedge and I really appreciated it!
Rigatoni alla Salumeria (large portion): this pasta was amazing. I'm usually not one to get blown away by pasta dishes but the flavor of this dish was out of this world. The cured meats, onions, and pecorino cheese give it so much flavor that is superimposed over this very good, fresh tomato sauce. Pasta was perfectly Al dente for my taste. 10/10 would recommend.
Gnocchi (large portion): probably best gnocchi I've had in NYC since moving here (granted I don't order gnocchi much) but I believe this dish is special. The gnocchi itself has this very complex flavor profile which is probably from the mix of the goat and ricotta cheeses. For those who don't like goat cheese and are worried this might taste too much like it, I actually did not think that flavor was very predominant so I would still recommend that you get this! They just feel like soft pillows with a delicious savory flavor! The tomato sauce they came it was also amazing, I don't understand how they make tomatoes taste so good!
Chocolate mousse: light, sweet, and truly a great way to end the meal. Comes with raspberries that give a nice tart balance to the dessert. It's consistency for me felt thicker than other mousses I have had but still airy enough to feel light. Extremely satisfying.
Overall, I loved this place. I always walk by when I'm in the area and the ambiance from the outside has always intrigued me so I am happy I was able to experience it! Delicious, fresh Italian food, very nice ambiance with great service, and very conveniently located in the upper west side near a lot of other restaurants, bars, supermarkets. A bit on the pricier end but really worth it in my opinion! Will come back again.