Sarabeth's Central Park South

American restaurant · Midtown West

Sarabeth's Central Park South

American restaurant · Midtown West

1

40 Central Park S Located in: 40 West 59th Street Condominium, New York, NY 10019

Photos

Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null
Sarabeth's Central Park South by null

Highlights

Sarabeth’s serves classic, generously portioned American brunch and cocktails just steps from Central Park in a chic, bustling setting.  

Placeholder
Placeholder

40 Central Park S Located in: 40 West 59th Street Condominium, New York, NY 10019 Get directions

sarabethsrestaurants.com
@sarabethsnyc

$30–50 · Menu

Reserve

Information

Static Map

40 Central Park S Located in: 40 West 59th Street Condominium, New York, NY 10019 Get directions

+1 212 826 5959
sarabethsrestaurants.com
@sarabethsnyc
𝕏
@sarabethsnyc

$30–50 · Menu

Reserve

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Jul 30, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@deuxmoi
Celeb frequented restaurants in Manhattan
View Postcard for Sarabeth's

Sergey Mayer

Google
Classic NYC breakfast spot with big portions and great quality — but pricey. We came here for breakfast and really enjoyed the food — everything was fresh, flavorful, and served in generous portions. It’s definitely on the expensive side: breakfast for two adults and a child came out to around $150. There is a kids’ menu, but the staff didn’t mention it initially. We had to ask twice — only then did they provide it, which felt like an unnecessary effort for a family-friendly place. Still, a lovely spot for a classic New York breakfast near Central Park — just be ready to pay for the experience.

S.H. M

Google
Sarabeth’s Central Park South is a popular brunch destination in New York City, known for its classic American fare and prime location steps away from Central Park. I recently visited for a late weekend brunch, and while there were some highlights, a few aspects fell short of expectations. We were seated after a short wait despite having a reservation, and the ambiance was charming—warm lighting, white tablecloths, and a bustling yet comfortable atmosphere. The service was polite but felt a bit rushed and inattentive at times, likely due to how busy the restaurant was. We ordered three brunch staples: an omelet, avocado toast, and the classic hamburger. The omelet was light and fluffy, filled with cheese and vegetables, but the flavor was somewhat muted—it could have used a bit more seasoning. The avocado toast was beautifully presented, topped with ripe avocado, poached eggs, and a drizzle of lemon and olive oil. It was fresh and satisfying, though the portion felt a little small for the price. The standout was the hamburger—it arrived juicy, well-seasoned, and cooked to our request, accompanied by crispy, golden fries that were a hit at the table. Prices were definitely on the higher end, even by NYC standards, which would be more justified if the food were slightly more memorable. That said, the Central Park South location does add to the appeal, especially for visitors who want a classic NYC brunch experience near major landmarks. Overall, Sarabeth’s offers a good brunch with some well-executed dishes and a prime location, but it might not live up to the hype for those seeking bold flavors or exceptional value. Worth trying once for the experience—but maybe not a go-to spot for regular weekend brunches.

Gökay Zeren

Google
We sat here on a Saturday afternoon and didn’t wait a single minute for three of us. They had a dinner pre-fix menu for $50, which included almost every item on their alacarte menu. The burger was decent, the salad and meatballs were good, and the crostata was a great finish. Overall, it was a good experience, and it’s a great spot for people-watching.

Gerardo Guzman

Google
Overall, a pleasant dining experience. This high-end diner offers a solid selection of classic options, with a few standout additions like Eggs Benedict. Portion sizes are generous, and the dishes are well-executed, though nothing particularly extraordinary. The French toast is especially well-prepared and beautifully presented. Service is attentive, although the busy atmosphere can occasionally present some challenges. Additional staff could help improve the flow during peak hours. Restroom availability is somewhat limited given the number of guests. On the bright side, the location is excellent.

Larissa Rivello

Google
We had a reservation for 9 AM, and when we arrived right on time, there was already a line stretching out the door. My husband asked the hostess if having a reservation gave us any priority, but she said no, we had to wait in line like everyone else. So we did. After about 10 minutes, when it was finally our turn, the hostess seemed completely lost. There were no available tables, even though we had a reservation, which should have guaranteed us a spot. We waited another 15 minutes in an overcrowded reception area until we were finally seated at the very last table, squeezed into the back of the restaurant. When our server came, we ordered coffee, two eggs benedict, and mentioned we’d like to try the French toast afterward. The eggs came out fairly quickly (in about 10 minutes), but the coffee never arrived. I’ve never seen a restaurant serve food before drinks, especially when the coffees were already prepared and just sitting on the counter. The server simply wasn’t bringing them. The cappuccino and eggs were fine, but nothing special. Then, when my husband called the waiter to order the French toast, he asked if we wanted the check. What kind of service is that? Yes, the place was packed and the staff seemed overwhelmed, but they should be trained to handle high demand, not push guests to leave. When the French toast finally arrived, it was dry, and flavorless (honestly the worst I’ve ever had). It felt like this place prioritizes volume over quality. I had noted in our reservation that it was for a birthday celebration, but that was completely ignored. Very different from other restaurants we visited during our trip to New York. Overall, it was not worth the price. We paid over $120 for a disappointing brunch that could have been so much better somewhere else. I don’t recommend it, the only good thing about this restaurant might be its location near Central Park.

Tim

Google
Here’s a polished and professional version of your Google review: ⸻ Slightly upscale breakfast spot near Central Park South offering a solid variety of options, from avocado toast and omelets to ricotta pancakes. Overall, the food was enjoyable, though the pumpkin muffin was a bit dry. The ambiance is beautiful, though it can get a little loud during peak hours. Reservations are recommended.

liat amano

Google
The recommended salad was great, and so were the fries – but the real star was the grilled cheese toast with their special sauce. It was incredibly tasty, just wish it was a bit bigger! We had a fun and delicious meal overall. We waited unnecessarily for about 10 minutes indoors before being seated outside, but once we were out – it was lovely, with a great view of the park.

M. H.

Google
A traditional place for breakfast or brunch right across from Central Park. For years you can enjoy tasty Eggs Benedict, Lobster Roll, Pancakes or a delicious French Toast along with great coffee. Service is friendly and the atmosphere is casual and cozy. Recommended!
google avatar

Kimberly B.

Yelp
Amazing brunch. I had the ricotta and lemon pancakes and I was not disappointed. Great service. Highly recommend!!
google avatar

Cole D.

Yelp
Really good breakfast. I had the eggs Benedict. The sauce is really creamy. The poached eggs were delicious. This meal inspired me to learn how to make eggs Benedict myself. I didn't come close to the flavor. Kind of hard to flag down service to get the bill and pay.
google avatar

Miles L.

Yelp
It is our first time here, we stumble upon this beautiful establishment one night this past weekend with my family for dinner. We started with deviled eggs and meatballs. Followed by the main course chicken pot pie and blackened risotto. The kids got chicken fingers and fries however the photo never happened because they were so hungry and it was delicious. The service was up to far, considering we had 2 kids in tow. Our waitress/waiter was nice but they kept switching with us.
google avatar

Elyse S.

Yelp
I did not take pictures...sorry... We went with a group dinner for around 40 people. I had the salmon entree and I asked for medium rare. It was well done. They gave me another piece which was a tad less well done but way too well done for me. The salad appetizer had way too much lemon and was also inedible to me. I ate downtown at a Sarabeths last spring and it was much better. Sometimes group dinners get overcooked. I'll keep that in mind and try it another time as a twosome. Service was impeccable.
google avatar

Jackie S.

Yelp
I haven't had Sarabeth's in a hot minute. It was THEEEE brunch spot circa 2012-2014 and I haven't been since then... Nothing has changed. If you want an upscale brunch/lunch with dainty, feminine vibes, this is your spot. It's very expensive for what you get but the food is good. I've had better brunches, I've had way worse. It's good, and the ambience really adds to the experience. I had the apple cinnamon granola and the portion of yogurt it came with was a bit small. The popovers were baked fresh and I liked the preserves they came with.
google avatar

Gatangalie S.

Yelp
Had brunch here with a work colleague visiting on a Sunday afternoon and absolutely loved the atmosphere. Such a cute and classy place to dine, they have lots of seating inside as well as outside when the weather is nice. And central park is right outside. My work colleague had to make reservation in advance. Very much loved their buttermilk pancakes and it was so yummy. Sarabeth is known for their breakfast. And to top it off, I had some delicious sorbets that were so delicious.
google avatar

Andrea R.

Yelp
Stopped here for brunch on a Sunday morning, which was convenientl located next to the Central Park Ritz where we were staying. We made a reservation ahead of time, although our train was running late from CT, but they were nice enough to hold our reservation until we arrived. It was a good thing we had a reservation because they were quite busy and we would have been waiting awhile, but we were seated right away. First up- coffee always! I ordered an iced latte while I took a look at their extensive breakfast and lunch menu. I was in a breakfast mood so went with the garden omelette. My daughter followed in my lead ordering 2 poached eggs, toast and bacon. My son wasn't feeling breakfast so ordered the turkey club. He liked it, but was probably the least satisfied of the 3 of us so I'd say breakfast is the way to go. The service was fine. The food came out pretty fast, but took awhile to find our waiter to pay. Overall, a solid experience and conveniently located near our hotel. We left full and ready to take on a full day in Manhattan!
google avatar

Caitlyn A.

Yelp
Always a good breakfast! Usually stay at the Park Lane next door and eat here at least once each trip. Highly recommend! I love the spinach and goat cheese omelette and the eggs Benedict. Pancakes are good but nothing too special, still hit the spot though.
google avatar

Misty D.

Yelp
I've been here a few times. I would say this is a good brunch spot, conveniently located next to Central Park. The portion sizes were big. My favorite dish was the lobster roll. It's going to be pretty expensive granted that it's right in the city and by Central Park. However it's not terribly devastating to your wallet. I would make reservations here beforehand as it can get very crowded . Good for large groups too.
google avatar

Katelyn W.

Yelp
We were up earlier than planned so we headed to Sarabeth's right after they opened without a reservation and were able to get a table! I had never been so I wanted the traditional NYC experience. The place was really cute, bright and clean. I ordered a mimosa and the quiche with a side of bacon. I was surprised with the amount of bacon that I got. You can tell it was cooked previously but it was still warm and well cooked. The quiche was delicious. The ham and leeks were flavorful, the egg mixture was creamy and crust was buttery. I just wished the crust was a little less soggy. Service was super quick and you could tell they were trying to rush us through to get as many people in as possible. Overall I'm glad we went but not sure if we'll go back next time we're in NYC.
google avatar

Kim N.

Yelp
I dined here for both breakfast and dinner while in NY. Sarabeth is a very comforting and reliable meal. I felt like I was eating a nice home cooked meal inside a fancy restaurant. For dinner, the chicken pot pie was a highlight! It was so delicious, flaky and warm. I also did love the beef and goat cheese salad. It was beautiful plated and tasted full of flavors. I would skip the chimichuri steak as it was quite dry. For breakfast the lemon ricotta pancakes were delicious and the rest of the meal felt home cooked. Overall if you're looking for a simple delicious meal, I'd stop here!
google avatar

Rusty R.

Yelp
Good food, attentive wait staff, but a bit overpriced. The bacon was superb. Muffins very good. Four flowers juice is really a thick nectar that needs to be combined with water if you aren't getting it in a cocktail. Would return for a special brunch, but can't justify the price for a standard brunch out.
google avatar

Clèm B.

Yelp
Nice brunch just in front of Central Park. It is a bit pricy but the portions are very generous ! The decoration inside is nice The menu offers classic brunch meals. I ordered the garden omelette with a tea and a fresh orange juice. It was good but really fulfilling ! I could not finish my place I assume the place is crowded during weekends, therefore, I recommend to go during weekdays if possible
google avatar

Zachary L.

Yelp
We had a reservation for the end of restaurant week so we avoided the line. However, despite the website saying they did restaurant week menus on the weekend, we were never given the option. Strike one. Strike two was the service: we felt rushed the whole meal (unsurprising given the growing line outside): but within 2 minutes of sitting down our waiter came over and brusquely wanted to know what we wanted to eat. Strike three was the price - $30 for eggs is a bit rich, even for NYC. Gluten free options were severely limited as well: there were no options for pastries or other items to be subbed out or replaced with a gluten-free option. My partner was relegated to replacing her potatoes (cross-contaminated, so not gluten free) with a salad: and had to talk the waiter out of upcharging her for the pleasure.
google avatar

Laken B.

Yelp
Love the location! Across the street from Central Park! The food was good. We had great seating by the window to enjoy the busy sidewalks. There was a wait over 20 mins which caused us not to be able to eat brunch. However, a few of the brunch items are still offered all day. The older hostess was very nice. However, the waiter and the server who brought out the plates were not very friendly. Once the food was ordered and brought out, we didn't get checked on until we got the attention of the server for the check. We felt as if we were bothering the servers to sit in his section. Granted it's the holiday season and it's busy, a little holiday cheer would of been great to add. Especially considering the pricing. We ordered cocktails too. With the exception of the older female host, the staff all seemed annoyed and not very friendly which is as unfortunate. My stars are based on the food. Otherwise, the remainder of the experience I would of rated it lower.
google avatar

Angelica R.

Yelp
Great location across from Central Park. Staff was friendly. Our server was prompt however we had to ask for more coffee. My Farmer's omelet was delicious! I chose the scone to go with it. It was excellent. My 7 yr old had the pancakes. He loved them. My husband had a popover and scramble. He enjoyed it but was surprised the popover was cold. Very nice atmosphere with delicious food.
google avatar

Lucy R.

Yelp
Every time I come to New York I always look for the right restaurant to eat and with good service . Today this restaurant was on my list.. the food was amazing and the gentleman's that served my table " Daniel & Jorge " were just great ..Made my family feel so welcome, but I will say that one of the managers named America a young lady at the front desk was very rude, unprofessional and unwelcoming while waiting for our table and after being seated ..BAD service she offered to the customer. Had to leave this review for the restaurant best interest..
google avatar

Momoka T.

Yelp
4.5 / 5.0 Sarabeth's on 59th St. There are both indoor and terrace seating, Atmosphere to enjoy a relaxing morning or lunch. The French toast is hearty and goes well with maple syrup. The service was great, they took care of everything! Strollers can be checked in at the reception, They have high chairs so you can enjoy it with your kids! This is one of those places that I would love to take my friends when they come to New York City. What I ordered was: ・Fat & Fluffy French Toast ・Iced latte
google avatar

Jennie C.

Yelp
disgustingly overcrowded and overpriced when i came which was on saturday! never again ahaha. when i asked the waiter for recommendations, he proceeded to name all the lost expensive things on the menu like the lobster ravioli. while i understand getting ur bag and can respect that, it seemed a bit fishy to me and needless to say a bit rude as well. the service was also not the friendliest. it felt like he was trying to rush us out of our seats asap to sit the next party. i know the line is out the door but sometimes you just want to enjoy a weekend brunch on your own time??? they also sat us in the outdoor dining area which had some nice lighting but was right next to all the passerby's who were entering, exiting, and waiting to be sat. kind of unpleasant. the tables were also very close together. the bathroom line was astronomical. i ended up going nearby outside to the girls room there. the food was pretty good but not worth the experience; the fiscal price and mental exhaustion.
google avatar

Karina A.

Yelp
I got the miso salmon and it was really juicy and flavorful. I love the miso sauce however $40 for this was a lot of money. I don't think it was worth it due to the portion size. Only reading this four out of five because the price was really expensive for the amount of quantity that I have received. Otherwise, the staff was super nice and it was cute inside. However, I also did have truffle fries, which were amazing and definitely would've ordered that again
google avatar

Andres F.

Yelp
Food was great service was good for the location. Definitely is a good spot if you're planning to be in Central Park area .. Ambience is calm ..
google avatar

Vanasha D.

Yelp
As an avid customer at Sarabeths, Central Park is my favorite, if you have visit any other the space is a bit smaller than the others but the food and the service is consistent overall. Visited to brunch for my sister birthday and if was a good time, we had the pancakes, French toast, apple sausages, eggs, coffee and cheese cake for dessert. The portions are pretty large so I always leave with a take out bag (lol) this restaurant has been a constant in my life and they've never disappointed me. I suggest when visiting this location to make reservations because it gets really busy.
google avatar

Kate F.

Yelp
I ordered takeout from here while staying in the city. The portion was generous, but the "side salad" was a few pieces or limp greens. The eggs with salmon and cream cheese were delicious, as was the popover. Because it was takeout I can't comment on the staff or service, but the space itself was lovely
google avatar

Aya E.

Yelp
Ordered: Smoked Salmon Benedict (~$29): hollandaise, peppers, chives, and served with local greens Fat & Fluffy French Toast (~$28): with strawberries Iced Latte (~$6): with oat milk Aya's take: There's no way around this - it's average. The name & location probably brings in more patrons than usual but it's certainly not for the quality or taste of the food. We had a reservation yet had to wait about 15 minutes before we were seated. Both dishes we got were decent but not great. The Smoked Salmon Benedict tasted a bit fishy but the eggs were cooked perfectly. I also enjoyed the greens on the side. The English muffin they use is also a bit unique; it's more buttery and flaky than your typical English muffin. The Fat & Fluffy French Toast was a bit too eggy; dousing it with syrup helped but you shouldn't have to do that for a good French toast. All in all, it was a good try but I probably wouldn't come back.

Taylor W.

Yelp
Honestly - never going back. I always walk by this restaurant and the brunch looks good and delightful. Well I went for dinner and well, 1 star and that's because the chips and guacamole with crab was great! I ordered a chicken potpie and as you can see this looks like slop. I ordered online at 6:08pm, the restaurant followed up and said that I would receive a notification when my food was ready. Time went by and no text, I called around 6:50pm - the hostess that answered the phone said my food was ready and had been sitting for a while. I walked over and she checked the food then sat it on the counter instead of handing it to me directly. The customer service at this place clearly was lacking. I get back to my hotel and there are no utensils, no napkins, nothing just the food. Never again, Sarabeth's.
google avatar

Lorraine G.

Yelp
Love Sara Beth's conveniently located on Central Park South between the Plaza and Ritz Carlton. Great for breakfast and lunch. Reservations available online. We ate in the bright garden room with the wisteria above. I chose the basic breakfast with scrambled eggs and applewood bacon. My partner chose eggs Benedict. Coffee is bottomless. A great choice when you're in the city.
google avatar

Aarti G.

Yelp
I wasn't able to get a reservation for 9:30 but it didn't take too long to get a table for 2 people. Our waitress was friendly. We both ordered cappuccinos which were so good and creamy. I got quiche which came with a side salad. I also ordered a scone on the side which came with cream and jam. I think the jam was apricot. The salad was tangy and not too heavily dressed. The scone wasn't too dry and I enjoyed both the cream and jam. My friend got lemon ricotta pancakes which she liked. She said it didn't have enough syrup but they were happy to bring more.
google avatar

Cherie G.

Yelp
I LOVE this place! I always come here for my birthday It's a great location. I usually sit indoors, but you can sit outside right by Central Park, how can you beat that? We always get an egg dish then share pancakes or French Toast. The salmon eggs Benedict was DIVOON! Service was great. I had reservations, and seated right away. Great NY VIBES!
google avatar

Lindsay A.

Yelp
Came for breakfast on a week day with no reservation and were seated immediately. It was crowded but manageable. The service was very quick, almost too quick! I got the wild mushroom scramble which was really good, if you like truffle. My sister had the farmers omelette which she described as unremarkable and a bit dry. Also a little pricey but you expect that being next to Central Park
google avatar

Yvette K.

Yelp
Beautiful surroundings. Light and airy. Nice atmosphere and the food is basically breakfast fare with a few add ons Nothing really jumped out at me flavor wise but all was good we ordered French toast, goat and scallion omelet and popover mushroom and egg The popover I envisioned was filled with the ingredients instead it was mushroom and egg scrambled with a popover instead of toast The coffee maker wasn't working but the espresso was so we ordered cappuccino and that was excellent

Jennifer B.

Yelp
Great spot, right next to our hotel. Food was average, nothing stood out but a cute spot to brunch.
google avatar

steve P.

Yelp
Great food, service,and ambiance close to Central Park. We stayed close by and enjoyed the experience. Reservations advised,
google avatar

Kelsey B.

Yelp
Great food! Great atmosphere! Service was less than great, but would go back again! Our waiter didn't pay a ton of attention to us and forgot stuff, but maybe they were short handed, so giving grace! Food was worth it!
google avatar

Amanda J.

Yelp
Sarabeth's remains a classic for quality and service. You may spend slightly more here, but the quality of the ingredients and comfortable setting justify it. We didn't have reservations. We were able to show up on a Wednesday evening at 7pm and were quickly seated. This is white tablecloth service, but does not have a strict dress code. Corporate casual seems to be the standard with more casual around the brunch hours. The drink menu is more extensive than they have posted online. It also seemed possible to modify and order what you liked, within reason. Cocktails were about $16 a piece and were balanced with unique combinations. Our waiter was very helpful in letting me know that my mostly deboned and butterflied roasted chicken would take 30 minutes to come to the table. I started with the tomato soup ($18), while my friend's salmon came to the table shortly afterwards. The soup was absolutely delicious Although creamy, it was not heavy. The Murray's Roasted Chicken ($35) was the star of the night, however. The roasted chicken was so tender; my knife cut through it like butter. The jus on it helped to hydrate the crispy skin and blended nicely with the puree. I was so happy to have enough of this left over to enjoy the next day. We finished by splitting a massive ice cream cookie ($8). I'm fairly certain a person could make a meal out of this. This was a simple vanilla ice cream wedged between two palm sized, hard chocolate chip cookies. While I enjoyed this, I think I would have liked something like a Thin Tate's cookie on the outside and a stronger Tahitian vanilla ice cream. Or perhaps lace cookies with a coconut ice cream or German chocolate. People coming here like their classics. I do feel dessert was an area that they could elevate and surprise more. I do look forward to returning one morning for their basket of popovers!
google avatar

Joy M.

Yelp
I can't go to New York and not go for a grilled cheese and tomato soup. That tomato soup is probably the best thing I've ever tasted. Creamy, chunky, fresh, and just so tasty. The grilled cheese is on a pretzel bun with a few different kinds of cheese. Warm and lovely. We sat outside across from Central Park. Beautiful day. Service was perfect. I can't wait to go back.
google avatar

Belle A.

Yelp
The food, service, and ambiance were all outstanding. Everything was elegant and the service exceptional. Because this place was literally steps from our hotel, we walked over for brunch. It was a quarter after 11 am on a Saturday, so it was packed! We were told there was a 30 minute wait, however we didn't even wait 10 minutes when they seated us! So a huge plus! They brought us water and drinks, then took our orders quickly. So exceptional was the service that no sooner had we put our order in, the servers all came out at the same time with everything! We ordered the Lemon ricotta pancakes with fresh blackberries and a generous side of bacon, the Breakfast Bowl, the wild mushroom popover omelette, and sparkling water, as well as the Four Flowers smoothie!
google avatar

Bryan S.

Yelp
Conveniently located, but the interior needs to be updated. The service was ok, but not particularly spectacular. The dishes exceeded my expectations a little and I enjoyed how fluffy the pancakes were. The pop over could have had slightly more salmon, but it was pretty tasty and the eggs were also perfectly cooked. Still a bit expensive for brunch, but I guess that's partly because of being next to central park south. $28 for pancakes seriously?

Gina L.

Yelp
The food and service were excellent, the prices were outrageous. I spent $75 on an omelette, pancakes and coffee for myself. My friend ordered one meal and spent about $50. While the ricotta pancakes were quite delicious, they were certainly not worth the price. However, you pay for the location and reputation. The ambiance was average.
google avatar

Edwin S.

Yelp
Sarabeths has been around for a very long time and is hotspot that sits between major hotels and Central Park. If you're looking for classic old New York, this is the place for you. However, should you want more bang for your buck I would have to recommend elsewhere. Taste: 2.5/5 Service: 4/5 Value for Money: 2/5 Ambience: 4/5 We had: 1) Seafood gumbo (16) - Not recommended. Unfortunately should not be considered a meal. It uses rock shrimp and perhaps 2oz of rice. Admittedly shocked to see the portion. As for the taste itself, it is unfortunate to have to say it tasted like leftover lentil soup. 2) Sarabeths signature sirloin burger (29) - the burger on the flip side had great flavour to it. This would be a recommended choice, the fries were skinny 3) Orange juice (14) - a glass of orange juice was 14. No alcohol, just plain ol 14 bucks for juice. Think of 8oz of your best Tropicana in glassware Not sure if I could say I would be back. Greedflation is very real.
google avatar

Alison M.

Yelp
This place is delicious. Great location near all the best shopping and The Plaza and right across from Central Park. We didn't realize how popular it was and were able to get in on a Saturday morning for brunch within 25 minutes and snag a nice patio seat. Our waiter was very busy, but good and we ordered the lobster roll with fries, a veggie omelet and a smoothie. Prices are high-ish but not any different from the rest of the city and the food was very good. My veggie egg omelet had cheese, peas, scallions and zucchini and was served with a small side of greens, and a warm muffin of choice. I chose banana. It was served with fresh butter and delicious house-made berry jam that they sell inside. SO good! My husband's lobster roll was phenomenal and he loved it. He subbed fries for the chips and it was a large and generous portion of fries. I ordered the smoothie - pineapple, orange, banana and cranberry. Small and expensive for $15 but delicious and fresh and refreshing. They are popular and busy - but service was prompt and we didn't wait a long time for our food and our busy waiter did a good job of taking good care of us. All in all - great spot for people watching and great food. Win!
google avatar

Chrissy F.

Yelp
I walked bye here the other day looking for lunch options with my friend. And we decided gave it a try ...we weren't that impressed. The place is actually really beautiful and everyone who works here are super nice. Now the food not so much in my opinion.I had the lobster roll it had so much stuff in there besides lobster I was so upset. At almost 35 dollars I had better ones at Luke's lobster. The chips were hard and cold. My friend had the burger she said it was like a regular burger nothing spectacular. And so sarabeth's was okay but not for the price.
google avatar

Maggie J.

Yelp
Great food & quick service!! Bonus is the location being so close to Central Park! Would definitely recommend!
google avatar

Mindy R.

Yelp
Best tomato soup of my life!!! My friend and I stopped in for a late lunch and we were seated right away by the window. The restaurant was pretty empty which was surprising. We both got the adult grilled cheese which was three cheeses on pretzel bread served with a bowl of creamy tomato soup with large chunks of tomatoes and a side/pile of bread and butter pickle chips on the side. We barely spoke to each other because we were too busy giggling over how amazing the food was!! 5 stars for the food and ambiance! The rest of the menu looked great as well. Prices were high but felt worth it.
google avatar

Ash B.

Yelp
Overall, I enjoyed what I ate here though the food itself is average. I came on a Saturday afternoon at 1 pm without a reservation. I only had to wait 20 minutes till a table opened up which is reasonable. The service was fast, the employees were kind, and I personally thought the portion sizes were decent. The garden omelette was on the richer size for me, with more cheese than I would've liked. I loved the lemon ricotta pancakes but honestly, it's hard to mess up pancakes.
google avatar

Chelle C.

Yelp
Good service. The bartender was very cute! Good menu, good selection. But the quality of the food was just mediocre. The location and ambience are what you go for. A very crowded and loud and touristy place. But we had a fun time! The mimosas are great!
google avatar

Candy A.

Yelp
Food was good and the atmosphere was great. Every time I come to New York, I come here to eat. I highly recommend it. I love the breakfast here.

Daniel G.

Yelp
The absolute worst salmon Benedict I've ever had. Extremely overpriced, which I wouldn't mind if they didnt clearly buy the cheapest quality salmon, eggs and muffin. Highly recommend to avoid this overpriced diner. And the servers were very pushy.
google avatar

Christopher S.

Yelp
Very basic breakfast food priced like it's something special. Coupled with poor and slow service makes this a place you'll want to skip.

Bill L.

Yelp
Had a really nice dinner at Sarabeths on 2/15, It was not too crowded and realtively quiet. We had the power bowl and the salmon and obth dishes were very good. Service was prompt and attentive.