Sarabeth's in Key West

Sarabeth’s has a secret weapon! Is it their amazing Lobster Spinach Omelette, possibly. Is it their delicious Lemon Ricotta Pancakes or the Crab Avocado Bacon Benedict platter? Perhaps it could be the to die for Strawberry shortcake that will make your mouth water. The actual secret weapon is their spectacular customer service, BINGO! Our server for our breakfast today was “Brad.” Brad welcomed us like we were family as soon as we walked in the door. We were shown the menus for both food and beverages, and while we waited fresh, ice cold water was served. Brad inquired if anyone had dietary restrictions or needed to be aware of any allergies. Brad gave us a run down on the specials, and particularly awesome menu items. We truly were in absolute heaven by his professionalism, friendliness and hospitality. The entire staff was impressive. In addition their restrooms were clean, and fully stocked. The restaurant is nestled into a gorgeous corner lot, with ample street parking as well as scooter/bike availability. If you need a lovely, quiet and relaxing breakfast, lunch or dinner please visit Sarabeth’s Key West. (P.S. ask to be seated in Brad section, you’re welcome). Enjoy!

Amazing food and service once again! I won't come to The Keys without eating brunch here! The mimosas are soooo good! The eggs Benedict are killer! Just pick one, cuz they're all amazing. The atmosphere is so great! Don't miss the opportunity to have brunch here! We had three people recommend other places but we bypassed them to come here!

Been coming to Key West for years and wanted try SaraBeths. Served promptly. Coffee and cream please. Decided on a ham and cheddar cheese omelette with home fries and all grain toast. Waitress brings coffee in this huge cup. No problem but I couldn’t get my finger in the hole. I ordered and repeated my order. Was served promptly. Asked for ketchup. Noticed no home fries. No butter for toast. Then noticed no waitress. Started to eat my omelette. No ham and mozzarella cheese. Still no waitress. Finally I had had enough of the omelette and the waitress finally appeared and asked if I wanted more coffee. I informed her of the deficiencies of my breakfast and she asked me if I wanted a new breakfast. No check please. A subpar $30 breakfast. I thought at least I’d get a break on my check.

What amazing food! Came here for the Keylime pie, but really enjoyed the lobster BLT on whole grain bread. Large portion extremely tasty and amazing. The potions are big so you can two can easily share this . And the fries are very good! Better than most fries I’ve had

we had a fantastic experience at sarabeth's on simonton street. the atmosphere is very casual, the staff is very friendly, welcoming and professional and the food was perfect, from apps to entrees to dessert. arriving after dark, the iphone pix don't do this stuff justice. just try it yourself, you'll love it.

We've been wanting to go and finally got to on this trip. Sunday morning brunch time. Inside was cool, tasteful nautical. Outside patio looked shaded and inviting. The staff were delightful, chatty and funny. We were well taken care of. I had the delicious spinach and goat cheese omelet with extra crispy bacon, generous mango pineapple mimosa. They even had gluten free bread for me, for toast. Served with Sarabeth's famous strawberry peach jam. My guy had a shrimp, bacon, cheese omelet and tasty muffin and bloody mary. All great. Highly recommend.

There’s nothing special. It’s very overpriced and the prices aren’t listened or mentioned to you for a reason which is really annoying considering their bottles of water are priced at $13 What easily would have cost us $25-$30 at any other restaurant in town, costed us $135 lol Also as someone who’s from Louisiana…your shrimp and grits are more like a breakfast bowl. I had a spoonful of grits, two shrimps, on top a mixture of sausage and idk what else they added in that bowl but it wasn’t no Shrimp and Grits plz don’t insult us like that again.

One word, AMAZING!! Not only is the food amazing but the customer service is out of this world!! My husband and I loved the shrimp and grits which I think was a special. My daughters loved the pancakes and French toast. The mimosas were amazing as well. I would start name dropping but the staff are ALL awesome with energetic positive attitudes. The service was so great we came back a second time and we were yet again met with those energetic positive attitudes. Do yourself a favor and stop by this awesome establishment!

On an excruciating hot day we decided to have brunch and get out of the sun and were very lucky that we found Sarabeth's. With both indoor and outdoor seating we chose the air conditioned indoor which had very nice tropical feel with bankettes with colorful paintings and pillows making us feel outdoors while cooling indoors. We had the shrimp Mac and cheese, foccacio bread eggs and cheese with slab bacon sandwich, chorizo sandwich;all were fabulous. The sides of French fries and home fries were delicious. Service was friendly and attentive . It is destination dining.

Warm atmosphere and great service ... a really good way to start your meal. We arrived for a late breakfast. This place is popular, so be prepared to wait. Once inside, you can tell the structure was repurposed many times over its existence. Pretty cool. On to the menu which had many interesting items to select from. I decided to go with the shrimp and bacon omelette. Very unique, and quite good! Overall, a great experience.

What amazing food! Came here for the Keylime pie, but really enjoyed the lobster BLT on whole grain bread. Large portion extremely tasty and amazing. The potions are big so you can two can easily share this . And the fries are very good! Better than most fries I've had

Absolutely DELICIOUS breakfast spot in Key West! My family visited about 9am on a weekday morning and were able to be seated right away on the patio which was really beautiful! My husband and I started with spicy bloody marys- very good! I ordered the breakfast sandwich the comes with breakfast potatoes- either I was very hungry or it was one of the best breakfast sandwiches I have ever eaten. My husband had the key lime French toast which he really enjoyed too. Our son had a side of scrambled eggs with an English muffin and he scarfed it down! If we ever visit Key West again I would love to go back to Sarabeth's!

This is a great place for breakfast, yet this trip we went for happy hour. We got half off wine and small bites. Doug our waiter was awesome. Happy hour is only an hour but the food was great and it was the cheapest dinner we had in Key West. Dinner was just as good as breakfast. It is very cute and eclectic. We were the first the ones there, got a seat right at the window and had an amazing time.

If you're looking for an off the beaten path brunch place, this place is awesome. Has Outdoor, covered patio seating, plus indoor. We sat outside. Interesting place as it appears to be a residential property with access in the middle of the restaurant. Service was great. Very attentive to our table. Ordered the special, which was a shrimp and grits with andouille sausage and a poached egg on top. It was delicious. Sorry no picture. Was stuffed when I left.

Brad is a great server! You can tell he really loves his job and cares about his customers. We were lucky our hotel was just next door. We dined here 2 days in a row, once for brunch and the second time for lunch. LUNCH IS WAY BETTER. There wasn't as many brunch options and the portions were so small. Never in my life have I ordered eggs Benedict and when it arrived in front of me I thought to myself, "where's the rest of it!?" But the mimosa flavors are unique and different. The lunch options and portions are way better and bigger. I had the lobster BLT with fries and it was perfect. The BLT contained plenty of lobster and the fries were seasoned and cooked to perfection. This restaurant is worth it to try if you're in the area!

Great menu!!! Everything was executed so well. Unique dishes and drinks. Service was great and seemed like a local favorite. When we went there seemed to be several regulars and locals we met either loved it or have wanted to go. Price point was decent as well.

The things that stand out here (and it's hard to stand out in an island full of brunch/lunch and dinner places at every corner) are the service and the space They have outdoor and indoor seating and although they don't take reservations they do seat people fairly quickly even larger parties We had a party of seven adults and two kids and they seated us in 20 minutes and we figured on a Tuesday during Christmas week The staff is super friendly even though our party was loud and we lingered on to catch up on old times they were attentive and nice, and I appreciate that The server even gave one of the kids a little gift bags The food is reliable and well proportioned and you will find something between the classic brunch options and the savory lunches to hit the spot The drawback of course is not being able to make a reservations Perhaps expanding the menu from the classic European brunch options to some island fare would be one minor suggestion Certainly some place I'd recommend

Delicious! Every person at our table loved every bite of food! They were also dog friendly and our dog was thrilled too. Drinks were amazing - but the best part of it all was the service. This staff was 5 star! Setting is the perfect place to start a day in key west sitting and looking out at the street in the patio. Loved it!

Must get the key lime French toast. Great atmosphere. Every we plate we ordered was fantastic.

We came here for brunch, and it was fantastic! We started with the millionaire's bacon, which was the perfect mix of sweet and savory. I had the surf and turf Benny, and my husband tried the special grits with lobster and sausage--the best grits I've ever tasted! We sat on the patio, which was lovely, and the service was outstanding. Our waiter was friendly, helpful, and gave us great recommendations. We'll definitely be back for dinner next time!

The Surf n Turf Benedict was the absolute best I ever had anywhere, hands down! Top that with a pineapple mango mimosa and I was in heaven. Great little spot if you are ever in Key West!

I have nothing bad to say. Nicolas my server was fast efficient and friendly. My food came out super quick and was flavorful hot and delicious. I am a basic eater so I got off of my virgin voyage to find a nice hardy breakfast in Key West and this was exactly what I needed. If you're ever in Key West check this one out!

After stopping in **** drinks along w quesadilla did a fantastic job - there's places all over also

I'm a twice yearly regular to Key West and I always make a stop at Sarabeth's for their delicious breakfast! Everything I've tried has been amazing. The service is impeccable every time. Such nice, friendly people! Can't wait to return again.

Previous review said we couldn't stop talking about the mimosas so with that, we returned to Sarabeth's before we left Key West for another round and more delicious food! Brad, our server, was fantastic just like the first time! We had to wait for a few minutes for a seat to open on the patio, and he got us our drinks while waiting, which was a lovely treat. Another great experience and if we find ourselves back in Key West, Sarabeth's will be on our list!

Came in with a group of six and got seated quickly! Service was exceptional and staff was well informed. Definitely would recommend asking about the specials. Super casual but trendy environment. We enjoyed the outdoor seating. I had the shrimp tacos, and they were definitely a highlight. The coleslaw on the tacos was EXCELLENT!

Oh man, I had a shrimp and grits dish with andouille and avocado and a little scrambled egg on top that was so good, we went back 2 days in a row. I also had a good strong Cosmopolitan that was soooooo good I took one to go. Relaxed vibe, super nice service. Will return, repeatedly. See y'all next time we are in KW.

Delicious brunch spot! I had the eggs Benedict- it came with potatoes and peppers. The hollandaise was so yummy! The cranberry lime mimosas were excellent too! Our party also enjoyed omelettes, the chicken sandwich and the lemon ricotta pancakes. Our server was attentive and the patio was shades and full of fans to keep everyone cool in the hot Key West weather! Highly recommend!

This place was right next to where we stayed so we stopped in for brunch one day! We almost even went a second day it was so good. We both got bloody Mary's and they were excellent. I got the breakfast sandwhich and my friend got the shrimp and grits and she said it might have been her favorite dish she had all week. The service was great and there is both and inside and outside. I would suggest this place for brunch to anyone who visits! The only downfall it is on the pricey side but worth it!

We've walked past Sarabeth's at odd-hours on so many trips to Key West, and we've always commented on how we want to try it. We finally got that chance in December, and we'll certainly return on the next visit. From the very first mimosa -- renamed a poinsettia complete with red and green nonpareils on the rim -- I knew this would be an awesome experience! We were able to sit outside on the porch which is nicely shaded, and the service was quick and friendly. Like most other Key West restaurants, attire is casual, and you won't feel out of place in your tank top and sandals. It takes a decent effort to stand out in terms of food on an island filled with restaurants and bars, but as a breakfast/brunch spot Sarabeth's is worth visiting. My husband had shrimp & grits, and he commented that it was one of the best he's had. I had the green & white, a very humble combination of scrambled eggs, scallions, and cream cheese that when served together was pure perfection! It doesn't seem like a large eatery and they do take reservations, so like many places in Key West, you may want to plan ahead for your visit. Highly recommend!

Amazing breakfast! I was blown away by my entree. I had the most amazing shrimp/crab grits. This dish was very elevated and flavorful. The grits came with avocado, a poached egg, shrimps, and crab. 10/10

Always 5 stars! Great food! Excellent service! Cool vibes. We went straight from the airport. True gem.

This was a fun little place to eat that definitely felt more like the residents go than the tourists. All of the food was delicious and the service was great. It was laid back, like much of Key West but better than the places that just jam you in and turn the tables as fast as they can.

Sarabeth's is a small restaurant a block from Duval Street about a 1/2 mile from the ocean. Seating is outside with a small kitchen inside. The rest of the building appears to be apartments. The food was very good. I enjoyed my shrimp, bacon and cheese omlette. I chose to have the blueberry muffin with the omelette. That was the right choice! The blueberry muffin was the best I've ever had! My wife enjoyed her lemon ricotta pancakes. Service was good. We were greeted right away, had water ordered and our order was taken promptly. There were a couple of minor issues at the end (I think our server couldn't hear well or was otherwise distracted).

Great little spot, but not on the affordable side. Food was great, can't go wrong with breakfast. Very accommodating, service was on point no doubt about it.

This is the perfect Key West breakfast spot. Although it's kind of small, the high ceilings and table spacing don't make you feel cramped. Nicolas provided awesome service and was very knowledgable about the menu, he provided excellent recommendations. The food was delicious. I tried - Lobster Spinach Omelette - Generous amount of fresh lobster and avocado. I think there was also spinach in here as well as a delicious light tomato based sauce. This was very flavorful. I loved that it came with a blueberry muffin as well, which was a nice sweet contrast to the savory omelette. This isn't on their menu, it was a special. 5/5 ($28) Their coffee was exceptionally good as well. I also tried their surf and turf Benedict which was tasty. Mimosas were good but on the pricey side. All-in-all this is a great spot. If you're in the area I would for sure give these guys a try.

We went there for breakfast and had the shrimp grits and omelette. My wife had the cranberry mimosa and I had water. The food was good and staff very friendly. My wife made me take a picture of the bill because we have never paid 72.00 for breakfast before.

This was a great brunch spot. We stayed across the street and this was not only convenient on our Keys getaway it was so good. I'd been craving French toast and they delivered. It was so good I didn't even get a picture. My husband had a great omelette. Only improvement I would make would be to have espresso drinks on the menu. BUT they have a great selection of mimosas. Service was good as well. We had outside in this cutest little tables.

Last time we were in town, about 8 months ago, we stopped in for lunch and had Nicholas as a server and his service and the amazing food are what made us return, this time for dinner. We got there just prior to happy hour ending, so we started with some treats from the happy hour menu, like Veuve, which is only $12.50 during happy hour! And some of their amazing steak tips... the sauce and the way the salad under it were both dressed, seasoned, and prepared were incredible! Their bacon wrapped BBQ shrimp wee excellent, as was their sword fish! In all, we had another excellent experience here and... score, we had Nicholas again! His service was excellent once again too! Highly recommend stopping in!

Sort of a don't miss out restaurant. We went for breakfast Food was unique and delicious. We had 4 in our party and everyone got something different. All enjoyed their meals. Service was impeccable. We went early, sat outside and the ambiance was a perfect Key West vibe. Walked the side streets and it was really quaint. Highly recommend.

Daily food specials were amazing!! Daily mimosa flavors were a nice surprise as well. Seafood was super fresh.

We were just walking and stumbled upon this place for breakfast and I'm sooooo happy we did! First off, customer service was the best I've seen on the island so far! They work as a team and are very attentive to their tables. Both inside and outside seating. No reservations. Secondly, the food choices were SO GOOD! You are truly paying for the portion size you get and the flavor and quality of food! It's a smaller place so it doesn't seat many but we came at a great time! I would definitely go back here again!!

Wow...just wow! Thanks to Yelp reviews while visiting Key West I found this gem of a place. We arrived around 10:30 on a Saturday and there was about a 40 min wait for four. There is outdoor as well as indoor seating. We did have the option to pick either but we locked inside. Once seated our server came right over and explained they have everyone service, So anyone and everyone will help serve and they all share tips. He also gave us the specials which sounded absolutely that we all ordered one of the choices. The music in the place is simply perfect, something for everyone. While waiting for the food we were able to sing along sipping our mimosas (they have over 50 flavors/variations). The food came out quickly and it was hot! I say hot because lately it seems food has been coming out just luke warm and it was amazing. You can taste the fresh ingredients and the care that was taken to prepare the meal. This place was so good we went back the next day! It is kind of $$, for the four of us the bill was $250 (including tip). Kinda pricey for breakfast but it was for the 4 of us and we did have mimosas. One other thing of note. One of us ordered an Arnold Palmer. Our server said we don't have lemonade but I'm happy to go back and squeeze some to make it just give me 5 minutes. When he returned he had a craft of ice tea and lemonade! Talk about service! Food Service Music Located Hospitality Amazing - Amazing

Delicious breakfast. Eggs Benedict was delicious. The key lime pie French toast has been in my dreams for the last 4 years since the last time I had it. It was just as good as I remembered. The bacon was extra crispy as I asked for. The service was good. The coffee was so cute. I love this place.

Went here for brunch today. Nice covered patio with lots of fans to keep the customers cool. Wait and host staff were friendly. My spouse had the traditional breakfast and really enjoyed his blueberry muffin. I had the lemon ricotta pancakes which were delicious. I also ordered an iced tea and to my surprise the waiter brought me a second one. My only complaint would be that for the cost of the meals I don't we should be charged an extra &2.50 for pure maple syrup. If you find customers waste it then bring it in a small container. If they requested more you could always charge for the extra. Just a suggestion. Cute interior too.

Absolutely amazing brunch spot! They have a nice shaded outdoor area with fans that is tolerable even in the summer. They don't do reservations, so you will have to wait a little bit but the wait goes quickly. We started off with their fresh watermelon mimosas and they were delicious! My husband got the blood Mary and said that was really good too. I ordered their special for the day, which was a cheese grits bowl with crab, sausage, shrimp and a poached egg. To die for!!! We all split an order of the key lime French toast for "dessert". Since there was 4 slices it worked out well. I highly recommend and would definitely go back for brunch.

Had a great meal here with my family. Food was delicious, service was excellent and the restaurant is small but very nice ambiance! Definitely recommend eating here.

One of my favorite restaurants in Key West. The specials menu is wonderful it was so hard to decide because all of the dishes sound delicious. I decided to try the shrimp and grits and it was the best shrimp and grits dish! So flavorful and fresh. Absolutely delicious, this delightful dish should be part of the regular menu. Service was very attentive, and friendly. Positive atmosphere throughout the restaurant Sarabeth's is a must visit and so worth it!

So glad this is where we started our day in Key West! Traveling with friends and we were starving by the time we drove into town, the reviews for this place looked really good so we parked nearby for the day and made our way here. Put our name on the list and were told the wait was about 40 minutes, but luckily it turned out to be only 15. We were sat at a table in their cute patio, and quickly got our menus. We had looked at the menu while we waited and weren't sure what to get, but then our waiter stopped by and listed the specials, and all of us went for that. Got the watermelon mimosa, it was adorable, not quite my preferred mimosa flavor but refreshing still. Then got the grits bowl with crab, shrimp, andouille sausage, avocado, and a poached egg. It was fabulous, best grits I've ever had. We wrapped it up splitting an order of the key lime french toast which was delicious as well. In all a fantastic experience, friendly service, delicious food, refreshing drinks, we were happy campers. Prices aren't cheap, and specials were more pricey than regular menu items, so ask for the price if that's a concern for your budget.

Totally worth the wait in the horrible Florida heat! Lol. We were there for Sunday brunch on the weekend before the 4th of July. We were quoted a wait time of about 40 minutes (which we expected) and it only took about 20 minutes to be seated. We ate outside on their covered patio and were pretty comfortable considering the HORRIBLE heat that day. We were in the shade and they had fans going. We started off with their watermelon mimosa, which was something we'd never had. It was delicious and super refreshing! I got the shrimp and grits and it was one of the most amazing things I've ever eaten. I've had shrimp and grits a LOT of place (I just can't help myself when its on the meu) and this one takes the cake!

We ordered two breakfasts...the eggs Benedict came out great. I also got their special, which was the lobster omelette, this was amazing. Food is really good. But $75 for 2 breakfasts and one coffee seems like a lot.

Solid breakfast stop a short walk off Duval! Stopped in here for a quick morning bite, but if you have the time it's worth making this a long breakfast. A block off Duval makes this a bit less of a mad house with a nice casual covered street-side dining area. The good: ok we were feeling unusually responsible and didn't order drinks but they had a great selection of brunch drinks with some very indulgent times glassware. The prices it's easy to up-charge in this neighbourhood but all the prices here were really reasonable, we did not get the filet or lobster specials but the benny and lox were great. Service. Attentive but not overbearing service throughout, service was quick and pleasant. The bad. Not much that can be helped. The place is adjacent to the fire station so we were treated to a siren during breakfast. ‍

Great service and vibe on the outdoor patio. We split 2 specials (grit bowl and surf &turf eggs benny).

Remains an amazing restaurant. It's been 10+ years since I've been there and understand a few changes have occurred but this is a gem in Key West. Just 1 block off Duval. Don't pass this place up. Thanks to Brad for an exceptional night.

We visit Sarabeth's anytime we're in Key West. The service, vibes, and mimosas are always amazing. My husband had the surf and turf benedict was phenomenal. I was in the mood for something sweeter, so opted for the cinnamon pecan french toast with berries. It did not disappoint! This time around, we were lucky enough to get a table right away, but it's not rare to have to a while to get seated. Sarabeth's is definitely worth it though!

Shady place to cool off in the hot sun. It was such a peaceful lunch with our kids. Our server who I wish I caught his name was phenomenal. He catered to our kids and did everything right to make for a pleasant lunch. I have not had service like this is a long time. Our food was also just as fantastic. I opted for the surf and turf Benedict and husband got the lobster BLT. Both were amazing. Will definitely be back. Worth it.

Order the shrimp and grits! The grits are some of the best I have ever eaten - the breakfast portion also had lobster, sausage, tomatoes, avocado and poached egg.... Favorite meal in Key West