Mark Hurter
Google
I went on a "standard sailing trip" (not one of the themed trips). When we talked with the booking team, it was billed as a mix of the trips, kind of a "best of all trips" trip. Here is what we found:
The boat itself is absolutely gorgeous. It's well-maintained and met our expectations. We had cabin 9, which is a queen bed, and it's tight, but manageable. The bathrooms were adequate. They are shared on the boat, but I thought it was fine, and again, expected.
The crew was kind and helpful. Anything you wanted to do that they could help with, they did, and I'm sure they would for you.
The captain is very knowledgeable of the waters and made sure to get us to unique places and always had some information to offer.
So why a 3*? Here's why:
On day 1, you board at 5, then have a captains meeting from 6-7. Then you are released to go back in town to find your own dinner. I think this is a huge miss. We basically paid for the privilege of a safety briefing and a bed on a sailboat for the first night. We didn't leave port, and zero food whatsoever was provided. Not a welcome drink, not a glass of wine, some welcome snacks or even a pitcher of water was out. Once we got the briefing, we were cut loose for dinner in Rockland (not an impressive selection). Why not sail us somewhere and let us enjoy a sunset dinner in a bay. Big miss on day zero IMO.
The menu was horrendous. I have no other way to put it.
You get 3 lunches, 3 dinners, and four breakfasts.
All breakfasts are cooked to order, but are nothing special. Instant pancakes, bacon and eggs, stuff like that. I was totally fine with it, but nothing special to write home about.
Day 1: Lunch was a beef stew. Dinner was Atlantic salmon on rice with a sauce on it. Salmon was okay, but nothing special. The stew was not good at all.
Day 2: Lunch was a lobster bake on shore. Before going, we were warned to eat a ton because dinner would be light. The lobster bake was well executed. But the funny thing is, the chef doesn't participate, it's all done by the crew. We had lobster, steak, chicken, and corn on the cob. We got handed crackers for the lobster, but had to eat everything with our hands. Fun... Dinner was another soup (chorizo & lamb). The soup again was okay, nothing special. Being warned to eat a ton because dinner is light is another thing in poor taste IMO. What if I don't want to sit around feeling like a fat slug all afternoon because I had to eat so much just to be satisfied?
Day 3: this day sealed the deal. Lunch was salad and mac and cheese. Not lobster mac and cheese, not mac and cheese with some kind of meat in it. They fed us like we were in some pre-school on a budget. Dinner was overcooked pork loin. We did have oyster appetizers, thanks to another guest who picked some up on shore, and the captain added another dozen. The oysters, were absolutely amazing. Nothing like top-tier oysters as an appetizer for a pork loin dinner.
Needless to say, the food killed the experience for us. This was billed as a "culinary" experience. It was a culinary experience alright...a really bad one. My expectation was that we would eat locally inspired dishes. If you weren't keeping count, there was 1 meal, and it was excellent (lobster bake). It felt a lot more like food was a pesky budget item in the captain's ledger and spending as little as possible is the name of the game, quality be damned.
I was fine with the itinerary (post day zero) and thought the captain did a good job of showing us things we wouldn't see on a different style of vacation.
Finally, I'll touch on the age range and pace of the trip. This did not factor into my rating whatsoever (the food and day zero killed the rating). I wouldn't recommend this trip for anyone under 65, and that's pushing it. We're in our mid 40's and are active people. We liked the idea of slowing down and "going where the wind takes you". This was just too slow for us.
We loved Maine and can't wait to explore it on our own terms.