Seashore Condo Hotel

We've just come back from a wonderful weekend at this lovely condo hotel. We can't wait to return! The amenities were fantastic-- a peaceful room with efficiency kitchen, large outdoor areas for lounging, reading, and grilling. There were beach chairs and towels, bikes to rent, an outdoor shower, etc. It's a very quick walk to a spectacular beach, and a nice stroll to the center of town where we had a top-notch dinner at Rachel's (don't miss it!). The ferry is very close, so it's no problem not having a car. In fact, it was wonderful to have a break from traffic noise on this quiet, jewel of an island. Jeff and Brett are very friendly and helpful-- they can answer all of your questions!

My stay at the Seashore Condo Hotel was an absolute delight. I was warmly greeted by the owners Jeffrey and Brett for a relaxing beach side stay. The amenities were great, the beds very comfortable, a great tuck shop when you get peckish after all the shops were closed and the bike rental was super handy. My favorite offering was the outdoor shower, which has a great piece of landscaping leading into it with a massive rainfall shower head. Would stay there again in a heartbeat!

Had to give a one start because we had an emergency & couldn't stay. I tried reaching out to the Hotel several times asking for a refund or possibly stay another time! No Results by phone or email!! Never had an opportunity to give a Real Review!!

This is the second year that we stayed at the Seashore Hotel, and the experience was even better than last year. Some money was spent on the property, with a new fence and lots of planters with colorful flowers on the deck. The managers were as lovely and hospitable as ever, and very accommodating. They allowed us to leave our luggage at the hotel after we checked out to enjoy the beach on our last day, and also said it was fine to use the outdoor shower to get cleaned up before we got back on the ferry. These folks are awesome, and we will be recommending this hotel to as many people as possible. It's a great place with great value. Well done, Brett and Jeff!

This was our first time visiting Fire Island, and we will ABSOLUTELY come again and stay here! Jeff and Brett are the most amazing hosts and make you feel like family. The Seashore Condo Hotel was in the best location. Everything you need to enjoy the beach is provided so you don't have to bring it with you, from beach towels, chairs, to umbrellas! You will be thankful you chose the Seashore Condo Hotel!

We stayed in room 18. It has been recently renovated and it is beautiful and functional. It has a refrigerator and freezer so I always had Ice on hand. The AC is a beast, kept the place very cool and a super soft bed. You don't need to bring much. They supply towels for the room and beach, beach chairs, coffee and even bike rentals. We would highly recommend Seashore Condo Hotel

My husband and I love staying at Seashore Condo Hotel. This is our 4th time and it doesn’t disappoint. Room 16 , 2nd floor. - Accommodations were beautiful. Newly renovated bathroom! Location has a wonderful sense of community to relax with friends and other guests. We plan to be back!

It’s been a year since I posted my 5 star review of Seashore Condo Hotel in 2023. Just stayed here for a 5 day Labor Day weekend 2024, and if it’s even possible, my stay was even better. Every improvement they made only added to what is already a really nice hotel to stay at, and a great value. I love this place. Bret and Jeff are super nice, totally attentive. will always stay here when I come to Fire Island