Serpico's Restaurant

Charming family style red sauce Italian restaurant. Great vibes and lovely staff. The food was nostalgic and perfectly prepared for what it is. It not a “fancy” restaurant but it was one of the best restaurant experiences I’ve had in a while.

Found this place on our drive back from Haleakala National Park. We had the pizza and it was some of the best I have had! Owner was very friendly. If you like thin crust pizza this is the place!

What a great local restaurant! Pretty sure we were the only tourist in there at the time. It's not a big place, but they pack a lot of flavor in big portions! Stumbled upon this place on the way down the mountain. You can instantly see everyone comes for the pizza. It was neat to watch them hand toss the dough right there. The pizza was a bit New York style, with a crispy thin crust. The flavor was fantastic! We also got two pasta dishes, Vodka Penne was pretty good and very popular. I really enjoyed the Mahi Pasta, a great sauce and lots of fresh veggies. Plus the fish was perfect. The building is older and very simple, but that makes it so charming. It's a wonderful little place and the staff put a lot of love into their work. Be sure to check them out and support the locals. You won't be disappointed!

Small local joint. There was no air conditioning, but it was a cool day and it didn’t feel uncomfortable inside. There are no bathrooms. Food was served quickly and was fresh. Service was great. Our server was friendly. The food was average for being Italian food and was reasonably priced. The pepperoni cheesy garlic bread was good. Marinara sauce was on the sweeter side and not too chunky. It tasted great. The Philly cheesesteak was average. Bread on the sandwiches did taste like it was freshly baked in house. Chicken Parmesan was cooked to perfection, but would have likely the breading on the chicken to be seasoned. The Caesar salad dressing was delicious. Drinks come in can, not fountain drink. I would come back here again for the price point.

What a jewel we found there. We went there after our trip to watch the sunset on Haleakala. The atmosphere and food are just amazing and I can just recommend everyone to stop by and get something to eat there. The pizzas are huge and are enough for at least 2 people. Next time on Maui I will definitely visit again.

Conveniently located right off the main road when you’re headed out of Haleakalā. They are open late and have tons of food options. I enjoyed the penna alla vodka and pizza. The portions are huge! Would recommend getting only one entree per 2-3 people. The pasta also comes with salad and bread which were very yummy.

If only they would put more toppings on the pizza!!! I’ve eaten here 4 times. I’m allergic to gluten and dairy so the only thing I can eat here is the gluten-free pizza with no cheese. The first time I came here I tried the chicken wings, but they came out breaded, so I just picked all the breading off and there was barely any meat on the wings underneath. The next time I came, I asked if they can do chicken wings without breading and they said no, they are pre-breaded. So I’m glad they have a GF pizza crust, but there’s an upcharge for it of course. The last 3 times I ate here I ordered a gluten-free pizza with no cheese, extra pepperoni and grilled chicken toppings. Every single time there was barely ANY toppings. Like seriously 10 little pepperonis and maybe 1oz of chicken bits on the entire pizza, which cost me $30 plus tip. I basically paid $35 for some pizza crust with very little red sauce. I don’t know why they charged me for extra pepperoni when there was barely a normal amount of pepperoni. This place really skimps on the protein. I should have gone to foodland for a poke bowl.

Photo of New Jersey (my home state) is on the menu. And the Italian themed food is authentic and good.

This is our late night go to place in Upcountry Pukalani. They serve big portions of pasta! They also have delicious Jersey Style Pizza and other entrees. The service is friendly and fast. They are hard workers and helpful. It's casual and great for after sports events to go to for dinner. You can dine in or take out. It's also a good place for a quick lunch. They usually have a lunch special with 2 slices of pizza.

We came here twice in a row. First night was a takeout order after the sunset view at the Haleakala summit. Our condo was on the west side of the island, so it took an hour after getting our food before eating them. We ordered the chicken parm, and the pepperoni calzone, and caesar salad. All were delicious, especially the caesar salsa. We couldn't understand why the average rating on yelp was only 3.9 stars. It was definitely 5 stars! We did the road to Hana the following day, and decided to dine in at this place considering our previous experience. However, we were disappointed as the dishes were all under-seasoned. We got the chicken parm again, and fettuccine alfredo, and kid's spaghetti with meatball. Chicken parm was the best of of three but lacked flavor compared to the takeout order from the previous night. And half the amount of chicken. Fettuccine was very bland. It is almost like the chef forgot to add salt and parm. The amount of salt i added to the dish was embarrassing if the chef saw me. The kid's spaghetti with meatball was decent, but the meatball was on the dry side and again lacked of salt. My son didn't like the meatball but loved the spaghetti. I would give it 3 stars for this dine-in experience. Service was great. My suggestion is to get the takeout order because the hour that took us to drive home probably enhanced the flavor of the chicken parm. Either that or the chef changed from Tuesday to Wednesday. Also, skip the fettuccine Alfredo unless you like milk flavored bland noodles.

We stopped into Serpico's Pizzeria late on a Saturday night with a group of six, there's a small parking lot that is shared and when we got inside there was only one other table of guests. I will say that I saw countless pick up orders throughout our visit- this was was really busy even though it was almost empty inside. We started with cheese sticks, they were good but our meals were 10 times better. We tried three different pastas (alfredo, spaghetti and red meat sauce) the portions are huge and enough to share between two people. We also ordered a pork pizza, again- the size was big and easily shared between two or three people. We also ordered a steak Caesar salad, was it enough for a meal? Maybe, but it helped having an app and some pizza to share. Service was great and the vibes were open and carefree- no rushing here and don't worry about over staying your welcome, everyone was friendly!

We really enjoyed a late lunch here last week. Our server was very friendly and quick. The menu is huge and makes it hard to decide what to get. The chicken broccoli fettuccini was great and came with salad and focaccia bread, as did the salmon and veggie pasta. Great big portions and great flavors. Note that sodas are just cans with ice cup. This is a great place to go when visiting the national park.

Pizza was solid. It was pretty big for a medium sized. It's also a thin crust pizza which is my favorite kind. The restaurant is a little older and in an older building. And there's a takeout window or you have a choice to dine-in. We ordered a "Serpico's Special" with no mushrooms. Service was quick and our server was very attentive. We could also see our pizza being made in front of us which was a plus.

July 30 - the entire Pacific Rim is on tsunami alert. All of the Hawaiian islands are evacuating to higher ground. 100s of thousands are displaced. We arrive at Serpico's at 935pm, hungry and scared. My son and diabetic father need to eat... Girl at takeout window tells us the kitchen is closed, even though the sign says last take out order at 945pm. Explain our situation, ask to be the last order, told "no." Then she takes an order from another couple for a desert. As we walk out other families are heading in looking for service, doubt they got it. Way to go Serpico's.

We just love this place! My husband and son have become pizza snobs since eating here. Their crust is thin and crispy and toppings are generous. But I've got a admit that they have a really good burger as well. They will deliver to the 96768 zip code. We typed in our address and got a msg saying they cant deliver to our area. So we called them. Luckily, the delivery driver said that it was ok. Thanks for saving our Saturday night dinner!

Lovely, small town pizzeria with a long standing in the community. Friendly service as usual. Breadsticks were new (to me) but crispy-soft and seved with marinara. It was an off night for the pasta, as the rigatoni was overcooked but the sauce was amazingly cheesy and was lipsmaking good. It will be a good breakfast scrambled with egg and fried. Chicken on my chicken caesar was excellently seasoned and *generously* portioned. I could have easily split it with my date. I should have asked for extra dressing. I ate all the greens and we threw the remaining chicken onto his rigatoni. We ordered their appetizer wings and they arrived breaded so they looked huge to me. The bbq sauce was delicious. I would come again.

Pretty good overall! I was only able to get takeout instead of eating in, but I loved the Chicken Parm sandwich! Definitely want to try the plate if I get a chance to next time - Miguel Morales Photography

Good service and ambiance. Solid meatball pasta dish, bread, wine, and lemon cake dessert.

So bummed. I've gone to Serpicos for years with mostly good results, but recently the quality has suffered. Our wings were so salty they were inedible (not exaggerating had to throw them away!), fries were burnt. Both calamari and Philly steak sub had almost no salt or flavors.

So great! Fresh made dough, fresh ingredients and the service was helpful and friendly. Charming interior and great Pizza!!! Mahalo!

How can 1 establishment be excellent on all menu items daily, consistently Q this place is the bomb dignity! We ordered at least twice if not 3 x a week,every week. It's the best! Their lasagne is excellent!

Can't speak to the pizzas, but the sandwiches use some of the worst bread I've ever put in my mouth. Tasted like cardboard, felt like swallowing chalk dust.

Really cool find. Really good food. Super super inexpensive. The best service. Adding this to the rotation when im upcountry.

One of the best places on Maui for pizza! Good entrees and sandwiches too. My preferred pizza has a thin, crisp crust, not much sauce and cheese, cheese, cheese! Yes, I was officially, a Cheesehead - having moved to Maui from the far North Chicago suburbs (which happen to be in Wisconsin). The 2 things every town in the Upper Midwest seems to have is at least 1 pizza shop and 1 Mexican restaurant. So we've eaten just ALL the pizza on Maui's and Serpico's is our favorite. The former favorite used to be Prison Stree Pizza in Lahaina (same owners as Serpico's). Great pizza!

Ordered a large supreme the outer crust so hard my dog chewed it like a bone, the center so soggy the crust was like soggy bread, cheese in center not melted looked like cottage cheese. Definitely not the same as when Hatch was there cooking. My second bad pizza from there. Will not return or recommend any more

The food was good and the price was reasonable. We ordered a Serpico's pizza and a sub sandwich. The crust was really good and not oily. Also got a salad but no photo.

I was craving Italian food and came across this gem. The pizza is fresh pizza, they prep it and bake it in front of you! The flavors are savory.. we got a large Buffalo chicken pizza, it was more than enough for two people and we had some to go. I also ordered the nutty hula cheesecake, which was delicious. If you're ever around here I would definitely recommend stopping by!

Food was amazing and the customer service from Aliza was outstanding! Needed a pasta fix and this sure hit the spot. Wish this place was back in Wisconsin. Thank you Aliza and cooks for a great meal before we fly back home.

Oh so good! I've gone five times. It was my first time here, I had the meatballs and spaghetti with a side Cesar salad. I took the Cesar salad only because the owner walked up to me and my friend from Zumba and told us his grandma made this homemade recipe, and this is what he uses. This was back maybe 2009. Since then, I've been back only four more times and never seems to amaze me how good their pizzas tasted and the salad. The only thing is I've become older, the music is just to loud to talk stories with the family of more than a party of four but then I found it hard to talk stories with a party of three. Maybe I'll opt for takeout. Only thing, by the time I reach down to Kahului and onto my dinner table, condensation will happen and colder pizza or burger and fires.

Spent my last day in Maui just driving and exploring. Stopped in as I hand a hankering for a pizza lunch. It is AWESOME! So delicious! I had three slices of the Serpico's Special. The crust was perfection. Service and prices are excellent! Highly recommend! The menu is extensive so you will satisfy any craving.

I know it's a staple and people love it, but my pizza was just OK. The chairs was a bit rubbery and there was not enough sauce.

Perfect place to go after a visit to Haleakala sunset. The place was quiet when we first entered, but got full really quick, and their take out window was constantly busy. We ordered a 30 inch pizza (that would have been enough for all four of us), it was perfectly baked! The crust was crunchy, not too thin, not too thick. Toppings were great too (pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, peppers). Cesar salad was delicious. Calamari was ok. Lasagna was delicious too! Would recommend this place if you're ever upcountry.

Small, casual dining room with great options for the whole family. Pasta, pizza, sandwiches, burgers, salads, good selection of wine, beer as well. I find the service is always friendly and attentive. Only thing is sometimes the cooking is inconsistent depending on the cooks/chef that's on shift.

Oh my.... I just need to share how amazingly yummy the lasagna is.... Conveniently, I called in my order and spoke to a gracious person... she was warm and patient. I ordered the traditional lasagna- first time for me... Not only was it amazing, the portions were plentiful! I love that food pickup is so easy with their order window. They also have theeee best Caesar salad dressing!

Great pizza! Hands down one of the best crust and flavors I've put into my mouth. This place knows flavors and portions. The fresh tomatoes and basil side was a perfect balance to the pepperoni and sausage side! I would definitely recommend. Would be sweet if we had a spot in Kihei

Great spot for pizza in upcountry Maui. Super good pizza. Easy to order and picked up on time. Nice to have great pizza and garlic bread in Maui. We were craving pizza and heard great things about Serpico's glad we tried it. Highly recommend!

Are you kidding me??? We got a pizza, garlic bread and shrimp fra diavlo and everything was SO GOOD. You can tell how fresh the ingredients are. Will definitely be ordering again.

Delicious food with the coolest staff ever! Free bread, we got the meatball sub and lasagna. 10/10 Thank you guys

Amazing food! Very nice staff. Attentive. Very reasonably priced and they use all fresh ingredients. We all had calzones and Cesar salad (not too fishy). Plenty of parking. Highly recommend!

Great local Pizza and Italian restaurant. Large portions, great prices and friendly servers. Pizzas are large and delicious.

While visiting Maui we googled a nice pizza place and we arrived here. The food was really good. My husband and I ordered a hamburger and Italia sub and they were both delicious. My kids ordered a pizza and they ate it all. Prices were reasonable and the waiter was the best. Service was prompt and everyone of the workers were friendly. I highly recommend this place

Pizza was pretty good here! I've been to Prison Street Pizza (formerly ) in Lahaina, and didn't realize the owners are the same. Food was good. Most of the staff seemed exhausted, they were not unkind, just had no energy.

Friendly, quick service and amazing food. We had the pizza and the garlic cheese bread and the flavors were amazing!!

My wife and I love Serpico's. The pizza is great freshly made, and friendly people. we have eaten there many times and every time it was enjoyable.

Great service, ambiance and food! One of our favorite spots during our stay here. We got the blackened mahi sandwich and it was really tasty! Highly recommend coming here if you're staying in the area :)

So if you are looking for a place that stays open a little later than the rest of Maui and you're headed back from Hana or the crater, this is your stop. The have great pizzas and a good beer and wine list. The pizzas are hand tossed right in full view of the patrons and will wow the kids! Well even wow the parents too! Awesome, perfectly cooked thin crust pizza with homemade sauce, you will love this pizza for sure. The atmosphere isn't all that amazing if you are looking for a beach or ocean view, or any view at all. It is in a little business building next to a gas station but just enjoy the food and great service and save those wishes for another day. Fast and friendly service with really good pizza, what else can you ask for?

Came here one night while looking for a late meal in Pukalani. Its one of the few places open past 9pm. I ordered a slice of pizza with kalua pork and a side salad. A bonus was the breadsticks that came to the table for free. Everything was super tasty. The pizza slice was large and filling and the breadsticks were amazing. I had to control myself on the bread. I would definitely go back. I see they serve wine but I didnt partake. However, I could see myself going back for a sip.

Serpico's This straightforward neighborhood pizza restaurant renovated the dining area before Covid newvtables they added a liquor license including a cocktail menu but frankly although I still like the place I didn't feel it was an improvement, What last night the Real Serpico's reemerged's local pizza restaurant with friendly service Good food the tables have been spread out a little bit for Covid which made them comfortable they were busy the pizza cook was knocking out the orders as quickly as she could throw the pizzas. The two servers that waited on us were friendly and attentive and gave a damn about us and their jobs much better than the last couple of high-end restaurants I went to where the service was in different. We had a Serpico special with added garlic and ricotta cheese loved it and the garlic flavor came through Serpico's has a very good marinara sauce which I get a side of and dip my pizza into there from New Jersey and the recipes show. I'm so happy they are still in business and appear to be thriving

Great Pizza selection, all portions worth the price, great service. Love their buffalo wings!

We were warmly welcomed as soon as we walked into the restaurant. We promptly ordered a pizza to go and waited while it was baked, about 20 minutes. Told it was better than Boston Pizza on Oahu, we were willing to try it. We ordered a small Serpico's Special, substituting black olives for green peppers. The pizza was flat crusted, which I prefer, and piping hot. It was good. I'd like to return to try some of the pastas and salads on the menu.

After watching the sunset at Haleakala we were struggling to find somewhere for dinner that was open past 9pm and stumbled across this place in the Upcountry. It's perfect! Cosy, family feel with oven-baked pizza. The server was friendly and helpful and we weren't rushed out. The pizza had a great texture - so much better than those conveyer-belt pizzas. Can't beat oven-baked base! The flavour was a little sweet (we got pulled pork with chili) but good overall and a very decent portion! Highly recommended if in the upcountry.

Great place to dine after Haleakala sunset. We had different combinations of pizzas that delighted the 12 of us. We sat outside to eat under the stars at the picnic benches.

Aloha is sadly gone from this restaurant. Arrived and in the door by 9:24PM. Per the sign we should have still been able to be sat. They claimed they had no room, but they had an open 2 top and 1 lady sitting by herself at a 4 top. So one of those (2) 2 tops could have been moved over to easily seat us. I explained we just wanted a hot meal. The lady said we could still order but had to sit outside. We stood outside in the wind trying to figure out what we wanted. Tables had cleared and we asked again if we could please be sat inside. The guy we were talking to now said No, sorry you have to be sat by 9:25, we have to closed at a certain time. Despite my better judgement we still ordered. When I tried to order a beer they told me I had to sit inside for that. I'm pretty sure it's Hawaii law, but this definitely added to the aggravation of the experience. Italian sub 4/10 - Bread was burnt, not enough flavor from seasonings/Italian dressing - fries hot & crunchy - didn't try coleslaw because it was watery Buffalo Wings 7.5/10 - breaded and yummy - nice heat - caution when eating a few of our bones splintered Pizza 7/10 - Crispy and Fluffy at the same time, good sauce to cheese ratio, crust burnt which gave it a lower rating Customer service 0/10 Our family of four ordered, received, ate AND left BEFORE the 1 lady taking up the four top that was sat before 9:25.... Whole experience could have been different if they treated all customers equal and with aloha. Customer service still matters!!!

Ordered the calzone not knowing it was the size of a small child! It was also delicious! Small dining area, but worth the wait and staff are wonderful.

Although their name is Pizzeria, their menu offers a selection of pastas, sandwiches, appetizers and salads! Their gluten-free crust had a nice combination of crispy crunch and softness. The buffalo chicken sandwich had good flavor, tasting the buffalo sauce with every bite! The coleslaw was not what we are used to. Had quite a vinegar kick. I also tried the chicken tenders with honey mustard sauce. The tenders are like any other but the sauce brought it to life. It was SO GOOD! Kept me coming back for more! The spaghetti was LARGE! Even for a take-out option which I was pleased with. The meatballs, also huge we're very tasty. For additional comfort food, we ordered the garlic bread and mozzarella sticks. YUM! An excellent meal for sure! Knocked off 1 star because once arriving at home, I noticed 1 of my 2 sandwiches & coleslaw were not in the package. I quickly checked the bag before leaving and assumed it was all there (my order was somewhat large). Thankfully after calling, I was reassured that my items were there and ready and the employee genuinely apologized. When I returned for my remaining items, thankfully the server double checked my order and realized my coleslaw was still MIA. A little bit of a bummer but I'm grateful that server apologized and remediate the issue.

My experience here wasn't great. My one star goes to the waitresses prompt service. Eating inside wasn't great-- it felt hot, and wasn't too clean. I cannot accurately judge the pizza, since I did not have any of that. Although, we were served a 3-piece of bread that we could have easily done without. We ordered a calamari plate and spaghetti with meatballs. We did not enjoy it. We only ate enough to fill our bellies and left much behind. In summary, very bland food. The food comes out so quickly, it makes me wonder if they care more about influx of traffic rather than putting much effort into taste and expertise. I do not recommend this eatery, even if you're craving Italian like I was.

Hidden gem in upcountry! Stopped in after Maui Gold Pineapple farm tour. Fantastic pizza and lasagna. Excellent value for the price. Staff and service were excellent. Will definitely be going back!