Sheridan Inn, BW Signature Collection

Wow this place will surprise you. We have stayed at nice hotels before but this one really is top notch. Jeremiah Tryon is executive chef the restaurant is very well managed. Wait staff were wonderful great timing not too forward but very willing and eager to serve. The food was wonderful! Kali Smith the General manager is very present to ensure each guest has a great experience. The common areas to include our room were very clean, thank you to the housekeepers for their diligence. Not very often a five star is given but the Sheridan Inn is deserving.

Absolutely incredible. This place is priceless. It honestly feels like walking intro a family reunion (but perhaps friendlier.) 😂🤣🤣 The rooms are an amazing blend of history and modern elegance. The restaurant & staff (particularly Miss Jennifer,) were equally as wonderful in every aspect. We could never articulate what a pleasant experience this hotel is.

Beautiful with all the charm of our historic Western life. The train just across the street also added to it charm. Restaurant was elegant and first class food. Thanks for keeping this beautiful Inn a working tourist destination.

This is NOT your run-of-the-mill hotel. Instead, it's a historic and very cool place to stay. If you're looking for TVs and in-room fridges, this isn't the place for you. However, if you're into history, unique rooms, and clawfoot tubs (vs. showers) check this place out. Each room is unique and has several period-style things inside. The place oozes with character. It may not have some of the conveniences of modern hotels, such a place to easily load/unload, but there are luggage carts and an elevator. Our room didn't have a shower, rather, a clawfoot tub with a shower sprayer. And again, no TV or fridge, but that was OK by me. The hotel does have fast WiFi, so you can still work. I'd also highly recommend this Best Western over the Best Western Center which is around the corner. My only gripe? The cold breakfast could've been better. Granted, when we stayed there, there was only one other room rented (it was right after Christmas), so having a full hot breakfast would've been a waste. Hey, at least the coffee was hot and fresh, albeit out of a Keurig. There are Keurigs in the room, too. There was tons of parking and the staff was super helpful and friendly, providing good recommendations of places to eat and drink. The hotel also has gobs of historical information about this hotel which was built in 1890. We'll most definitely stay here again.

We visited Open Range restaurant inside the hotel||The meal was fantastic ! Enjoyed the pork chop, and a New York strip. Had a fantastic wedge salad also. The server was exceptional, Walking us through the menu and making great recommendations about the winelist. She was extremely attentive to our table in spite of getting a 10 top and her section at nearly the same time. All the staff seemed like they were trained well and experienced.||Really nice meal !

Great place to stay! Beautiful and historical with access to everything in the area! The restaurant was great!

Such a cool historic hotel with very kind staff, really interesting artifacts and pictures throughout. And a nice cozy, clean room with a remodeled bathroom that maintained the historic feel. We’ll definitely stay again when we visit Sheridan!

Very historic building but rooms are sparse, lobby was dark, manager was less than helpful. We left without even asking for a refund. Room just had a bathtub, no shower, no tv. Honestly it was a bit creepy. We decided to keep driving to Cody rather than stay the night.

Awesome hotel and great staff. The restaurant attached is really nice. Love the rooms, I stayed in the Queen Victorian. Really great

Everything! Love the town and the inn. They're super accommodating, have amazing breakfast, and are so welcoming. You will love it! Enjoy! There is a fabulous Mexican restaurant downtown. I haven't had time to review yet, but will try to. Sheridan Inn, Mexican dinner and my love! Perfect.

While we did not stay at the hotel we did have dinner they and take a walk around. The service and food was phenomenal. Kaci the general manager and Amanda our server really made our night by taking the time to get to know us while we dined. We cannot wait to go back there again and stay at the hotel next time. I'd recommend you do the same. Oh PS they have a nice wine list and the prices are more than palatable. Elk dinner was mouth watering, not even a drop of sauce was left. The berry cobbler was a highlight as well.

We booked a refundable room for a trip to Yellowstone. Unfortunately we had to cancel. It was 16 days prior to our scheduled arrival and we were DENIED A REFUND. It seems, even with a refundable room, you have to provide a ONE MONTH NOTICE. It may be a lovely place, but I cannot give anyone a good review when they take a customers money without providing any service at all. DO NOT BOOK THIS HOTEL UNLESS YOU ALSO BUY TRAVEL INSURANCE.

This is a cool hotel once part-owned by "Buffalo Bill" Cody. It has rooms kept as original as possible and dedicated to his Wild West Show. The restaurant called Open Range (OR), is awesome with great food and drinks and the hotel and restaurant staff are really nice. Beds are comfy too! Would be good to have a white-noise source to help block the rumble of the occasional train that comes through but really not that bad (no horns), just a low rumble.

One of the best hotels! The rooms are very clean and well taken care of. You can tell the staff has paid attention to detail with little touches in the room most chain hotels lack. Each room is named after a person Buffalo Bill knew, a wonderful way to tie into the rich history. The staff was very kind and attentive and helped assist us in all of our needs. The rooms come with breakfast vouchers for a restaurant across the street. Such unique and delicious food!! The kids appreciated the experience of having real keys to open our room. It's rare to come across that these days!

This is a very special place. There's a ton of history and it's quite unique. The rooms are also super clean, comfortable and spacious. If you're in town, you should stay here overnight. What an experience!

We were in Sheridan for a family funeral and decided to have all of our family members stay here. It was perfect! The owners have done a fabulous job remodeling this historic hotel to its original state. In addition to being well cared for, it was so nice and clean (and I am picky about cleanliness). The staff was terrific - friendly and accommodating. Even gave us a historical tour of the hotel! The room included a free breakfast at a local cafe, which was delicious! I saw a review where someone complained about no televisions on the property. Personally, I love that there are no tv's. It's nice to have a break! My thanks to the owners and staff for making our stay memorable!

Lovely place with lots of history and comfortable clean rooms. Breakfast was nice by a real wood fire!

As part of a major tour company which brings in a group of 50 every day of the summer for lunch, let me tell you fellow Yelpers, you are making a great choice stopping by for a meal at the Inn. The service we receive daily from the staff for launch, Susan, Leslie, Max and others, is first rate. From the various, tasty sandwich choices, to the homemade, remarkable potato chips, to the unique Russian cream dessert, our guest continually rave about the quality of the food, the grandeur of the historic Inn, and the memorable rosewood bar. Kudos to the Inn's staff for making our daily lunch spot a highlight of our tour day! We only wish we had a chance to stay and experience a night where so many legends have laid their heads through the years.

Well maintained, historical hotel but is not what it promises to be. First, there is no restaurant or bar which was very disappointing. Our room came with breakfast but we were given a $5.30 voucher for a restaurant done the road. The room is updated and tasteful but very small (I.e., no closet, no tv, no amenities, bathtub only). Lobby is attractive but not like the photos suggest. The area around the hotel is sketchy with boarded up houses, The air conditioning vent is right above the headboard blowing right on one's face at night. Definitely not worth $200 per night!

The hotel it self was good! But their policy of finders keepers was extremely disappointing! I forgot 5 items in the closet and when i called the hotel the next day I was told "we did not find it!!" I believe when housekeeping cleans the room they must look over the room whole entire room. They cannot find my 5 items! I find that hard to believe! I was told they were investigating the situation. I called back numerous time that I wanted to speak to the manager, messages were left for him but he never returned my call. It is now September still no answer I stayed there on the long weekend in August! I am so troubled with their policy of FINDERS KEEPERS!!!! you need to look at your staff why they are keeping your customer garments!!!!!

The Inn itself is neat and the rooms are done well. Cool to visit. Our room was nice but right on 2 roads with lots of traffic and a train that was stopped loudly in front of the hotel around 6 am. The guests in the room next to us talked until past midnight loudly and we could hear every word they said followed by loud snoring starting at 1 am. Terrible night of sleep. Sadly I messaged both of the night staff around 11:30 to see if there was anything we could do (we were given the numbers upon check in as no one was there overnight) and no one replied or ever said anything about our issues. The highlight was the claw foot tub which we used and proceeded to flood the bathroom as it was broken and we weren't informed prior to use.

This BW had what we needed for this stay. Bunk beds with two queens for a reasonable price. No elevator was a bit inconvenient but we had several people to help carrying things. MW bank down the hall not ideal but better than none. Not enough counter space in large room. Temp was good. Shower head too lower for avg height adults. Toilet overflowed. Staff arrived with plunger but no mop. I sopped it up with towels and sprayed with Lysol I always bring now. Breakfast was not a buffet. Made to order three small choices. We didn't even go to it one of two mornings. Our day started early and no time to wait. Staff was nice. Most everybody in Sheridan is nice.

Newly remodeled suite was great! Super comfortable bed and really cool shower/tub. Bummer the restaurant bar, which is a historic bar sent by the Queen of England, is closed until further notice. Check in process was nice but could use a little updating for speed. If you're out of the hotel past 11pm, you're locked out and need to call to get back in. I can imagine that could be a problem.

We ended up here by accident in transit - looking after a hotel! Already when entering the lobby, we knew that it would be nice to stay here. We were but more overwhelmed by the room, we get a dream of nostalgia have combined with modern facilities and convenience, plus the attention to detail! After making fresh, we are in the restaurant, at the bar, since all the tables were occupied - always a good sign! Very fine American cuisine, class cocktails and enought staff...! You can highly recommend this House! Perfect!

While the location, lobby and rooms were 4 star, the management and customer service gives this hotel a 1 star. Poor desk service that went beyond inattentive and rude. No refunds for unused rooms that we had to cancel with multiple days warning - that were later booked by hotel is not hospitable and fair dealing. Never going back - I'll have to go back to the corporate places. Not to mention rooms didn't have tv's.

A wonderful hotel, and especially as a historic hotel! A local actually told us it had been recently renovated, so I don't know what it was like before, but it was fantastic. The hotel still has all the right feel of history but with the subtle, elegant updates that fit and add the right amount of modern comfort. The bed was SUPER comfortable, There were nice upscale touches like water bottles in the room and chocolate chip scones. There is a nice set up for a continental breakfast in the morning in the Lady's parlor which has the feel of a movie set..but you can actually enjoy eating in there! It was easy to book online, and the hotel had great communication on email with booking and questions, and at check in, very helpful with historic tidbits on the hotel and information on useful things with the hotel. They have "common" areas which are couches, chairs, some books just outside of the rooms on the top, 3rd floor, with Keurigs so that you can help yourself to some tea or coffee at your schedule...though we ended up not doing that since we felt it might be intrusive to anyone staying up on that floor, but the area looked welcoming and comfortable. The other GREAT thing was being just off the main street where bars and restaurants were, which allowed us to walk around and check the town out a little on foot. HIGHLY recommend this place and would absolutely stay here again.

Last weekend was my first visit to Sheridan. I absolutely loved the town and this hotel. The main areas of the hotel are decorated with antiques and several beautiful stone fireplaces. The restaurant and bar were gorgeous and the food was very good. The guest rooms are also lovely and comfortable with nicely finished bathrooms. The hotel is in walking distance of Main Street with so many shops, restaurants and bars it will take several more visits to see them all. I'm pretty sure this hotel spoiled any chance of me staying anywhere else in Sheridan - unless it's booked up the next time I plan a trip...

The food is by far the best in all of Sheridan. My fav is the chicken fried chicken with mash potatoes and gravy! Don't forget the root beer which is locally made at Luminous brewery in Sheridan!

A historic hotel in downtown. Close to a number of restaurants, which was fortunate as their's was closed. Lots of western art and books set around to look at. Not real convenient for those needing a wheelchair as the ramp was on the opposite end of the building from the one door you can enter. Close to the tracks and even thought the trains do not use their airhorn, they make enough noise to wake a light sleeper. (Heavier insulated curtains may help.) An old building with a lot of creaking floors and vibrations, they could pass it off as haunted. A great place for the history minded but if you really need your sleep I would recommend elsewhere.

The Sheridan Inn is located in the historical area of Sheridan WY. When we arrived, we parked at the south parking lot of the Inn. Frankly, the area surrounding the Inn is rather industrial although the Inn itself is gorgeous. After trying to open several doors which were all locked, we finally made it around the Inn and found the open door leading to the registration counter. Once inside, the person at the counter warmly welcomed us. In fact, she even gave us a short tour of the Inn after checking us in. Moreover, she also made a reservation for us at the Open Range restaurant that is located within the Inn. Good thing the Inn has an elevator as our Broncho Billy room was on the third floor. After a long day on the road, it would have been disheartening to have to lug our luggage up the stairs to the third floor. The Broncho Billy room was marvelous. The furnishings were appropriately of a western motif. The bed was very comfortable. My wife found the bed to be so comfortable that she slept soundly through the night. As this was the 17th day of of our road trip, this was a major accomplishment. The area outside of our room had comfortable couches and chairs. The breakfast was simple but scrumptious. The staff person whom we saw in the morning was very cordial and friendly. If you are in Sheridan, I highly recommend the Sheridan Inn. How often do you have an opportunity to stay at a fantastic historical hotel where Buffalo Bill once held court? Add in the reasonable rates, the comfortable rooms, and nice ambience, you will definitely enjoy staying at the Inn.

Most people just pass through Sheridan. The newly opened Sheridan Inn should give you a reason to make the old west town your destination. I stayed here for one night in the Ned Buntline room right next to the Buffalo Bill room. Surprisingly classy and well thought out decor - was expecting the traditional slight tackiness associated with themed rooms. Everything was modern and unique (and comfy)- I spent half an hour just exploring the details. Watched a sunset on the historic porch while eating bison nachos (!!!) and drinking wine from the attached restaurant. Listened to a bluegrass band jam on another section of the porch during my dinner. A real treat, and a great welcome to a great western experience in a beautiful part of the country. Staff was friendly and I hope I will be back soon!

Prearranged lunch stop on our tour. We were told that our lunch would we awaiting us when we walked into the dining room... and it was. We were told we could take half a sandwich and either a salad or a cup of soup. The problem is that those of us at the end of the line were left with little more than scraps. Tasty scraps, but scraps nonetheless. The people at the front of the line got a choice or shaved prime rib or Reuben sandwiches along with either tossed salad or a cup of creamy beef barley and mushroom soup. Those of us at the back got Reuben tidbits and lots of lettuce with a cherry tomato or two. The ranch dressing was tasty and the meat was tender. The lemon cake that was served for dessert was moist and tasty.

Great historic hotel, very comfortable room/bed, beautiful newly renovated bathrooms, lovely lobby and great staff. We were treated with great service. Buffalo Bill was the original operator of this hotel in early 1900's. How cool is that? Looking forward to staying here again!

Decent food, but a more of a tourist trap. The Inn has been wonderfully restored and redone, but the restaurant's food was still a little shaky. Their bacon is a very strange super-peppery bacon that detracts from the meal ( I wanted the Bison Burger, not strange super-peppery bacon with a side of bison burger). I'm sure they will improve with the time, and the manager on duty was super responsive and helpful, so kudos!

It would be hard not to like the states here. They also have a large bar area and a decent appetizer selection. Great for dinners!

Stayed last weekend in Sheridan, WY to attend the Battle of Little Big Horn anniversary events at the historical site/battlefield and on the Crow Agency. We ate dinner at the Sheridan Inn on Saturday. My husband had the prime rib--which is loved and I had the chicken fried chicken breast, which was also very, very good. Service was good. The hotel was hosting a wedding reception, so we ended up parking about a block away from the hotel/restaurant. We had considered staying at the hotel, but ended up at the Hampton Inn instead. That was a good choice, because the Sheridan Inn has limited parking, so by the time we got back from the events at Little Big Horn, we would not have had an overnight parking space in the hotel's small lot. The food was very, very good. I'm glad we decided to eat there that evening.

Its clean, comfortable. Thats all I wanted, just a place to sleep. I took the time to seek out an affordable pet friendly room on Expedia and booked this one. Traveling with two well cared for medium dogs. The office computer was down and I was asked to pay a pet fee in cash. This took a long time and a line of tired people formed behind me as I did not have cash and his credit card machine was on the blink. As I got my key the owner told me it is harder to deal with online reservations and I could have saved money and had no pet fee if I had come in person. Why?? I am still confused....

November 18, 2017. If you bill yourself as high end hotel and the rooms are relatively expensive you need a restaurant to match the rooms. We were there with family who are local and it was just prior to Thanksgiving week. There were eight of us including two children. The food was mostly SYSCO, cold, late, and the service was poor. I worked in restaurants for six years in high school and college from bus boy through room service, dining room waiter, bellman and filled in as a line cook and this place's food was poorly prepared. The hostess had no idea of her job and just hung around the front entrance. The waitress was nice enough but hampered by a slow kitchen. If there was an executive chef he must have been off and the line cooks must have been drinking. I know there was no expediter. Simple things: 1. Bread should be warmed (they have machines that do that) and a variety is appropriate. How hard is it to throw in a little cranberry or walnut bread, perhaps a scone or small biscuit, or hard bagette. I know they have no pastry chef or baking staff. The commercial rolls were a little below Golden Corral and the butter was rock hard (again they have machines that regulate the temperature of butter). 2. When a hamburger ordered by a seven year old is sent back because it has blood running on the plate, don't send it back out still rare. Here is a clue. Most children generally don't like to eat blood in their meat. There is a reason its a kids menu. Kids want simple food, that they have tried before and is not threatening. 3. Poor (late, slow, inconsistent) service was explained away by the staff by having a banquet party scheduled somewhere in the hotel. Here's a thought, bring in more people to work or is this the first banquet to ever book in the hotel. 4. Try to bring most of the food out at the same time especially if its over an hour between ordering and service. 5. Try to bring most of the food out somewhere between suitably warm and hot as the food would dictate. 6. The bison soup was home made but lacked salt, flavor and anything to distinguish it from beef soup. And nothing says high end like two little packs of cellophane wrapped Nabisco crackers on the side of your plate. 7. When you order the "chef's special" (in this case fried chicken) you assume it's somehow "special" or at least fresh chicken (not pre-cooked and breaded), hot and possibly juicy. Alas, this chicken fell off the back of a truck already breaded for the convention oven and had that Banquet TV dinner taste that I remember from my Mom's hurried efforts to feed her kids. It was also the size of an undernourished quail. 8. The room was noisy, crowded and awkwardly arranged. The bathroom had a "college bar" quality to it. I have read the other reviews and wonder if I was in the same hotel. I assume the rooms are great and they would have to be to make up for the food and service of the dining room. The chef, most cooks, banquet manager, food and beverage manager and whoever trains the wait staff need to go somewhere else.

Great historical joint! Very friendly staff and nice clean rooms! Only complaint was no TV in any of the rooms. However, this is probably the best hotel in Sheridan! I still don't understand why TVs aren't present in all hotels but hey, it is not my call. If you're interested in something different come here for a great experience!

Our recent stay at the Sheridan Inn was remarkable. The rooms are lovely, beds and bedding luxe, quiet quiet quiet, staff friendly and helpful. Each of the rooms is unique and named for one of Buffalo Bill Cody's Wild West Show stars. I can't recommend it highly enough. Sheridan itself is a lovely town with lots to see and do. We'll be back. PS The in house restaurant, Open Range, has great food and drink. We ate there every night!

Wonderful experience in a historical setting. Was pleasantly surprised on how good the food was. What a pleasure to enjoy well prepared food and the western ambiance.

First of all, I expected a smaller room, as I was traveling alone. I was booked into the Lillian Francis Smith room. This being said, I did not expect a room that could barely hold the queen size bed. There were gables that encroached into the room which limited the walking space to about 2 feet beyond the bed. There was no closet, only a rack mounted on the wall. No TV or radio. The bathroom, although spotlessly clean, had a clawfoot tub, with a hand-held shower wand, but no shower curtain. Sleeping became a challenge when it became apparent that the trains (just across the street) ran all night long. They did stop blowing their horns at 9:30PM, but started up again at 6AM. OK, there is a continental breakfast. Sliced white and wheat bread, half frozen english muffins, no bagels (although there was cream cheese) and some decent coffee, cream available, but no sugar. For $180 a night I expected a little more effort. The Open Range restaurant was a pleasant experience. the Chicken Fried Steak was tender and well flavored. It was covered in a maple flavored gravy with real mashed potatoes which was a nice surprise. The roasted asparagus was well past it's prime, the stalks were approaching tree sapling size, but they were nicely roasted and had great flavor. All in all, I can say that I've stayed at the Sheridan Inn, but I won't be back.