Sicily Pizzeria & Lounge Bar

The absolute best pizza I’ve eaten in Sicily. Sicily Pizzeria was recommended to us by a local, it was the only pizza place he recommended in Ortigia, not because the rest are bad, but because he knows this business and they make great pizza. I had to stop the owner to ask about the crust because I’m obsessed with flour used in pizza dough. I’m not a big fan of all-white flour crusts. They use exceptionally high quality flours in a slow fermentation process and you can taste it! After our conversation it was clear that attention to quality is the drive behind this pizzeria, more of a mission than a business. I ordered the seasonal pumpkin pizza with fresh sausage and the delicious fiordilatte mozzarella. It was divine. My husband ordered the Vicenza which he also loved. We took a Margherita home for our girls and they devoured it. The entire staff was very friendly, the atmosphere was cozy and sophisticated and fun, but with a touch of nostalgic charm. We’ll be back!

Sicily Pizzeria was fantastic! The staff were incredibly kind, and the Margherita pizza was the best I’ve had in Sicily—perfectly crispy, flavorful, and authentic. A must-visit for any pizza lover! Highly recommend!

Sicily #15, Ortigia #4, Italian #7, Pizza #2: excellent pizza and wine here. Had such better food and was a much better experience than the pizza we had in Catania. We ordered: the rosso della casa in bottiglia €20, An.ge.la €14 (bufala, salame picante, peperoncino), Immacolata €8,5 (melanzane, ricotta), Mimì €12 (pizza fritta, pecorino, acciughe). I loved everything we ordered but the An.ge.la may have been my favorite. Strongly reccommend ordering at least one pizza fritta. Vibe was solid, service was solid, and everything was pleasant. I guess my only edit would be if they could be open for lunch. Would happily return for more pizza and wine :)

Really good pizza and the staff is amazing. To be honest we were not expecting this place or pizza to be so delicious as this is the first restaurant of the Main Street. Highly recommended going and trying, also the we really liked the combinations of toppings on each pizza on the menu.

Absolutely stellar place! Visited it twice with my sister during our stay in Siracusa and fell in love with it! Amazing staff - very friendly and takes great care of the guests. Pizza was delicious and it definitely was the best food we had during our trip. The atmosphere was to die for and I seriously recommend it to anyone looking for a place to have a flavorful dinner.

Creative pizzas with a slightly crisp but springy dough, and a perfect dough-to-sauce ratio. We were grateful for the baby seat and the kind attention to our daughter (crayons and smiles).

We have been traveling through Sicily and still think of that place and this very delicious pizza! The service and staff was very kind and nice, we will definitely recommend the food and place to our friends and everyone who wants to have good pizza! 😍🫶🏽

Everything was great. The pizza was the best I've had in years. Super tasty ingredients and a fluffy dough. Service was friendly and had good recommendations for us. Beer from the tap was great as well. Not cheap, but you will get some really extraordinary pizza creations here. Highly recommended!

Amazing pizza and calzones. You can taste the freshness of ingredients. Wonderful and attentive service too even though they were busy.

At Sicily Pizzeria, the pizza was light and delicious, and the wine selection was good, too. The location was perfect, just around the corner from the main piazza. The servers were very attentive, and the owner, Dariana, greeted us and was so generous with her time, even though the restaurant was full. Thank you again, Dariana! We definitely recommend this pizzeria.

The manager of our Airbnb said this was his favorite pizzeria in Siracusa and it's in a very central location in Ortigia where we were staying, so our party of six went for dinner. We had several appetizers, six pizzas, a couple of cocktails, and wine. The appetizers seemed like they'd gone from an industrial freezer to a deep fryer, but the pizzas were delicious and very fresh. I loved my red orange cocktail, too. My husband's cocktail had very little flavor. The service was good, not overly friendly but not rude. Prices are moderate.

With so many delicious dining options in Siracusa it's hard to make a bad choice but Sicily is an easy go-to for delicious pizza, great service, and a nice experience overall.

We arrived and got a table fairly easily as the place was half empty around 9:00, we were waiting for the rest of our party to join us, as we sat down we were continously reminded by different waiters that we had to leave as our friends had not arrived with us... Made no sense as the three of us had already ordered food. As for the menu it was quite limited for a place that claimed to specialise in pizza. If you weren't willing to spend €15 for their luxury pizzas you had to content yourself with a simple Margherita or Diavola ( a Margherita with spicy salami) for €10. Being Italian myself I have had many pizzas and I must say that never have I had a pizzas made with such lousy dough, undercooked, too salty and toppings weren't anything you couldn't buy at a supermarket. Would not recommend...