Adrienne M.
Yelp
I kinda sit here wanting to give Soho Wines & Spirits 3.5 stars. But because I believe in the benefit-of-the-doubt and I'm a glass-half-full kinda person, I'm settling on 4.
The reasons I like Soho Wines & Spirits:
-lovely, lovely atmosphere in which to browse and meander over your next bottle o'sumthin. Very relaxed, lots of space, no one bothering you.
-very decent prices of wines, in general. I saw at least 5 bottles of $5 wines on my last visit. Not that I would be drinking these alone with a slice of parmiggiano, but heck, I'll pour it in my pasta sauce.
-an extensive selection of spirits, including my sometimes hard-to-find favorite rums (Mount Gay and Pampero Aniversario), several gin selections (though no Tanqueray Ten, which is a shame), and apertifs.
Things I'm indifferent about:
-helpful service. While I had my questions answered (re: Argentinian wines and the new limey-style Tanqueray), I would not say the service was friendly. Perhaps this is because I'm not as regular as some of their other clientele; I overheard several conversations with customers that implied a long-ish relationship, and staff was friendly to these people. Not that I'm expecting to be treated like you've known me for 10 years, but smiling and making eye contact would be a start, rather than a general gesture in the direction of the wine I'm looking for.
Things I don't like:
-most of the world's wines are grossly under-represented here. This is massive issue for me, someone who likes to drink representations beyond the USA and France. I mean, don't get me wrong -- California and Cote du Rhones have supplied the world with some beautiful wines. But when I walk into a wine shop -- especially one this size -- I expect some VARIETY. Go elsewhere if you like wines from Australia, New Zealand, Argentina, Chile (yes! Chile!), or South Africa. Seriously, including no more than 4 wines from each of these countries is a BIG mistake, IMO, as there are some beautiful wines from these places.
So, clearly, Soho Wines & Spirits is not about turning your average Manhattanite into a wine connoisseur. Rather, they're about providing "staples" (being, in this case, mostly French, Californian, and substantial Italian wines).
For wine variety *and* friendly service, go to Spring Street Wine & Liquor. For some wine variety, no helpful service, and an NYU discount, go to Thompson Wine & Liquor. But if you're looking for standard table wine and a bottle of tequila, and want to take your time being left alone browsing, head to Soho Wines & Spirits. But remember that if you give away a smile, don't expect one back.