Emily O.
Yelp
So here is the deal with the St. Charles Guest House:
Yes, the bed is way too soft and the whole place smells a little like natural gas due to the very old built-in-wall heaters many of the bathrooms are equipped with*....okay so the pool is not heated and there's no central air, just pleasantly humming window units (which guests are kindly asked not to use while not in the room).
*CAUTION: these are NOT self-lighting so don't just go cranking them on as it will do nothing but fill the room with natural gas (can you tell we found out the hard way?)!!!
All that said, I have now stayed here twice and at the end of each stay I find myself thinking, "there's something about this place."
Both times I have stayed here it has been clean, no cobwebs and clearly given a thorough once over, albeit over often cracked paint and splintered wood. :) I am not doubting the previous reviewers experience with roaches, but I did not personally encounter any here on either visit. You will find your room will be pleasantly tidied daily and you'll receive fresh towels too, which is more than I can say for a couple of chain hotels I've had the fine pleasure of inhabiting for those lovely work trips.
The first time we stayed here it was with a fairly large group of friends (6-8 people) and we had an absolute blast. Yeah, we were all in our twenties/thirties and it was pre-Katrina so we were pretty "footloose and fancy free" to say the least.
The second time was just this month; needless to say, my husband and I are in a totally different time of life now. My older step-son is at Tulane so we were down for "Parents' Weekend" and decided to stay in our old haunt for kicks.
When we first arrived, not having remembered the somewhat shabby appearance of the place, I think we were both a little disappointed.
However, over the course of the weekend, we began to remember what we'd loved about it so much. It's old and shabby for sure but the owner (Dennis) who I concur, is somewhat "spacey," is such a loveable guy. You will truly feel as though you are staying in his very own home. It got to the point that I actually did not even have to tell him my name when I called. He would just say, "is this Emily?" or "Hi, Emily," and he was full of helpful suggestions and ideas.
Not only that, due to our flights being bumped, he actually allowed us to completely change the dates of our trip (pre-booked and pre-paid) with NO notice. Kind of hard to explain but having been bumped from our plane, we arrived a day late and were initially issued a credit for the night we missed, which we were happy with. Then upon departure, we were bumped from our flight again. Even though we had already checked out, I called and Dennis from the airport and he just said, "well c'mon back!" He not only allowed us to return, he let us use our "credit" from the first night and we walked right back into our room as though we had never left. I don't know of any chain hotel that would have allowed such a thing.
Now, you may argue that many hotels would also not require prepayment to secure booking (as the St. Charles does) but they would probably also not let you just come back after having checked out and waltz right on back into your room (which had been re-tidied despite the absence of the housekeeper, btw).
Plus, being on Pyrtania, the St. Charles is basically a block or two from the streetcar line of the same name. Situated in the lower Garden District, you can be in either to Uptown or the Quarter within a matter of about 15 minutes. We had no trouble getting a car and it was just as easy to get to Tulane as it was to Bourbon street. Not to mention the hotel is 1 block from the Avenue Pub, a personal favorite of ours (I'll save that for another review but try the Bloody Mary). The shops on Magazine are also close by and I had a scavengerific time exploring the boutiques and their wares. So despite our initial rush judgement, it ended up being a win-win.
We are undecided about staying there next time just because at this point in our lives, we want something a little more luxurious but if you want something that is centrally located, clean and where you will be treated like family, the St. Charles Guest House is the place for you.