Nigel P.
Yelp
One of the best sit-down options in Guthrie. Quintessentially decent.
If you stick to what they think they'll do well, you'll have a good time with managed expectations.
Their burgers, steaks, and appetizers are good, and comparable to other accepted steakhouses. The smoking of the burgers is a nice touch.
My only problem with the restaurant is perhaps more of a culture issue in the area. I was trying to eat relatively healthy so I attempted to do a "steak and eggs" w grilled veg instead of the ultra-fried side dishes. Both of these "substitutions" are on their menu (fried "runny" egg is an option for the burgers, and grilled onions and mushrooms are a side). They were visibly confused and even asked a manager and said nobody had ever ordered these before. In OKC, this would be a super common substitution, but Guthrie be wilin'. They attempted to be accommodating, but I was told that the "chef" would "attempt" the fried egg, but it wouldn't be "runny." Bro a fried egg is like the first thing most cooks learn.
Anyway, besides that the only problem is the wait can be atrocious at times, which makes sense since it is one of the only decent options in the city.
All in all, I like the place and will be back, especially if I'm not trying to eat healthy.