Dean C.
Yelp
3/20/21
Thank you to our friends Emma and Eric for inviting us! In regards to flavor and quality, this was my best wine tasting of red wines, ever. Immensely pleasurable.
I believe (correct me if I'm wrong please) that this is The Winery that put America on the world map of wine. Yes, This one. It all began with their 1st place entry in the Judgement of Paris, even being honored with a 2006 Congressional Resolution honoring the significance! Hell, even a bottle of the winning S.L.V. Cabernet Sauvignon was placed in the Smithsonian in 1996!
Also note: they will make sure you know the above. Over and over. And again. But every time the staff tries to tell you just go ahead and say, hey, I already read that on Yelp but thank you very much. Cool. Now let's talk that extraordinary wine!...
1. Estate Collection Tasting Flight $50: Since we were guests, the tasting was free. A step above others, before we sat down the table was already prepped with settings, and all the glasses poured for us! So, we had...
1a. 2017 Arcadia Vineyard Chardonnay $65: The sommelier (does that apply outside restaurants?--I dunno, but for the purposes of this review let's just call our host that) went into detail about the history of this place first, see "Also note" above, then went to even more detail about what went into this chardonnay, and their goal of supporting flavor with oak, but not calling attention to the oak like one would like to not notice salt, but still feel it. I think they've achieved what they aimed to do, but overall it wasn't as exciting as some chards that my gf loves most. 7/10
1b. 2017 FAY Cabernet Sauvignon $150: The tasting notes were spot on, noting, "aromas of ripe berries, figs, plums, candied cherries, strawberry preserves, and a touch of a jasmine perfume,... and cherry pie aftertaste." I will add to that, that this wine was a fruit bomb, event with a very slightly tartness reminiscent of citrus and probably any other fruit your mind might just conjure. I REALLY wanted to buy this but... 10/10
1c. 2017 S.L.V. Cabernet Sauvignon $195: ...but... well we ain't rich so I can't justify spending $350 on 2 bottles, so we got this one instead. Alas, it wasn't my favorite, but you know... the Smithsonian right?--I gotta get one for my cellar and pop it open in a decade or two. Same thing here--the notes were spot on saying, "dark chocolate, graphite, truffle, dried fig and a lovely touch of violet... with a dusty cocoa powder note." This certainly had a darker character than the FAY version, and personally I think even a less complex character. With much less fruit layered in I think this would be a more classically "good" cab, bold and all, but I did enjoy the FAY one better. 9/10
1d. 2017 CASK 23 Cabernet Sauvignon $305: Well, I don't got an AP on my wrist (yet), so I guess I just don't got a rich enough taste yet... but our table unanimously rated this wine the worst on the table. I don't remember how the sommelier justified the $$$ price tag, but I don't think it reflects the lack of complexity in flavor, or the relatively bad, bitter and short finish. Though I'm sure their notes are spot on again ("a rich berry medley with silky layered aromas of dates, cocoa spice, cassis, black olive, and pomegranate") you have to pay far more attention to find the subdued character. Anyway, an easy pass. 5/10
Lastly, which was actually firstly, when we got here we actually stood in the greeting room for at least 15min and not a single person helped us while we stood there. We did see a dozen staff walk through the room, but no one said hi. Anyway, whateverz.
5/5
#napa #napavallery #winery #winetasting #cabernetsauvignon