Alan B.
Yelp
Our party of four wanted to dine alfresco in this general area and selected Stone's Public House based on the photos of their nice outside patio and the many positive Yelp reviews. Their comfort food menu also looked inviting, so we descended upon this restaurant, anticipating some very good food.
I was seated at a high-top table, about 10 minutes early. While awaiting my other colleagues, I sat unattended for those 10 minutes, and an additional 5 minutes after my first colleague arrived. Our waitress finally arrived, close to 20 minutes after I was seated, and took our drink orders. She was very nice, and seemed very new, as she could provide little guidance on what was offered from the bar.
To say that this restaurant is located near the train tracks is an understatement, as the Commuter Rail is so close to the restaurant and the patio, you can almost feel the breeze as the train passes, blaring it's horn every 20 minutes while we were dining. That said, the patio is a private, attractive brick venue, and aside from the train and Main Street road noise, a very nice spot.
We ordered 3 appetizers to share:
* Corned Beef & Cabbage Egg Rolls - Outstanding, best dish of the evening
* Beef Chili With Cornbread - Tasty with delicious cornbread
* Crispy Fried Calamari - Disappointing, arrived cool and not crispy
For our dinners we ordered:
* Lamb Shepherd's Pie (Carrots/Parsnips/Tomatoes/Mashed Potatoes)
* BBQ Pulled Pork (Housemade bbq sauce / Coleslaw/ Toasted Brioche Roll)
* Fish & Chips ( Extra Chunky Tartar Sauce/Housemade Chutney Ketchup/Pickled Onion)
The presentation was nicely done for all our dinners. The lamb pie was fairly good and the lamb was very tender. The mash potatoes are placed on top of the gravy, and become potato soup as you consume the dish. I think they could come up with a better plating alternative. Most of my mashed potatoes remained uneaten.
My colleague was underwhelmed with his Fish & Chips. He has dined here several times before, but for breakfast/brunch. He said his dish was just OK, though he liked the curry sauce which accompanies this dish.
The BBQ sandwich comes on a large roll. The diner who had this dish removed the top roll and consumed this as an open face sandwich. He said it was good, but left quite a bit of it unconsumed.
Out of the six dishes selected, we really liked two (Egg Roll and Chili). We would order those any time. I don't think we'd order any of the others, though we would certainly give this place another visit. The service was painfully slow, with people, leaving their tables to check on the status of their orders or the whereabouts of their checks. Many restaurants are having difficulty with staffing, so I'm hopeful this will improve over time. Overall, a three star dining experience.