Sundae Times Ice Cream Shop

Courteous staff great ice-cream. One of the best milkshakes I've ever had. They're pricing is excellent, especially for the shore.. highly recommend

Great place to get some perfect ice cream in a wide variety of flavors. The staff was super friendly with great attitudes and beautiful 😍 smiles 😊. Definitely stopping here again.

Times have been tough. I recently divorced (my idea not his) and wanted some time for myself. I always heard what a cute little town Spring Lake, New Jersey is. Well... They weren't lying. I was strolling around the pond when I stumbled upon what looked like an old newspaper building, but people were walking out with ice cream! As I entered I was greeted by the nicest staff. Sundae times was able to fill up the empty spot in my divorced heart with their delicious brownie sundae. It's another cash only ice cream place, but definitely worth it! NEWS FLASH! Sundae Times is a hit!

We love going here for ice cream. My sons loved it. They have great options and it’s so close to the boardwalk! Staff super nice and friendly.

Had our cake with their ice cream great combination. Together with good friends after a nice board walk walk.

Awesome little ice cream store in Spring Lake. Definitely grab a cup and walk one block to enjoy it at the beach / pavillion. Lines can sometimes be long, but move quickly. The smell of the freshly made waffle cones hits you as soon as you walk in. Enjoy! CASH ONLY!

We went in around 8PM. It was still packed. There were indoor and outdoor seatings available. The decorations inside looked fun and welcoming. The choices you can make are just mesmerizing. We were all very happy with what we got.

Friendly staff and great ice cream. Everyone in my family enjoyed theirs, especially me. 10/10

A charming ice cream shop that really captures the classic Jersey Shore vibe. It's got that laid-back, beach-town charm, and it's always fun to see people biking over for a sweet treat. They offer a great variety of flavors, and the ice cream is fresh, creamy, and delicious. Plenty of toppings to choose from to make your cone or sundae just the way you like it. Just a heads-up -- it's cash only, but there's an ATM conveniently located on the side if you forget. Definitely worth the stop if you're in the area and craving something cold and sweet!

My new favorite parlor (sorry Hoffman fan club). More convenient and low key area, ample flavor options, and friendly service. Perfectly textured ice cream. The waffle sundae is magnificent! Be sure to grab a loyalty stamp card.

Cute ice cream shop within a block of the beach. Inside there are seats as well as a few outside. There are plenty of flavors to choose from and they have options for sugar free customers.

It's hard to go wrong with ice cream, and indeed the ice cream we got was great! I got cherry vanilla and cappuccino crunch. I'm a huge fan of coffee ice cream and this one certainly didn't disappoint; i'm pretty sure there were actual coffee beans in the chocolate chips! It was very very busy and there are only 3 servers at a time, so be warned that you'll be waiting for a while.

Delicious ice cream, friendly service and reasonably priced. Good selection of flavors without being overwhelming and many options to make the sundae, cone or float of your dreams! Located in a small, stately building with a classic, old-fashioned vibe. Great place to get a cold treat on the way to or from the beach.

Great ice cream in a historic building dating back to the 1900s. This unique spot is nestled into a neighborhood. Indoor and outdoor seating and friendly staff!

The ice cream here is delicious - I appreciated that the pistachio and coconut ice cream had strong authentic flavors, sprinkled throughout with actual pistachio nuts and coconut. Knocking off a star because I thought the waffle cone didn't have the crisp I hoped for. It seemed a little underbaked, and the browning was uneven from one side of the cone to the other. Service was friendly and prompt. Cash only! There's are a few benches out front where you can enjoy your ice cream. I loved that the shop is in a historic building! And that it is only a block away from the beach!

I finally stopped in and got soft serve vanilla ice cream with colored sprinkles. My mom got chocolate soft serve with cookie crumbs. Both were delicious. I'll be back for more.

Yummy ice cream! They make their own waffle cones that are light, crispy and tasty. Enough choices and many toppings to chose from. Enjoy today

First off, CASH ONLY! Also, yum! Tried 2 scoops in a wafer cone in the raspberry sorbet flavor, absolutely delicious! My ice cream was $4.50. Right next to the beach! During Covid, they take orders at the window. A few benches to sit on. Would come back again!

The best ice cream spot in Spring Lake! I have been going here since I could walk and I am never ever disappointed. They just recently redid the inside and it is so cute. There is an array of ice cream flavors to choose from as well as toppings, cones, etc...really anything your heart desires. My family and I have tried nearly everything on the menu and we are always excited to go back. The line is typically long but moves fast and is 100% worth it. Everyone who works there is always super sweet and accommodating to all the customers. Sundae Times is the sweetest spot and holds a special place in my heart

Just popped in yesterday for some ice cream for the way home from a morning at the beach. We've been going for years but the pandemic allowed the owners to do an overhaul and the place has been cleaned, curtains added, and even the quality of ice cream seemed to go up a few notches. I highly recommend. Four small sized cups for a family of four came to $19 and because the server was so gracious and friendly and generous in s oops he earned his tip! Bathrooms clean as well. The building is super fun too.

A Spring Lake classic. Any flavor you need. Cute theme. As long as you have cash on hand, it's close to the beach and won't disappoint (as you can tell by the presence of a line most days).

Beautiful historical building built in 1906. Originally a pharmacy which sold soda pop and ice cream. Now you can enjoy over 40 flavors of premium ice cream and homemade desserts.

Love, love, love their ice cream! Some of the best in Monmouth County! We drive half an hour to get there, bypassing several other shops along the way. Big mistake on their part which is very irritating (in this day and age) is they seem to be closed for the winter but they failed to update their Facebook page to let people know! That's why they only get 3 stars from us!

The best ice cream in Nj! The same if not better taste and quality than Hoffman's, without the long line. Very quick and efficient service, and it is right near the boardwalk.

This place is a convenient stop for ice cream along the shore. I had the hot fudge sundae and the hot fudge was very good: warm, thick and chocolatey. The ice cream itself had a good, clean vanilla flavor even though it was a bit "melted" in texture (and the melting was not from the hot fudge). Sundaes are much better with intact ice cream. The place was well kept and neat. Tables were not sticky which is always a plus in an ice cream place. It can get crowded in here during busy hours, which is most of the summer. Prices are fairly reasonable and the amount you get is large. Overall, it's pretty good.

Old fashioned ice cream shop at the Jersey Shore. They have a nice selection of flavors and a menu that offers various ways to expand your waist line. Real hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, caramel.... I'm getting a craving for ice cream just thinking about Sundae Times! Yummie. Kid friendly but make sure you bring plenty of cash...One could set up an awesome sundae bar at home for the amount it will cost to satisfy the family here.

Once again I received top tier service from Michael Dora. He let me combine multiple ice cream flavors in my milkshake. I have never had this request filled at any other establishment. Michael Dora you dropped this king.

Delicious ice cream, perfectly thick milkshakes, a block from the beach, historic building, friendly and efficient service - what more can you ask for?! Sundae Times has been a tradition in our family for many years and will be for many more years to come!

You will not be disappointed with a trip to the Sundae Times! The ice cream is delicious, location near the beach is awesome and the employees are always quick and seem genuinely happy to help you. My family looks forward to treating ourselves here! Oh and be sure to try the "Black Bottom Pie," you won't regret it!!

My son Sparky and I were walking down the boardwalk but poor little Sparky got very hungry and we walked down to sundae times. Very yummy and they could accommodate to good ol Sparky's allergies of peanuts and tree nuts by getting vanilla soft serve in a bowl he let me have some very delectable. I got Superman ice cream brought back many memories it was amazing! 10/10 would recommend.

I don't know why someone found it necessary to convert a Spring Lake house into something that looks like a library and turn that into an ice cream shop. This ice cream is simply OK, not anything you couldn't find at a Dairy Queen or grocery store. And what kind of ice cream shop runs out of every flavor of soft serve? It's expensive, not satisfying, and it's not even cute inside! Lacking any kind of decor, this place is bare, barren, and sterile looking. Which is good... if it's a hospital. Unfortunately, it's an ice cream shop and it feels cold. And it's not because it's filled with ice cream.

Nice ice cream stop in Spring Lake. Butter pecan was pretty good. Can't tell ya more than that. Located in what looks like an old bank or hall of some sort. De worth stopping in for your ice cream fix when in Spring Lake

Our favorite ice cream spot! Can't go wrong with Milky Way Ice cream. Waffle cones are best we have ever had. Always a delight.

Stopped in Friday evening and very happy I did! Loved the environment as it is a block from the beach and a clean shop. Loved seeing all the locals ride their bikes here too. I got the cotton candy ice cream and my husband enjoyed the smores, cookies and cream mix. The workers were nice and the pricing was reasonable. Will definitely visit the shop again as I loved the fact it's a short walk from the beach. Definitely a must try if you enjoy other local shops like Hoffmanns.

Good icecream, bad service. Girl with short blonde hair was mean ! I wasn't ready to order but I was forced to. Icecream melts quickly too

The sundae times is one of my favorite ice cream shops. They have a great location to right next to the spring lake beach I recomend to come to the sundae times.

What better place to come for a sundae than the Sundae Times! They make great hot fudge sundaes, mostly because they use real hot fudge. I can't stand when I go to a place expecting hot fudge and the fudge just comes out of the bottle. The whip cream is just basic out of the can, not a huge fan. But that's just me. The ice cream is good, my boyfriend happens to be in love with their vanilla soft serve with hot fudge on top.

Great because of its location (i.e., near the beach). Because I have a house nearby, this is also a great meeting place. Don't order the Superman without trying it first (it's not for everyone).

Great ice cream, walking distance from the beach. Lita of indoor and outdoor seating. Can't go wrong here.

absolutely amazing ice cream, always good, almost always a line. I can't get anything else but the Hotel Black Bottom flavor, so ridiculously good. Highly recommend.

This place is awesome!!! I read about it here on yelp and mistakenly thought it was open until 11pm every night... But they actually close at 10pm on week nights and stay open until 11pm on the weekends. We rode our bikes over and got there at 10:10pm without realizing they were closed. The nice guy behind the counter waved for us to come in anyway. We apologized for getting there late and he responded with "It's ice cream. Everyone deserves ice cream!" What a nice guy, right?! But not only are the people here super nice, the ice cream was incredible! So many rich, delicious favors to choose from! Definitely recommend this cute shop to anyone!

I walked into sundae times wanting to satisfy an urge. I left disappointed and distressed that some hard earned money was spent on such poor ice cream. My milkshake had the same consistency as my morning glass. My mint choc. Chip was softer than any thing i have ever seen before. I regret giving them money for something as sub-par as their product. Sundae Times should be ashamed.

Awesome ice cream shop, friendly people, great flavors! It's a great place to stop after the beach or later in the evening.

Worst ice cream i've ever had! They should call it milk cream. The last thing anyone wants on a hot night is soft and melted ice cream. Awful. Will never go back.

Great tasting ice cream, cute shop. Good service. They only take cash but there is an ATM machine located inside for convenience.

Used to go here a lot but saw a huge roach crawl across the floor last time. And you know what they say about roaches. ..there's 100 more for every one you see. I also started noticing that their ice cream often had ice crystals in it. Now we go to Sundaes on Rt 35...better ice cream (they make their own!) and better service.

We love this place! When we walk the boardwalk we detour to have ice cream here. They have lots of creative flavors. Too bad they are only open Memorial day to Labor day.

The ice cream shop wasn't a home converted in to an ice cream shop. Its the old Hill's Pharmacy that was built at the turn of the century as their summer store. I was one of the lucky ones that got to restore the building to what you see today and it is a major historic landmark for the town, being one of the few buildings that survived the Monmouth Hotel Fire in 1900.

The ice cream is not amazing here. I had the chocolate banana and my friend had black raspberry. Both were meh. Also, the portions were way too large. When I order a small, I'm thinking I want just a little ice cream to satisfy my sweet tooth. I was pretty horrified to watch the server piling scoop after scoop into my cone. I cost close to $5 and I couldn't finish it. Not a small. The inside is awkward looking. It feels long and narrow and there was a door open that appeared to lead into someone's living room? When the line gets long it interferes with people coming in and out and people trying to get up from the seating and go outside. The plus side is that it's in a good location right by the Spring Lake boardwalk and it's nice sometimes to have ice cream while you're strolling along or after a day at the beach. Servers also seemed really nice and attentive. But there are lots of good ice cream places in the general area that don't offer way to much of a mediocre ice cream for too much money, so I probably won't go back in a hurry.