Supreme Pizza

We heard about Supreme Pizza from our community FB page. The comments left by other people were accurate, this place is great! I ordered the baked lasagna and for $16 it was huge! The dish itself was 8"x5"x1.5" deep, it was enough for 3-4 people. The sauce was a little different than what I am used to from Olive Garden. It was actually very good, I would definitely order the lasagna again. We ordered a side of buffalo wings, which were spot on. Nicely baked, not dripping with sauce like other places. The wings could be a meal by themselves. This place is excellent!!!!

Take out focused. Only a couple of tables. But always have a good game on. Food is top notch h. Staff is personable and just easy going. A must try!!

Got 2 pizzas, 1 cheese and 1 with meatball, sausage, mushroom and artichokes and a cesar salad. Pizza is pretty good and service is quick. The salad is large enough to feel 4 with pizza. It was romaine, croutons and shaved parm. The kicker is they gave us a tiny container of dressing that holds a tbl or 2 of dressing. We're not huge dressing users, but common on what did I pay 15 bucks for? We could have used a couple more with a salad that size.

I've done several larger lunch orders from them now, and the pizzas have always been ready on time, piping hot, and super fresh. It's been a huge hit at our office nearby and I've always been greeted with a smile when I walk in. I can tell the ingredients are very fresh and super high quality. Definitely the best pizza in town!

As a small business owner myself, I often entertain family and potential clients with gatherings at our Ocean Breeze Living Board and Care. I have used Supreme Pizza several times. Everyone LOVES it! Freshly made to order, with what I call their secret red sauce. I do not usually like red sauce, but I love theirs. Great family owned business, with excellent personal service.

The food is AMAZING. you actually get what you pay for. I recommend the wings to everyone. not the small tiny one bite, these actually have meat on the bones. The sandwiches have great flavor and bread is always fresh. Wife and I will split 12 wings and a sandwich with 2 drinks. $30 is not a bad meal. The staff and the owner are always friendly and courteous. Highly recommend Supreme pizza to everyone.

I usually don’t eat bread but their pizza was made with sourdough light, easy to digest and lots of toppings I loved it. Their Cesar salad was made according to traditional & authentic Italian way lots of Parmesan cheese shavings and a delicious dressing. I totally recommend Red Ladle to those who are vegans, they have vegan cheese. I also recommend Red Ladle to those who care about what they eat, everything is fresh and 95% is made from scratch in the restaurant.

It's some pretty great pizza I will say... Looks average but tasted amazing. Decently impressed. You get what you pay for here. If you want cheap, little Caesars isn't far away... But you gotta pay to play sometimes.

Went on Halloween and it was great! Loved the cheese pizza, the garlic chicken pizza, and the wings were great. We'll definitely be coming back.

I really enjoyed my stop here. I came for the Buffalo Fries. Loved em. Will return to try more. The employees are super nice and the place is absolutely spotless. I needed a place to do a little work (about 20 minutes worth) and my search lead me here. Lucky me!

My order was very bland. The 3-cheese pizza does not come with pizza sauce. That was a surprise. I should have read the small print. The penne with vodka sauce had very little flavor and didn't taste like vodka sauce. I feel like I wasted my $$.

The pizza was good. Not great. Good flavor we got pepperoni, pineapple & ham. Decent amount of sauce and cheese and toppings large pizza for $16.99 plus $2 for extra topping that is their daily deal except for weekends. It's small inside best for take out. Not much room. The thing that lacked the most was the customer service. Barely greeted with a "hi". Nothing else was said by the gentleman that helped us. We did more talking than him. 50/50 on going back. ‍

I cannot believe all the great reviews. I had high hopes and was sorely let down. I got a small thin crust sausage and pepperoni. The crust was like a store bought frozen mediocre pizza crust. And they had the audacity to charge extra for it! The toppings were OK but overcooked and I hardly tasted any sauce and they were skimpy on the cheese which I hate. And for what I got it was overpriced as hell! Maybe the regular crust is better but I don't think I'll bother coming back to try it. Major fail. Sorry.

Very good pizza. We got a two topping special for $16.99 and got pepperoni and sausage. The amount of sauce and cheese were plentiful and spread evenly. The crust was their regular crust and it was slightly on the dry/bland side, but this may be fine for most people. Phone ordering was easy and my pizza to go was ready in 15 minutes. There's no dine in so this is a to go place only.

Well we did not get a Pizza BUT we had a sandwich and salad. Barforama !!!! I can see now why the hole time we where in eating the phone never rang and NOBODE walked in . And of course the order wasn't even close to being right . A BIG NO

My wife and I ordered the meat lovers pizza and vodka sauce pasta. Pizza was good but the pasta tasted like nothing. Not sure if we'll be back but if we do we won't order pasta.

Pizza is so good and fresh. Calzones are extremely filling, split one. The cesar salad is a must if you like sharp flavors and a solid amount of thick parmesan shavings.

came here to pick up dinner for the family, 7/19/25. ordered pizza, salad, and wings and they were all 10/10!!! ranch is also good, great customer service . definitely recommend

We were going to try different pizza place but they didn't open till 4:00. Started looking on Yelp for another pizza place and read some great reviews on Supreme Pizza so we tried it. So glad we did! Got the meat lovers pizza and chicken and garlic pizza. Both were delicious but the chicken and garlic pizza was amazing. Three days later we again purchased the same pizzas but also wanted to try other items. We got lemon pepper chicken wings, fried zucchini, baked lasagna and onion rings. Everyone enjoyed the food. Next time we'll try other items. I'm sure they'll all be great. The gentleman who works there also delivers and is a very nice person. Prices are reasonable too.

First off pizza is good but........they advertised a large pizza with one topping for $14.99. We wanted 1/2 with one topping and the other 1/2 with another. They said this is 2 toppings for $15.99. So we said okay but did not understand this logic. So we figured $17 and change. Yes they charged us $18 and change and picked up the pizza. Doubt we come back.

You need to try this spot!!!! Service is friendly and fast! But most importantly the food is AMAZINGGGGG!!!! Great place for lunch and they also deliver.

We ordered a party all meat pizza and a pepperoni and received an amazing desert pizza!!! The pizza is soooo good!! Their prices are amazing and the delivery was fast! Everything was perfect! We have found our new family pizza placehighly recommended!!!

Wife was craving a calzone and this place did not disappoint. They had lots of options over here and no other place around has calzones like this. I love getting pizza at small shops like this cause the ingredients will always taste better than big chain pizza places. Support your local businesses everyone!

Fire pizza! Plenty of toppings, quality you can taste and great service, all at a great price! Winner! Winner!

Great first time visit, we tried it as an alternative to another place nearby (starts with V, ends in Tina's) and we were not disappointed. Great service, hot and delicious pizza.

New place in West GG that was average at best. Pizza was no better than anything else in the area. A bit lite on the toppings. Overall taste was just ok. Will not be going back.

Ordered a vegetarian pizza tonight and it was so delicious. Every time we order from here, it's very good; pizza as well as wings.

Pizza flavor and toppings were GREAT But the crust isn't homemade it's defiantly like a ready made. Such a bummer because it could be truly the best pizza around here

Absolutely delicious pizza and the wings are even better, big and flavorful! Friendly and welcoming staff. Thank you Supreme!

Small place mostly take out by they have a few tables. No fountain drinks (cans and bottles are available) however the pizza was amazing! So good and there was not one piece left. Grandkids happy! They have desert pizzas too.

This pizza shop is at a location that used to be a Pizza Hut. When I ordered pizza from there tonight, the pizza was identical to Pizza Hut pizza. The menu does have lots of stuff that is different from Pizza Hut. But the pizza is just Pizza Hut pizza under a different name. Maybe the owner got tired of paying the franchise fee or maybe they wanted more menu flexibility. But they didn't change the pizza recipe at all.

Pricy pizza but good pizza. We had Hawaiian pizza with sausage. Service was good and fast. Would recommend this place.

ordered a couple pizzas and some wings and a sandwich. walked in 15 minutes later order was ready. Guy behind counter was very friendly. everything was very good. pizza tasty wings had a great flavor. highly recommend

Received a promotional menu in the mail, and since it's a mile away from our house, thought we would try it out. Very glad we did! This is not really a sit down restaurant, more of a order and take home. That being said, the front counter people were extremely friendly, they definitely aim to please! we ordered the full pie 10 inch meat lovers calzone and I swear it was the best I have ever had, and I'm 68 years old! This was big enough for two people. The suggestions, the employees made were spot on! Service and wait time very fast! And the dough was extremely tasty, not that tomato sauce on a cracker stuff at the joint across the street! The meats were very flavorful, could've used more cheese, but that's my own personal view I'm a cheese person! we will certainly return! And for you seniors out there, it's tasty, not spicy! The prices are well within appropriate range, and we will return! HIGHLY RECOMMEND to all!

Bought pizzas & BBQ wings for a Halloween party. Everyone raved about how delicious everything was & dealing with the gentleman @ the cash register was spot one (nice guy). I signed up for their points program because we'll definitely be back. Thank you for being some delish eats to our neighborhood!

The definition of good pizza. Right amount of sauce & cheese. Crispy Pepperoni in every bite to the edge of the crust. Delicious fettuccine Alfredo with fresh tasting sauce. I got chicken added & they didn't skimp. My son was surprised by the large container. All for $40 including tip was plenty to feed two big eaters & me. I added broccoli to the fettuccine. Yum!

We've ordered from here several times, and I confess, it's been the same pizza every time. Meatball, sausage, red onion, mushroom, extra cheese and light sauce. Perfection for us! It's what we ordered the first time and it was perfection.

Excellent pizza (I got the large pizza with 1 topping special) and friendly service. Fsmily owned.

the pizza is awesome!! the employees are always smiling and will go help you with anything. I go here at least once a week. great ownership.

Twice we have ordered here and twice they've messed up my order. The first time I ordered a simple half cheese/ half sausage and peppers, they forgot the peppers. Tonight we ordered two pizzas for a specific pick up time. They made the pizzas right away and they sat in the warmer for half an hour. I want to support a local business but they can't get their orders straight. The flavor of the pizza was good once I warmed it in the oven.

Food is great but warning: the staff DO NOT WEAR MASKS. It is around the corner from my Mother's house so I do pick up. Never masks. Pretty scary. During this out of control Pandemic we made the decision not to order again from this restaurant until the virus is under control. We cannot take the risk of doing business, with ANY business that do not follow CDC guidelines.

Another really good local pizza joint! This place offers a really wide variety of different pizza potions as well as sandwiches , salads, and bread sticks . My only gripe was that my pizza was pretty late. Initially it was suppose to be delivered within 40 minutes and it took about an hour to show up. BUT the taste made up for it . The pizza wasn't cold and I could tell even thought it was late it was freshly made and wasn't sitting around

I was feeling kinda guilty cheating on my longtime pizza spot but after I had a couple bites of my Supreme pizza with jalapenos and the dee- lish mango habanero wings...time to move on from the same old! There's a new pizza spot in my life! The kids loved the 3 cheese pizza! Food was "sooo yum" - Mimi (daughter).

Decided to try this place out since I had been let down by nearby chain pizza places. It was amazing! I ordered an XL for four as the staff recommended and it was great. I thought I had ordered too much at first sight, but there were none left over not too long after arriving home The pizza had a generous amount of toppings and the dough is delicious as well.

Tried their calzones tonight for dinner. I got the meatball one and boy was it good. Best I've ever had. It was enormous and delicious. There really wasn't anything negative about it. I did have trouble trying to order online so I just called it in. They have free delivery if you live within 2 miles and order at least $25 worth. That's hard to find these days. I highly recommend this place and will become a regular customer.

Oh my gosh this place was so good! I got the calzone and salad and wow! They both were twice as big as most places and half the price! They did not skimp on cheese or meat. I am amazed. I can all the way from Cerritos bc my calzone place closed down. I found my new spot!

The other day I ordered two sandwiches. A pastrami and a ham and cheese. The pastrami sandwich was salty, but the ham and cheese was good. Both of my sandwiches were delivered hot and on time. Your sandwiches are sliced into two, five inch portions. I paid about $10.30 for each sandwich, which is a bit much. Keep in mind you're paying for convenience and delivery. If you order more than $30, you get free delivery. I would recommend this place. Just keep in mind their pastrami sandwiches are on the salty side.

This place just opened up right by my beauty school, and I love it! It's a small cozy spot, super convenient, and the food is always fresh! I've had the chicken tenders, wings, pizza and more and have loved it all. The service is always welcoming & friendly. 10/10 recommend.

Great pizza and super friendly delivery persons. We appreciate, all the hard work this restaurant did supporting first responders during the pandemic.

First time customer here, 10/12/19. Very friendly staff. They now have Grand Opening Specials for Large Garlic Pizza at $5 and Large Cheese Pizza at $5, etc. Great environment, convenient parking. Garlic pizza and Buffalo BBQ Wings are MUST TRY delicious item.

Supreme Pizza was great. I needed pizza delivered and I got a supreme Pizza that was great. (Smallish but great) the bbq chicken and bacon calzone was really really good! And the Caesar was good too. Everything was good. Prompt courteous phone call and delivery. I'd buy it again. Esp the calzone!!!

I'm always curious to try out new places, so the wife and I checked out Supreme Pizza Bar. My wife and I shared the Supreme and although was wary of Nutella on a pizza--It's Nutella, 'nuff said. The Supreme has tons of toppings and was surprisingly really good. The real surprise was the Nutella one, it just works! All in all, the price was reasonable, food was great, and the service was friendly.

New owners and the food isnt good anymore. Chicken is soooooooo dry, pizza isnt cooked all the way, and the pizza is cut into million pieces like they cut it at chucky cheese. We regularly order from here but wont be ordering from here anymore.

We have gotten pizza here quite a few times. It's always been really good. Ordered one today and it was not as good. We always order a supreme. The crust was thinner, sauce sweeter and toppings were different. Probably won't be going back.

The false advertise that you can any large 9.99 from 12 to 3 and then when u get there it's a different price The place isn't worth the 5 bucks for pepperoni

My kids and I were in the area and decided to Pull in and check this place out since we were starving. We just wanted something quick and simple. Surprisingly this joint was pretty darn good! Pizza came out fast and fresh. I judge pizza by the crust and this place past my test. Crust was the perfect balance between crispness and dough, not greasy, which I love!! Service friendly, cleanliness was good. I recommend this place if you're looking for a good mom and pop shop with good food! My kiddos loved it!!

Must try! The pizza here is amazing! So far we tried the supreme pizza, their wings and the bacon ranch calzone. By far the best pizza place we have eaten! Definitely our new favorite spot! They will see us regularly