Emily Nelson
Google
I'll preface this by saying that I'm not leaving this review in the hopes of getting anything in return, I just simply think that this property could really use this feedback, if they choose.
The Balfour is a lovely old hotel, like many in the area. Since it's old, you can expect smaller rooms with old charming fixtures and creaky floorboards. That's part of the experience and certainly not why I'm leaving a "negative" review.
Our experience was made bad by the lack of customer service surrounding two key instances.
1. The second day we were at the hotel, there was a notable sewer smell as we passed the second floor and upon arriving onto the third floor. It was so strong in the hallways that I suspected that there was a backup somewhere, which I mentioned to another guest who said she could hardly stand to be around it and had to step outside or she would be sick. I went down to the reception desk and asked the front desk clerk why the strong sewer smell had suddenly appeared. She simply replied, "I don't smell it!" and dismissed me. I sat in the lobby for a bit and noticed that she did go over to the hallway and then called over some staff and had a whispered conversation with them. A simple response of, "Let me look into that for you!" or "I'm sorry you're experiencing that, let me see what I can do." would have gone SO much further than pretending the problem didn't exist.
2. The first day we arrived, there was water out in the lobby with cups provided. This was very welcome after a long journey. That night, though, when we arrived home - there were no cups available. Knowing that we didn't have any water in our rooms (unless we wanted to spend $8 on the warm bottles in the room for us to purchase), we asked the woman behind the front desk if she could replenish the water cups. She said that there would be no more water provided for the night, as they were out of cups. The next day, the water was removed entirely. It remained gone for the entirety of our 3 day stay. Since the restaurant/bar was under construction and closed (though we were told it would be hen on the second day of our stay, which it was not), there was no other way for us to get a cup of water. The bathroom sinks were so old and I couldn't fit my water bottle under the spigot. We asked the front desk multiple times if we could have a cup of water, and were denied. Water is such a small thing that can drastically improve the quality of a guests' stay, but so does friendliness and accommodation from the front desk staff. We paid nearly $50/day in a resort fee, surely that could have covered a couple bottles of water to make up for their construction project.
I'd recommend staying elsewhere in this area. The other hotels are all equally charming and in a tremendous location, but I'm sure their staff are trained better and will hopefully improve the quality of your stay as a result.