Jonathan C.
Yelp
This hotel has the potential to be a great boutique hotel. It is located in a former home for Civil War widows built in a "Victorian industrial" brick style, with two turrets on the front facing the road. It tries to build on that history, but in a couple of ways, goes off on unexplainable stylistic tangent.
We went on a "Romantic Getaway" package and, while there were some really very good things about the place, there were a couple of things that ruined it for us. First the good.
The staff at the hotel was excellent and attentive. There were wonderful touches during our stay, with turn down service and cookies by the bedside when we arrived. We stayed in one of the turret rooms on the second floor with a balcony. The room was large, the bed very comfortable and we felt very relaxed. There was air conditioning, but because of the architectural structure, they were window units. (No big deal)
The restaurant was one of the best we have ever been to. The food was amazing and the kitchen staff clearly knew their business. While our meals came as part of the package, the prices on the menu were NOT expensive.
From a design standpoint, here are the tangents. The carpets (sort of a pea green) do not work with the setting of the building and atmosphere they are apparently trying to create. They are just an ugly color, plain and simple. The artwork in the foyer, lobby and restaurant are fine, but in the halls and room, they've placed faux 1930s/40s studio shots. It all just comes across as a sort of historically schizophrenic. Still everyone has their own tastes...
What was totally unacceptable (and what we didn't discover until morning light) was the large amount of mildew in the shower. My wife (distgusted) was able to clean it off herself without too much effort. In addition, on the door frame going out to the balcony, there was a dark brown, greasy dripping stain. The housekeeping staff clearly was not doing it's job. in addition, the ceiling in the bathroom was separating from apparently previous water damage.
We brought all of these things to the attention of the hotel staff at the front desk and, while she was courteous and took note of what we said, I think it would have been appropriate if they had at least made an offer to discount our stay. But nothing. (Except that they hope we come again and give them another chance).
We really wanted to like this hotel. But, to us, these are big time hygiene concerns. If they address these issues, then this can be a wonderful place to stay. But, while we may come back for the restaurant, we will not be coming for an overnight stay.