Derek L.
Yelp
I am actually going to call this the "Best Italian Restaurant Ever". Bold claim sure, but I had begun to hate Italian food, only because so many do it so poorly. Coming back from a business trip to Detroit, I stopped in with a business associate. We were looking for a meal before the drive back to the GTA, and I noticed that Kris U had reviewed Cook's. If you can't trust the Yelp Area Manager...
It was about 20 minutes before the opening time of 5PM, but Lino the owner welcomed and entertained us with gracious conversation until the kitchen was ready.
He spent a lot of time throughout the meal explaining why his Black Angus Beef is not available at many Eastern Canadian restaurants, and why his lamb is authentic spring lamb and why it is important. We felt like we were guests in his home.
But about the food: we started with the New Zealand Green Mussels in Maranara that was impossibly fresh. Actually, everything is so impossibly fresh, I was tasting balances in ingredients I have not experienced at 3 times the price in Toronto or Chicago or Vegas. The dozen mussels for $8 were perfect.
Lino explained that the dishes shown on the menu don't indicate any sides, but in the true Italian tradition, fresh garlic bread, salad and pasta were included and abundant. We used two orders of garlic bread to sop up every drop of the marinara on the mussels.
The salad was a basic whole leaf romaine with a few FRESH croutons (not the stone pellets other joints serve) and a dressing that is incredible. The salad bowls arrived chilled to freezing, further indicating the attention to detail and passion Lino has for his food.
I had the Angus Scallopini Picatta at a mere $18, with 3 large butterlike portions of perfectly cooked beef, and about a pound of fresh chopped mushrooms in the perfect sauce. Clearly this is not over seasoned, or using anything other than the minimum amount of fresh seasonings. I hoovered down every morsel, then dumped my side of al dente spaghetti in tomato sauce onto the plate so I could soak up every last bit of gravy.
My associate ordered the Lamb Chops, 5 healthy sized chops on a steel skewer. I sampled a piece and was amazed that I could cut it with a fork I have never had lamb this tender-anywhere-ever!
In preparation for the drive back to the GTA, I ordered a cappuccino to build up a bit of caffeine. I was shocked to find out that the fresh pressed cappuccino is 75 CENTS, and a pot of normal fresh brewed coffee is 50 CENTS!!!! Pricewise, Cook's is embarrassingly inexpensive. I have spent up to $50 for a veal scallopini in other places and it was not half as good as Cook's. I would have paid triple what the final bill came to and felt I had received good value.
I have to editorialize: I read the reviews of the few that gave less than 3 stars, and clearly recognize that you experienced an anomaly. Get over it, because in the greater scheme of things, you are simply painting over a masterpiece with a dirty brush. Annoyed that they are only open a strict 5 hours per night? If you don't know that a true Italian meal takes nearly two hours, go back to powdered and frozen joints that slam you through in 45 minutes, but don't bother to complain about Cooks. Sorry, but you simply don't get it. Rant over...
As for me, I will not be likely to ever eat an another Italian restaurant this side of Naples ever again, except for Cook's. They spoiled me forever. Bad Italian is the worst, and Cook's makes everyone else look bad...Sorry, Giuseppe...