The Edgartown Inn

Staying at the Edgartown Inn feels like coming home. The staff are warm and professional, and do everything they can to make your stay enjoyable. While the old decor of the Inn was full of history and antiques, the new renovations are well-done and provide a peaceful and cozy update to this historic gem of an inn. The rooms are comfortable, the breakfast is delicious, and the warm chocolate chip cookies are not to be missed! We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and highly recommend this inn for visitors to Martha's Vineyard.

This was a wonderful place to stay as the rooms and staff were great! The location is very convenient to restaurants, shops and historic sites. The continental breakfast is quite hardy with fresh baked goods, yogurt, smoothies, parfaits, juice, coffee and selection of Smith Teas (my favorite from my home city). They also have homemade chocolate chip cookies throughout the day and if you time it right, warm right out of the oven.

Very nice hotel, centrally located in Edgartown. Nothing seemed to be more than a 5 minute walk away. Neusa and her team kept everything pristine! Rooms are a bit small, but well appointed and there's a lot of common space to relax in. We really appreciated the beach chairs and towels that were available. Would definitely return!

We had booked here as been wanted to visit the area for years and linked it in with a trip to Boston.|Nice drive to catch the ferry and a smooth crossing. Easy drive to the hotel and we arrived early which wasn’t a problem given the time of year but would guess it would have been in high season.|Checked in and shown to our room and treated to warm chocolate cookies what a start.|Asked for recommendations for places to eat and visit, shown on a detailed map where to eat and even places to visit further afield which we did as beautiful scenery around the island.|Rooms are very clean and superbly decorated and presented, it made a change to have a proper shower rather than where we had stayed previous along with some lovely bath products.|Simple breakfast but sufficient and some nice touches with different options to eat and teas to drink.|Overall a great place to stay and would recommend.||One gripe was the cost of parking given the price being paid for the room, and having just seen on trip advisor it’s being promoted as FREE PARKING which is not the case it’s $50 a night additional fees.

Our second stay at the Edgartown Inn and we were even impressed than the last. The property is in an excellent location which makes for easy walkability. The staff (Neusa) were wonderful and the breakfast will undoubtedly exceed your expectations. We did hear another guest complain about the room between rooms / floors - but I would imagine they’re not typical BnB customers. ||Thanks again for a wonderful stay.

I had a wonderful time at this property last week; four nights. I'm sharing just a few remarks to describe my experience...It was well-appointed and first-class. The breakfast spread exceeded my expectations. Though the space in the room was on the smaller side, the bed was super comfortable with cozy high-quality linens. The staff was amicable and accommodating - everyone was just so darn nice. I especially liked the location which made all the main attractions Chappy Ferry, and restaurants/shopping very walkable. The only downside (for me) is that it is very quiet in the evenings like NO one is sitting outside around the fire pit, I saw no one in the living room lobby, and no one on the front porch so our group felt a bit uncomfortable when we gathered in public areas for our after dinner chats and girlfriend talk time.

Conveniently located old house with modern rooms with plenty of space. The continental breakfast is amazing with fresh baked goods, smoothies, oats, granola, etc. Fresh baked cookies were available every afternoon.

The Edgartown Inn is now part of Mr. and Mrs. Smith brand owned by Hyatt which is how I booked my reservation. Staff is warm and helpful. Feels so safe that I never locked my door while walking around the premises. We had to put a cot in our room to accommodate a third person so it felt a bit tight. Only negative room comments are that although the bathroom is beautiful and spacious there was no place to put our personal toiletries. I don't understand why they have no shelving. Also, the walls were a bit thin. We were on the first floor and I could hear everything going on at the breakfast area. Breakfast was great. Wonderful options and excellent quality. Everything was fresh and prepared with care. The backyard area was fun to sit and drink wine by the firepit or have our breakfast in the morning. Location in Edgartown is unbeatable. Everything is steps away.

I can't say enough about the Edgartown Inn The most subtle elegance the most beautiful touches - you are surrounded in the most luxe appointments yet without any pretension. Neusa was the most efficient kind knowledgeable friendly host for us at the Inn. Looked forward to seeing her smiling face every morning while she prepared the beautiful breakfast spread on the island. It was créme de la creme from start to finish

It was a misery trying to speak to a human and then in order to speak to the local desk of this hotel I was told that she couldn't connect me unless I gave my name, fair, phone #,fair, but why my email? I just wanted to ask someone AT the location for some regional information.They use an outside booking source and frankly have absolutely NOTHING TO DO WITH Martha's Vineyard.Another outside company trying to look local without the person to person connection

Great place to stay for a few days. Every morning there is a lovely spread of ciabatta bread with a delicious topping which changed each morning, overnight oats, fresh cut up fruit and a muffin or breakfast bread, all very fresh. There is also coffee. In the afternoons a snack such as cookies, brownies or chocolate chip bread is offered. There is also a tap to choose still, fizzy or ambient water and in each room are glass bottles you can use if you don't have your own. Also available for guests are beach chairs and towels. There is a quaint seating area in a courtyard, with several tables, chairs, couches and a fire pit that is lit nightly. There are three rooms on the first floor, 4 or 5 on the second and at least one on the third. There is no elevator. Room 5 is a great spot, faces the street, which is quiet at night. There is a fridge and a safe and nice touches like a jewelry velvet drawer and bathrobes. The AC worked well, but it would be nice to have a ceiling fan. There is parking in the back. There are 3 or 4 first come first serve spots which are free. There are a dozen others (can get tight if all full), which can be reserved for $50 a night. After Labor Day the lot was pretty empty so there was not a need to pay the extra to get a spot. Room 5 overlooks the fire pit section and can get loud if folks are enjoying lively conversation. That room is also smaller than 5. Mariella, who I believe is the manager, is very pleasant and attentive and all the staff we encountered were friendly. Even when it rained, the porch in front was comfy to use. 4 rocking chairs on one side, and lots of couch seating on the other.

Visiting Martha's Vineyard this week & staying at the Edgartown Inn. Wonderful staff & the entire Inn is completely renovated & modernized. Repeat guests & highly recommend over any other place to stay on the Edgartown. Entire staff is amazing

This hotel is beautiful with a wonderful front porch and an excellent location in downtown Edgartown. The room is decorated and appointed well. Huge tiled shower and bathroom as well as a super comfy bed. Staff was super accommodating and very courteous as well as always wearing mask and keeping place looking clean and spotless. Served breakfast in boxes due to covid and all was delicious. Excellent outdoor and seating space out back. Looks like their adding on. Seems to be under new management under Lark hotels. Only gripe that kept it from being 5 star is that no one ever came to tidy up our room or bathroom or replace towels. For the price there should be housekeeping on site rather than the 2 or 3 younger seeming managers/front desk personnel running the show.

We had such a lovely stay at the Edgartown Inn. They are very accommodating, it's in a great location, and very clean! Highly recommend.

The hotel is OK but overpriced. Our room was extremely small and without privacy as it looked into other windows. Service is poor, we came back one night and the room was not made up. There was a ceiling fan in the bathroom that could not be stopped and was noisy all night long. Breakfast was included but is not good. We paid more than $ 600 a night for a motel kind of room and amateur service. The location is very convenient but there are much better options in the area.

We stayed at the Edgartown Inn about two years ago. My husband and I were graduate students at the time so we didn't have a lot of money to spend on hotels. Edgartown seemed to be the most affordable place in town and close to everything in Edgartown. It is a walk to ocean and all the stores and restaurants. It's a quiet and beautiful place to stay in. The rooms are simple, no TV in our room which was fine since we spent most of our time walking around town and enjoying MV. We also had breakfast a couple of times while we were there, the breakfast was good, if I remember correctly. Good coffee too! But the best part [agreeing with Daniel L. is the coffeecake they give! YUMM]. My only complaint about the room is that we were in the downstairs bedroom, right across from the check-in desk. The walls seemed to be paper-thin and I felt like there wasn't much privacy since we were basically at the entrance of the Inn. And that the bed was pretty hard and uncomfortable. The decor, throws you back into the 50's and while it isn't my style, it gives a very homey feeling to the whole place. The bathroom and room were very clean. The staff was very nice and accommodating.

I was lucky to stay at the Edgartown Inn a few times. The Inn is locationed in downtown Edgartown and is quiet, nice and very clean. The owners are very accommodating and will try to place you in a great room even if you happen to show up without reservations. I was able to get a great room on my last visit that had a small balcony and a great view of downtown. I uploaded a picture from the balcony. FYI. If you are a big TV watcher be aware that some rooms do not have TV's since it is a Inn. Check with then to be sure but do not let that spot you from staying here. You will like the Edgartown Inn.

We had an excellent stay here this past weekend. It is completely renovated and beautifully decorated. The most comfortable mattresses and everything was super clean! They told us upfront we'd have to request cleaning staff to come in, which we were totally fine with since everyone is being cautious with Covid. Breakfast was delicious, it changed every day and they quickly brought it to our room with just a text. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. Also great location, walking distance to everything. One downside was no mini fridges in the room - which was our fault for not checking the amenities list - but we had brought food, which thankfully they allowed us to store in a fridge downstairs. Overall, excellent stay and would for sure come back.

Good breakfast spot & it has to be since that's the only meal they serve. They don't have a large selection, but everything they make is tasty. I've had better pancakes at other spots, but these did the job quite nicely. I got the cinnamon apple pancakes and the apples were cut small so they blended into the pancake but i think that they could have used a heavier hand on the cinnamon. The poached eggs were some of the best I'd ever had anywhere with no vinegary taste to them and they were cooked perfectly so that the yolk made a nice sauce to scoop up with the bread. The best part of their breakfast, though, is that everyone gets a freshly-baked warm piece of coffeecake. This little appeteaser is accompanied by your choice of juice and coffee or tea and is included with every breakfast. The decor is out of the 50's with old dutch decorations and a radio that plays songs made well before my time. The staff is great and they sing along to the radio, further cementing the timewarp feel you get when you walk into this place. I didn't stay here, so I can't comment on how good the inn is, but breakfast is good. Come here for a good complete breakfast if you're hungry and you'll leave satisfied.

The best place I have ever stayed! They bake brownies for you on the 4th of July and bring them out to you along with iced tea while you watch the 4th of July parade from the front porch. The front porch there is the best porch sitting place I have ever seen. The staff is so friendly and treats you like their own. Breakfast is great! Location is awesome! I can't say enough good things about the Edgartown Inn! It is a must when you visit Martha's Vineyard!

We recently stayed here for a wedding. The Inn is beautiful and quaintly decorated. It was also close to everything around town. We loved being able to walk to everything, including the wedding location. The staff was absolutely delightful and accommodating. The building itself is an older structure so the walls are not completely soundproof, but that is found in any historic hotel or inn. I would recommend this lovely inn to anyone looking for somewhere to stay in Edgartown that is close to almost everything, has a great history behind it, and has a friendly and beautiful environment.

My husband and I had a wonderful experience at the Edgartown Inn. The location was perfect -- out of the way enough to be peaceful, but close enough to town to walk to the shops and restaurants. We stayed in the smallest room in the inn and it was perfect. Private bath, comfy bed and no TV, so we could truly unplug. Sandi, the innkeeper could not have been lovelier, and the same can be said about Claire, her assistant. Everything was clean and homey. The continental breakfast was perfect, with warm homemade coffee cake and our choice of freshly made bread for toasting. If you have the opportunity to try the Cheese Toast, I highly recommend it. If you are looking for a wonderful experience, this is the place to stay. We will 100% be back.