Joe P.
Yelp
I had lunch w/ a client in the Four Seasons before heading to JFK. I would have liked to have gone elsewhere, but we wrapped up a larger group mtg, and I didn't want to bring my luggage w/ me. The Garden offers all day dining as well as tea & coffee between meals.
I ordered the octopus ($28), while my client ordered the nicoise salad ($44). He also ordered an iced tea ($12). We both received complimentary, warm onion focaccia bread while we waited.
First of all, the bread was excellent. It was warm and contained a lot of onions. I would have had more, but I didn't want to be a pig in front of my client: 5 Stars.
Secondarily, my octopus was very good. It was tender and not overcooked like Water Grill in SC Plaza. The only downside was the price: 4 Stars.
Likewise, my client enjoyed his salad. Although the portion looks small, there was a lot of high-end cannned tuna in the salad. The waiter informed us that an original nicoise uses high-end canned tuna, that in this case costs $52/can. American recipes call for grilled ahi, thus giving most of us an Americanized version. My client actually became full on the salad. Again the only downside was the really high price: 4 Stars.
Regarding the ambiance, its your basic casual dining restaurant in a hotel: 3 Stars. However, what sets the Garden apart is the overall "Four Seasons" excellent service. For example, the hostess checked my luggage so we could have more room. In addition, Milton our waiter was super nice & attentive. We struck up a convo about Hawai'i, and how much he enjoys Maui. Lastly, the Mgr was very polite, and allowed me to pass as we met in an aisle: Imagine that, giving a client the right of way!: 5 Stars.
Yes, the Garden is pricey. Nonetheless, I would have no qualms about having a power coffee mtg as others were, or having a power lunch if I didn't want to cart my luggage around Manhattan. The excellent service more than makes up for the high prices.