The Great Old House

Third time trying to eat at this restaurant and we succeeded First time it was closed when it was supposed to be open, yesterday we called and they said they are open and when we got here we were told that they are not serving any food because they don't have any waiters...so finally we made it. The waiter seems to be doing most of the work whilst the waitress seems to sit around a lot and rolls her eyes when asked by her colleague to do something. Many of the items on the menu were missing. We had the fish cakes to start and goat curry for main, both very good. The card machine was out of order apparently, so we had to pay cash. Very interesting experience.

I ordered the shrimp pasta and it was delicious. The vegetables were crisp yet perfectly cooked, the portion of shrimp was generous and full of flavor, and the subtle touch of cheese added just the right creaminess. It was an excellent recommendation from the waiter, who was very attentive and polite. As a European, I’m not used to surcharges and prices not including taxes, but in this case it was worth the price.

Great place. Name of restaurant did not match but we found it. Food choices were varied but a few of the menu items were unavailable. Everything was fantastic. I would highly recommend and would most definitely return. The staff were super friendly and provided excellent service.

The Great Old House (formerly Old Stone Grill) was warm, welcoming, and delicious. When other places couldn’t seat us, they kindly accommodated us. We sat outside on the balcony, and the setting was perfect. I had grilled chicken with jerk sauce, rice, and salad—so flavorful. My friend’s BBQ ribs were tender and delicious. Great food and great service.

Don't go here. Tons of reviews say they will tell you they "don't have that" from the menu. That's true. They didn't have at least 5 things and it's a SLIM menu to begin with. I had to disagree with my bill and have it corrected 3 times. First- they charged me for sides that the waitress stated were part of the meal I picked (I asked to make sure before I ordered them because I didn't need any sides) Then- they told me that the bill was higher because the prices on the menu had increased. They told me AFTER I ordered AND ate the food. Then- they tried to charge me for alcohol in my fruit punch when there wasn't any. Being told the "prices are higher than the menu shows" after eating the food was absolutely UNEXPECTABLE. They corrected the bill, after I made it clear I was paying the printed menu price and only for food that I had ordered based on the menu. The food was mediocre and the service was less than mediocre, and I'm not picky with either of those items.

This place is by far one of the best restaurants I have eaten at on the island. You will not be disappointed. I mean service is great, the food exceptional. It is not a fast food restaurant so if you are looking for a quick meal, this is not the place for you. If you are looking for culinary experience--you have found a gem in this place. Friendly staff and that goes for the owner Steve as well. I ate here for the 1st time in March and knew that when I visited again I would return. Tonight I did with my mom and brother. We were not disappointed.

I’m not sure if I should be posting to the Old Stone Grill and Bar or The Great Old House (same place). The name has no effect —the food is lovely, the balcony gets the perfect breeze, and the service is helpful and friendly. Some folks note that they are often out of things on the menu. It’s an island and the food is fresh. You get what’s good, and it is. Be prepared for large portions. The mains come with two sides and that would be plenty for me. That said, the appetizers were also very good and plentiful. Love the fish cakes! Spicy fries are a treat too.

The service was awesome, our waiter mario was polite and made us feel at home. The food 😘wonderful. Def worth a 2nd visit .