Teena S.
Yelp
The overall 3.5 star rating for this hotel is incredibly generous. A more realistic rating is a 2 star.
First, good luck with finding the hotel on Google maps -- not the hotels fault, but we drove around for 15-20 minutes trying to locate the hotel given the Google maps issues (would be nice if hotel provided a heads up that this is an issue).
Second, the hotel weekend rate is $548/night + 15.5% of additional taxes and fees + $30 resort fee (which we are happy to pay for a good quality hotel), but -- given the age, low quality and how run down the hotel is -- $200-250/night would be more appropriate.
Third, upon our arrival, the door man, Mike, was incredible apathetic, dismissive and unwelcoming. He is clearly a "last resort" hire as he had an "it's not my job" attitude -- we felt he was truly inconvenienced when we showed up at the hotel. I've never been able to understand why people like him take jobs that are required to interact with the public when they are so disinterested or incapable of interacting positively with the public.
Fourth, upon entering the hotel, the first thing we immediately noticed was the age and low quality of the carpets, wall paper, and many other aspects that make it immediately clear that this hotel's best days are far behind it. The hotel may be historic, but it is just tired and old (and we've seen a lot of historic hotels that are incredible well-kept and modernized).
Fifth, as we walked up to the room, there was a big pile of trash sitting outside of our room (see picture). This appeared to be food-related trash left out from the residents next door which is understandable, but -- based on the look and smell, our guess was that this trash had been sitting out for quite awhile.
Sixth, once we entered the room, we quickly took note of the air conditioning in room is a "room unit" AC device (versus central air) that is very old and very, very loud (see picture). Add that to the abnormally loud noises throughout the night created by doors slamming and toilets flushing in other rooms, and it is next to impossible to get a good night of sleep at this hotel.
Seventh, the furniture is old and aging and -- as a result -- is in disrepair (see picture). We tried to keep a sense of humor by questioning if the chair in the picture was a relic from the days when the hotel first opened. :)
Eighth, we thought Arlene (front desk manager) was very pleasant and understanding when sharing the issues about Mike (front door manager) and some issues we dealt with regarding the delivery of our bags (i.e., our bags were never delivered to our room but -- instead -- were parked in a storage room where my husband had to go downstairs to retrieve after realizing they were not going to be delivered to our room) and the parking of our car (the valet "lost our keys" and couldn't find them after an extensive search but -- fortunately -- he later realized that our car had never been parked in the first place so it was still outside the hotel front door unlocked with the keys inside), but Stephanie (another front desk manager) was unresponsive (we are still awaiting a call back from her).
I normally post positive ratings and shy away from posting negative ratings, but this hotel is -- in a word -- AWFUL especially when you consider the extraordinary "gap" between the incredibly high price and the incredibly low quality and age of the hotel. We were really hoping for and expecting a far better experience (this was our first time visiting West Virginia). We were scheduled to stay for 3 nights and 4 days, but -- given the number and variety of issues that we experience shortly after arriving, we checked out and wound up staying at a better hotel in Beckley (are you ready for this? We wound up staying at a Courtyard by Marriott which was -- shockingly -- much better from a quality and price ratio perspective and amazing service).
I'm giving the hotel a 2 star (and I consider that a very generous rating). Net, don't stay here -- it's too expensive and the quality is just not on par with a hotel that charges this much.