Kaiwan C.
Yelp
I'll start out by saying that I have now stayed once at both The Lodge at Pebble Beach and the Inn at Spanish Bay. Both properties are owned by Pebble Beach Resorts but offer subtle differences in experience. While the Lodge feels more intimate with a small Check In area and no real lobby to speak of, the Inn resembles a more classic hotel experience with a sizeable lobby/lounge area, lots of patio space with fire pits and even a ballroom. Each resort has its place. Both are pricey but, imho, both properties are worth the splurge.
If I were to review the Inn on its own I would give it 4.5 stars (rounded to 5). The hotel itself is beautiful. The concierge staff was amazing with my family. The rest of the staff also exemplified great service. The rooms were well appointed, housekeeping did a great job, dining on property was good as well. My family stayed over New Years weekend and, while the weather was not very cooperative, I can still say we all had a great time, from experiencing the bagpiper at sunset to NYE dinner at Hay's Place, to visiting the Monterey Bay aquarium only 15 min away.
Now, if I were framing this review as the Lodge vs. the Inn, I think the Lodge edges the Inn out slightly. When it comes to view, I think the Lodge wins. It is sort of situated overlooking a cove and the 18th green and is much closer to the beach. While the views at The Inn are also lovely, I can't help but feel like I'm a little too far away from the water. Also on this subject, be aware that forest view may really just refer to a a view of a few trees, scenic view will give you a look at a sliver of ocean and the balconies of other rooms and anything below that you might be staring at a parking lot. Both resorts demonstrated great service but I feel like they really went above and beyond at The Lodge (separate review) while at The Inn we had to kind of persuade/negotiate things a bit more. The Inn, however, wins when it comes to proximity to Monterey and Carmel. This made eating or doing things off resort significantly easier. And it was more alive in general which was great when trying to entertain our daughter while it was too wet to go outside. I should also mention we did get a discounted rate at the Inn which was nice.
So overall, I'll be back im sure. And I would still recommend staying here. Next time I'll probably pick a different room and hopefully the weather will cooperate more. Or maybe I'll check out the Lodge. Honestly, you can't really lose either way.