Nicole D.
Yelp
PSA: Buckle in, this is a long review. My husband and I got married at the Ivy House two years ago (4.16.22). We stayed at the Iron Horse after, as well as a lot of our guests after doing a block with them. Although it was on the pricier end, we felt that the location and atmosphere was worth it. And it was, two years ago. Now, I would not recommend any aspect of this hotel other than the room itself.
My husband booked a room for our anniversary which fell on a Tuesday night. He requested the same room we stayed in when we got married & it was available. Yay! There was no acknowledgement of our anniversary on the phone, or even when we arrived. No gift, no coupon, not even a "happy anniversary" from the person working the front desk. Disappointing start.
We had drinks and dinner in the bar. Online it shows tacos & tequila on Tuesdays, and there is a happy hour menu. We were there during happy hour and it was a Tuesday. Neither of these things were mentioned to us, and when I asked our server, she had absolutely no idea what I was talking about. She said happy hour is for the outdoor restaurant. Weird. I asked the front desk person and he said both should be available. The bartender cleared this up for us (kind of). I was under the assumption that the tacos and tequila menu was a good deal. The bartender suggested a tequila to us so we got two margaritas. They were in the smallest glasses and we found out when we got the bill that they were $17 a piece. What? We would not have ordered those... the bill was incorrect and confusing but they took some money off to make up for it. At least the cheese curds were good!
Our room was gorgeous and clean. Room cleaning services walked right into our room without knocking at 7am so that was annoying. Other than that, no complaints about the room itself.
The absolute worst part of this stay was the room service breakfast we ordered. It was appalling. I cannot believe they served us that food. We ordered two mimosas, biscuit and gravy, a side of bacon, and chicken and waffles. The total was $120 with tip (ouch). We were really hungry and looking forward to this since it took over an hour.
The biscuit and gravy included one biscuit (if you can call it that) which was burnt. There was minimal gravy and then a bunch of scrambled eggs thrown on top. The chicken and waffles came with an over easy egg. This was really confusing. It's not mentioned on the menu, and I was not asked how I'd like the egg to be cooked. My husband hates runny eggs. Not only was this random egg splattered all over his meal, IT WASN'T FULLY COOKED. Actual egg yolk membrane was on this plate. The bacon was the only edible portion of this meal. The mimosas were good, but not for $16 a piece. I called the front desk to talk about how disgusting the food was. He credited us half of the meal. We essentially paid $60 for two mimosas and bacon. I guess giving your guests salmonella isn't worth a full refund.
We will not be spending future anniversaries at the Iron Horse. This really bums me out because we loved the idea of that tradition. I'm not sure what is going on over there, but it's not worth your money. My husband and I will check out the Pfister next year and pretend that's where we stayed after our wedding.