Nate (Nate T.
Google
⭐☆☆☆☆ Disappointed, But Hopefully Just Bad Timing
My wife and I were visiting the Outer Banks and were on the hunt for some amazing seafood. After doing some searching, we came across Kill Devil Grill, and we were genuinely excited. The online reviews, photos of the food, and the overall atmosphere looked exactly like what we were hoping for during our trip.
Unfortunately, when we arrived, the parking lot was completely empty, all the lights were off, and there was a sign posted stating “Last Day: Dec 20.” This was confusing because online listings indicated the restaurant was still open. We weren’t sure if December 20 was the last day for the season, the year, or if the closure was indefinite—but either way, it was a big letdown.
We also weren’t the only ones caught off guard. While we sat in the parking lot looking for another option, at least 20–30 other vehicles pulled in. Several people got out to check the doors, all with the same confused and disappointed reaction. Clearly, many visitors were relying on the same online information we were.
After a quick search, we found Barefoot Bernie’s Tropical Grill & Bar, which showed as open online—and thankfully, it actually was. They ended up delivering exactly what we were looking for and saved our seafood craving that day.
That said, we truly wish Kill Devil Grill had been open. Based on everything we saw online, it looks like a fantastic place and possibly even better than the alternatives we found. Hopefully this was just a timing or seasonal issue. If it’s open on a future visit, we’d absolutely give it another shot and provide a proper food-and-service review.
For now, due to inaccurate availability information and the closure, this visit earns one star—not for the quality of the restaurant itself, but simply because inaccurate information of it being open and that we never got the chance to experience it.
Hopefully next time.