Pamela A.
Yelp
My husband is far more a sandwich person than I, but a friend mentioning mufalettas made us seek them out. We unfortunately aren't close to Matthews - the downtown is one of the Charlotte area's best features - but mid-afternoon on a Saturday we made a little road trip across town to The Loyalist Market, whose mufaletta is well considered.
Glad we did.
This small deli/bistro is a gem of a find, with its locally sourced ingredients and its uncomplicated, inviting interior. Looks like a good place to settle in with friends for some wine and conversation. My husband of course opted for the mufaletta, while I succumbed to my gastronomic Achilles' heel: cheese boards. I asked our server, whom I suspect was manager and/or owner, to surprise me, and she exceeded all expectations.
I've had a lifelong addiction to cheese. I could live on bread, cheese and fruit, with occasional crunchy veggies. What was delivered to me were a trio of artisan cheeses and brilliantly paired accoutrements, along with five or so toast points. Let me tell you, our server, whoever she was, knew her cheeses. The first was a manchego-like Spanish hard cheese, the second a washed rind cheese from Virginia, and the third a soft-ripened local creamy offering. Each was delicious and different, with my favorite the Grayson from Virginia. Matched with pickled cauliflower, its complex flavors were sublime.
The mufaletta was...good, solid, I would say, but not entirely accurate to the sandwich's origins. The bread, though excellent, was not mufaletta bread and the contents were a tad less generous than one traditionally finds in this dish. The olive salad was wonderful but, alas, also fairly lightly applied. It was perfectly acceptable as a sandwich but was more an homage to a mufaletta than an actual mufaletta.
The prices are a little upscale, which is to be expected with the care in local sourcing, and the portions a little downscaled. All in all, though, I give this place high marks for its honest approach to offering good food, supporting local growers and its welcoming atmosphere. I'm looking forward to returning.